wilburt – Member
Best HW boxer in my lifetime by some distance is Evander Holyfield
Hmm. I’ve always had question marks over Holyfield. No doubt a great boxer, but I think his heavyweight record flatters to deceive.
Won the HW title from Buster Douglas who was crap in reality, with the exception of the once in a lifetime performance against Tyson and the circumstances around that fight
Beat an ancient Foreman
Beat an ancient Holmes
Lost to Michael Moorer, who then went on to lose to Foreman!
Beat the shell of Tyson and all the nonsense there
Lost to Lewis twice (despite what the judges said in the 1st fight)
Lost to Ruiz, one of the worst heavyweight champions I’ve ever seen
Pissed away his legacy by carrying on far too long and taking beatings from very poor fighters
Then on top of that he was roided off his head (“evan field” scandal)
Exciting fighter, and the Bowe trilogy was great, but not a great heavyweight in his own era (“peak” Tyson would have dispatched him, Lewis beat him twice, Bowe beat him twice)