to be fair, if I was an enduro bro, I’d be happier with them on my bike. My bikes are steel hardtails or rigid, and I don’t ride with pads, so it’d look a bit odd riding with handguards, especially with gorse and bramble scratches over my unprotected calves and forearms!
That’s interesting actually, I would argue that on the right hard tail, they’d look fine. Seems like they’re a marmite option for most riders in spite of seemingly having a genuine functional benefit. Such is the way in MTB..
For me its definitely the hands that are the issue- I’ve had the odd infected splinter from a trail brush with scrub and whilst not a huge issue, it’s a bummer and can be painful.