Are Hope Pro 2's comparible to XT? (not wishing to sound like such a dumb-ass)
Pro II hubs are quite expensive compared to Shimano XT, but the free hub is a lot simpler and is easy to pull apart and clean (making sure there is no water in there for winter), where the shimano unit is sealed so you use it till it fails then replace the freehub. If you get water in the shimano unit it is quite difficult to get it out.
I've had XT free hubs freeze several times before, even quite new ones. I've never had a Hope hub freeze in over 4 years of using them in all weathers (none of this staying indoors in cold weather).
I think the design of the hope freehubs is quite difficult to 'freeze up' as I only rarely service them and they always have moisture in there after a few months riding (I hose the bike off nearly every ride in winter and the sealing on the hope hubs is not great) and no problemns with freezing.
Now problems with snapping pawl springs in Pro II hubs is a different matter altogether.