Remarkable… five years or so ago all you would have heard on a thread similar to this would have been something like ‘they’re rubbish, simply don’t bother’.
Has this forum got a bit more reasonable of late?
As an avid Egg Beater user of 10 years or so, I can recommend them. The new generation design seems fairly bomb-proof and has dealt with a lot of problems the old ones had.
Nevertheless, I’m still running eight sets of the old design on my other bikes and they seem to work okay with a bit of TLC now and again. The lose springs / wobbly wings thing can be solved by taking the entire pedal mechanism apart and bending the spring tabs slightly – to force tension in the spring. This seems to need doing about once every 6 months’ riding. With practice I can do this in about 15 minutes on both pedals now when necessary.
To me, I like the way these pedals feel to clip into and pedal on. I also find they just look good, in a nicely descrete minimal way. Things like big, heavy SPDs, or those grey plastic Time things are simply too damn fugly to my eye.
I’m always looking for spare pairs though… how much for the ‘Beaters above? 😉