All waterproof jackets have flaws.
Agreed.
For me, the hassle of tending to eVent is nothing compared to the improved breathability. Hell, unlike Gore, it actually breathes, even when it’s wet! (After all, when it’s pissing down and your jacket is done up to the neck, that’s when breathability is more important, and that’s exactly where Gore falls down).
It’s a shame that so many people just assume that GoreTex = waterproof/breathable, and that’s Gore’s attitude to market protection precludes anyone making gear in multiple fabrics across their ranges. See also Lowe’s long defunct, but excellent, Triple Point Ceramic.
Waterproof? Breathable? A bin bag is waterproof. Pertex is superbly breathable, and windproof and a real favourite of mine. eVent strikes the best balance of both for me.