Aero Factory Vs Handbuilt… Soon to be the new “what tyres” thread? 😉
Some people will tell you it’s got to be aero, some people will say handbuilts every time. But I’d think about what riding you do first before anything else.
How often do you ride your road bike? When you go out is it for 30-40 fast miles at a good average speed, or is it for hours and hours covering larger distances but at a more relaxed pace? Have you got a head down, arse up race rep bike that’s as stiff as a very stiff thing and you like it like that, or do you have a “Sportive” geometry frame with a longer head tube and more forgiving back end?
Remember aero really only starts to make much difference as you’re approaching and exceeding 20mph, so if you’re spending almost all your time below this speed then I wouldn’t worry about an aero rim… Also, it’s not just overall wheel weight you need to look at, aero profile ally rims are quite a bit heavier than non aero and though they might not be any heavier as a wheelset, they may be built on lightweight hubs, and hub weight isn’t really an issue in the grand scheme of things. Certainly a good handbuilt on a lightweight rim will accelerate faster than a deep section aero (hence also be better for climbing)…
You pays yer money and takes yer choice as they say!