Magic Mary 2.35 Trail Star lasts ages in my experience, used to be £30 all the time for the proper top end one (not the Super Gravity 1045g) but the 795g trail version. Now though… they have this new new Addix thing and they’re super expensive £58 each.
Then again I paid £49 for a Minion DHF 3C when I couldn’t find stock (they’re £41 ATM) so they’ve all gone up in price. The DHR II 3C is always £49 too because nobody stocks it except NextDay tyres. The Minion SS I got recently was £41.
All my Schwalbe 2.35s come up wider than the 2.3 Maxxis on 25mm internal width.
I’ve not tried the 2.5 Maxxis because they’re not TR. Dunno if that matters. Quite fancy a DHF 2.5 SuperTacky to try for winter up front if it’ll go up Tubeless reliably without being a TR?
Wouldn’t touch any Continentals. I have some top of the range 2.4 PT BC MK2 and XK… zero grip, dangerous things the lot of them. Big volume yes. Useful on a MTB… nope. One friend thinks it’s because I’m 25kg lighter than him that Continetnals don’t work for me. Gravity eh!