- This topic has 25 replies, 20 voices, and was last updated 12 years ago by fivespot.
-
10 speed worth the effort??
-
jumpupanddownFree MemberPosted 12 years ago
is it worth the almost £500 it will cost to make my bike 10 speed..
jumpupanddownFree MemberPosted 12 years agoi want a higher gear so i can go up any thing, want to run 22 36 any way of doing this with 9 speed?
greebleFree MemberPosted 12 years agopersonally if I was building a new build and looking for new drivechain yes go 10speed.
I’m currently running 1×9 32 front 12-32t rear and have zero problems with getting up steep stuff
my brother runs 1×10 34 front 11-34 rear. and I can’t tell the diffence.jamesFree MemberPosted 12 years ago22T front ring and a Deore 12-36T casette is possible, though most rear mechs are designed to run upto a 34T casette sprocket though? Depends how far the B tension screw goes on yours, how big/worn jockey wheels are and how much you mind a jockey wheel/casette ‘buzz’ in bottom gear ..
Middleburn also offer 40/30/20T rings, but I believe are only available for 5 bolt crankarms. I’m not familiar with 5bolt, but I know middleburn crankarms will fit for one
20:36 would be about another gear lower than 22:34jamesFree MemberPosted 12 years ago“22 front, 36 rear?
It would be quicker to walk up”Depends how fast you spin?
If its a pedal mashingly slow speed/cadence your at then likely yes, but manically spinning up rubble/etc IME I’d say notThough you’ve got to factor in the extra slowness of getting off/on the bike if you’re not going to ride you bike on the bike ride that you’re apparantly undertaking
deanfbmFree MemberPosted 12 years agoIs there anything you’re not getting up with your current gear?
Even if you’re on 22/34 (0.647) now, 22/36 (0.611) will only be 5% “easier”. That would make zero tangible difference.
The real advantages for 10 speed is that you can drop down to double or going further, dropping down to a single ring.
Or for roadies or serious XCers, maintains a more consistent cadence.
jumpupanddownFree MemberPosted 12 years agoI over taken loads of people pushing bikes going up the other side of Jacobs ladder in granny gear. Its faster to ride, ive tried it both ways just to see, its more fun to ride any way develop youre trail skills.
speaker2animalsFull MemberPosted 12 years agoHow long will it take you to earn the £500? If you can fork it out and still do all the other spending that you do in a month then probably yes. If it takes you 12 months to save it and you have to cut out other things to do so, I’d say no.
If you are bunging it on a credit card, I’d have a look at the current economic climate and have a serious think about it.
jumpupanddownFree MemberPosted 12 years agoEven if you’re on 22/34 (0.647) now, 22/36 (0.611) will only be 5% “easier”. That would make zero tangible difference.
i once almost killed my self riding all the way up a big hill only to stall 0.5 meters from the top…its would have made all the difference.. 🙂
thomthumbFree MemberPosted 12 years agoi want a higher gear so i can go up any thing, want to run 22 36 any way of doing this with 9 speed?
hth
jumpupanddownFree MemberPosted 12 years agoHow long will it take you to earn the £500? If you can fork it out and still do all the other spending that you do in a month then probably yes. If it takes you 12 months to save it and you have to cut out other things to do so, I’d say no.
If you are bunging it on a credit card, I’d have a look at the current economic climate and have a serious think about it.
was going to spend my first ever bonus on it.. just to celebrate having my first ever real job.
MostlyBalancedFree MemberPosted 12 years agowas going to spend my first ever bonus on it.. just to celebrate having my first ever real job.
£500 would go a long way towards giving you your first real holiday.
bruneepFull MemberPosted 12 years agoBonus?
How do you come to the £500 price, bought a XT groupset from actionsports.de for about £300.
jumpupanddownFree MemberPosted 12 years agoHow do you come to the £500 price, bought a XT groupset from actionsports.de for about £300.
xtr levers xrt brake levers, xt casset, xtr rear mech, xt chain, cables… about 500 quid:(
rwc03Free MemberPosted 12 years agoAgree with bruneep, if you shop around you can go 10 speed for less than that. Got xt with the fancy new xtr rear mech for £350 from rosebikes and using crc vouchers.
Edit: with the brakes that is £500
cookeaaFull MemberPosted 12 years agoThe Simple answer is Yes you can assemble an 11-36t 9 speed cassette, most easily by changing the bottom 12t sprocket on an HG-61 for an 11t…
But I’m not sure there is that much advantage in doing this, you could just opt for an 11-34 – 9speed off the shelf cassette and “Nut up” for the lack of 2 teeth…
My own current lowest available ratio is 30-22 at the minute about 19 “Gear inches” That gets used very infrequently and TBH is probably a bit too “spinney” – 36-22 would come out a shade under 15.9 and 34-22 works out at 16.8 the gains would be minimal…
Perhaps your easiest, short term option is to get an 11-34 9 speed cassette just to try having a broad range cassette and see how you get on with it…
Don’t get too caught up with the idea of having 10spd kit on your bike, it’s just the latest gimick all the old 5/6/7/8/9spd kit hasn’t suddenly ceased to function.
There are far better things you can do with your Bonus….
momoFull MemberPosted 12 years agoI made the change back in the summer from 1×9 (32/11-32) to 1×10 (34/11-36). I think it’s an improvement, better gear range for me and the shift seems to be better too. Cost me about £250 for XT chain, mech and cassette, single XTR shifter and a renthal chainring.
The mech and shifter I have removed, along with the old chainring have gone into the spares box and will be used when I build my second bike up next year (I have a full bikes worth of parts knocking around in the garage) and the cassette and chain were goosed anyway, so were due to be changed.
Personally I wouldn’t take perfectly good 9spd parts off a bike to fit 10spd, the difference isn’t that profound, however if your drivetrain is pretty worn, then it’s a worthwhile upgrade.
skywalkerFree MemberPosted 12 years agoYou can get this years 10 speed XT group set for 379.90 Euros, or last years for 299 Euros
DanWFree MemberPosted 12 years agoIn summary:
1) 10spd isn’t worth it for an easier gear- smoother cadence, yes, going double up front, yes.
2) 22-36 is daft be it 9 or 10 spd. It isn’t so different from 22-34 which is itself far too easy a gear. Climbing on any surface that is vaguely loose will result in loss of traction or climbing anything vaguely steep and technical will most likely have the front lifting. Granted these effects can be reduced by various means but 22-32 or preferably 22-28 should be practical for most people.Just my 2 cents to reiterate what other have already said 😀
stevepitchFree MemberPosted 12 years agoWow and I thought I spent a lot going 1×10 at £120 notes saying that I dont think the wife would let me spend xtr money 🙁
thisisnotaspoonFree MemberPosted 12 years agoWell it ‘cost’ me £110 for X7 shifters, X9 mech, chain and 1050 cassette (i think, its aluminium bodied?) casette.
I say ‘cost’ as the chan and cassette needed replacing as the cassette was a OEM one and weighed a ton, so the upgrade wasnt all that, and the original went on my winter bike for occasional rides.
Is it any better?
36t sprocket is usefull, but I’m no faster than I was. And I prefered the clunkyness of the older SRAM shiting, the new ones are much smoother.
snowpaulFree MemberPosted 12 years agoI love low gears – tried riding up cadair idris or most of snowdon / helvellyn / high street without a granny? I would love a 22 x 36….
I would stick with 9spd untill its worn out then upgrade to narrower chains and 10 spd which does wear out quicker than 9 spd in my experience ( thats on the road bike though )
rottenFree MemberPosted 12 years agoLove my 22×36 gear, also love riding big mountains and after 6hrs riding this ratio gets used a lot. On super steep climbs I would be quicker walking but I’m on a bike ride not a walk.
fivespotFree MemberPosted 12 years agoCost me less than £200 to go 1×10…. XTR Shifter, XT Shadow mech, XT 11-36 Cassette, Sram 1050 chain, Middleburn chainring, ( with a bit of carefully researched bargain hunting ) and got almost half of that back by selling my old XT shifters, mechs and cassette. Plus saved over 1/2 pound in weight 8)
The topic ‘10 speed worth the effort??’ is closed to new replies.
