I’m lucky enough (er..depending on your opinion!) to have a 2010 Five and Trek EX8. Also had a couple of decent off-road demo rides on Alu & Carbon Remedy’s.
The carbon Remedy was very nice, but at £5k, I guess it should be!
However, if I was forced to choose between the Five and an Alu EX or Remedy, I’d go with the Five every time. TBH, my jury is still out on the looks of the Five (tho I reckon white is a good colour for them), but lets face it, when you’re hooning along a nice bit of singletrack on any decent bike, are you really gonna give a flyin’ fig what ot looks like?
p.s. good move getting the household used to a bike being kept indoors 🙂 My newest bikes have lived in the dining room for years, but now I’ve got a decent dry & secure workshop, they live in there, apart from when the in-laws visit, when one of ’em gets brought back in – just love the look on the mother in laws face 😉