I killed a 2.3 eliminator grid on its first ride. Hit a rock and got a big hole plus a cut at the bead I couldn’t fix.
I’ve had no such problems with butchers and purgatorys
I did exactly the same but with the 2.6. Ran previously a 2.6 butcher on the same trails for a year with no issues.
Plus the eliminator is much smaller (both in width and volume)than the equivalent butcher which measures up a true 2.6 on 35mm rims. I’m firmly back on the butchers on the rear. Just grid with a tyre insert, although I do have a black diamond version I’m yet to try it, but the extra heft it will prob be without the insert.