I think they iz great.
I have never noticed them changing, which I suppose is a good thing. I suppose it's about the same timescale as your eyes adjusting, so it seems to work out nicely with what your brain's expecting to happen. I have not used a pair in the height of summer yet, so I suppose most effects have been subtle. Oh, tell a lie – I used them on the Builth, and the current sunlight is fairly close to its maximum – and still did not notice anything happening.
They do work though – I got a speck of mud on them and when I wiped it off there was a pale spot – I thought for a minute I'd wiped off some kind of coating, but of course it was dark behind the mud speck…
They are meant to go as dark as black iridium.. so I shall see how well they cope with full desert sun in 5 weeks' time.
Would never buy non-transition lenses I don't think – no reason not to.