Dave, I own all your books and have enjoyed all of them with one exception.
The issue I had with your writing in this was sentences like “after 3 months rider x had ridden some 5000 miles, which was some 1200 miles more than the previous record but some 600 miles fewer than rider y”. It was so irritating to read the repetition of “some” all the time and it made reading the book a real trial.
I appreciate the massive effort of research that went into it, and it is of course entirely between you and your publisher when you publish. However getting into the final chapter and reading about the preparation of the two new rival attempts before just ending it 6 months into their attempts just made me angry – hence my review. Either see the year out, or end the book by saying that after 40 years there is new interest in the record and 2 serious attempts have been announced for next year. Don’t just leave me hanging.
I’m sorry you didn’t like the review. I very rarely review books, but I was really disappointed and frustrated reading it. Clearly from the reviews others think differently. But just putting a lot of effort into something does not entitle you to glowing reviews, and if you put the fruits of your labour into the public domain and charge for it, you must expect people to have opinions on your work, not all of which will be positive.