Home › Forums › Chat Forum › Jeremy Corbyn
- This topic has 21,376 replies, 172 voices, and was last updated 1 year ago by ernielynch.
-
Jeremy Corbyn
-
ransosFree Member
Anyone who reads that as ‘comparing Israel to ISIS’ needs to work on their comprehension skills. Weak as ****.
We all know that there was nothing factually incorrect about his statement. Equally, it was an incredibly stupid thing to say, as the reaction to it was entirely predictable.
dazhFull MemberIt’s getting beyond a joke now. Eagle has supposedly postponed her leadership challenge (as we’re all waiting with baited breath), because ‘today is for the tories’. Do they coordinate their incompetence? I’ve got an image in my head of tory and labour spin doctors sending back-channel emails to each other to arrange which days they would like f*** up on.
Where are the libdems in all this f***wittery? I really think Tim Farron should be chipping in with a sex scandal or two.
martinhutchFull MemberHe’s frantically ringing the other two MPs to organise a leadership challenge.
jambalayaFree MemberFar from calming the situation around anti-semitism Corbyn has inflamed it with his remarks today prompting one Labour councillor present to demand he resign immediately and another Jewish MP has left in tears after being attacked and abused by a member of Momentum
Corbyn is not stupid this was a deliberate attempt to raise the termperature comparing Israel to Islamic State, something his anti-semitic followers and supporters inside and outside the Labour Party will have been delighted with I am sure
jambalayaFree MemberStatement from the Jewish Labour MP
The MP called for Mr Corbyn to resign after the incident, saying he failed to intervene.
“Until today I had made no public comment about Jeremy’s ability to lead our party, but the fact that he failed to intervene is final proof for me that he is unfit to lead, and that a Labour Party under his stewardship cannot be a safe space for British Jews,” Ms Smeeth added.
bongohoohaaFree Memberprompting one Labour councillor present to demand he resign immediately
I would imagine at any one time there is a Labour councillor demanding he resigns.
Corbyn is not stupid this was a deliberate attempt to raise the termperature comparing Israel to Islamic State, something his anti-semitic followers and supporters inside and outside the Labour Party will have been delighted with I am sure
wwaswasFull Membervideo and text evidence confirms tweets attributing Islamic State reference to @jeremycorbyn were misquotes….
be interesting who was first to attribute it to him and why…
chakapingFull MemberJust read the actual quote, masterful bit of trolling by Jez.
Our Jewish friends are no more responsible for the actions of Israel or the Netanyahu government than our Muslim friends are for those of various self-styled Islamic states or organisations.”
Zing!
ernie_lynchFree Memberransos – Member
“Anyone who reads that as ‘comparing Israel to ISIS’ needs to work on their comprehension skills. Weak as ****.”
We all know that there was nothing factually incorrect about his statement. Equally, it was an incredibly stupid thing to say, as the reaction to it was entirely predictable.
Well you’ve hit the nail on the head there. Corbyn is not a politician as we know politicians to be.
A senior politician, as we know them, would have had a team of advisors to carefully look at his prepared speech to see if it contained any potential hazards, like this obvious one.
The Tories, the Blairites, the media, are out to get Corbyn, they scrutinize every single word he utters to try and trip him up. As you say, this was entirely predictable.
But Corbyn speaks like a normal person, a normal functioning human being, the sort of person you meet normal life, not as a manufactured politician.
His supporters say that is Corbyn’s appeal – he is a normal person not a typical politician which voters have grown to dislike, distrust, and been put off by.
His critics say he’s not a proper politician and lacks the skills to be one, as this latest incident shows.
The question is who will the voters back? Corbyn’s critics say not someone who they describe as “decent and honest” but someone more like those who voters have grown to dislike and distrust.
I suspect that his critics might be right, although I am very far from convinced. However this is a moot point as the overwhelming majority of the Labour Party has clearly made their decision, ie, to try a different approach.
highlandmanFree MemberSincere apologies if this has been done already as I cannot face the bile overload of checking every page.
Meanwhile, Chilcot is waiting in the wings.
Tony Blair’s peace camp are stirring against Corbyn in order to attempt to deflect attention away from the absolute s***storm heading Blair’s way next week…ransosFree MemberA senior politician, as we know them, would have had a team of advisors to carefully look at his prepared speech to see if it contained any potential hazards, like this obvious one.
The Tories, the Blairites, the media, are out to get Corbyn, they scrutinize every single word he utters to try and trip him up. As you say, this was entirely predictable.
But Corbyn speaks like a normal person, a normal functioning human being, the sort of person you meet normal life, not as a manufactured politician.
Yes, but it looked as if Corbyn was reading from prepared remarks…
dazhFull MemberBut Corbyn speaks like a normal person, a normal functioning human being, the sort of person you meet normal life, not as a manufactured politician.
I just don’t buy this. Yes it’s refreshing to have someone who isn’t a PR-moulded soundbite-bot. But he is still a politician. Being careful about what you say is hardly a new thing. Given that he has been under huge pressure on the anti-semitism issue, even if it is an invention of the media, his remarks were frankly idiotic, and if it wasn’t for the fact that he has few friends already, he should have sacked his advisors and speech writers on the spot.
5thElefantFree MemberNo normal person would depict Israel and IS as equivalents at a meeting about anti-semitism.
chakapingFull MemberI suspect that his critics might be right, although I am very far from convinced. However this is a moot point as the overwhelming majority of the Labour Party has clearly made their decision, ie, to try a different approach.
I hear you Ernie. I am really torn on the subject of Corbyn.
I have a lot of respect for him and its great to see a proper socialist at the forefront of UK politics, even if I think he failed to get the message across that it was socialist reforms like the welfare state which formed the foundation of the “golden era” that Leave voters were pining for.
I’ve always thought he’d be a transitional figure, heralding a rebalancing of Labour policy leftwards – but probably not that far left.
Yes his critics probably are right that he won’t win a general election, but the knives have been out for him from day one and he doesn’t appear to have ever had the support of much of the PLP.
And the manner of this botched coup leaves a really nasty taste in the mouth and makes those involved look amateur and unprincipled. There doesn’t seem to be any real plan for the way forward.
So while I sadly don’t see him becoming PM, I can’t support efforts to get rid of him like this.
dazhFull MemberMassively stupid! But he wasn’t saying they were equivalent.
Doesn’t matter, all that matters is that his detractors can portray him as having said it. Politics 101.
ninfanFree MemberI think it must be utter f***ing genius
On the one day when the biggest and most dominant story in the news is the utter cat fight of Tory backstabbing and greasy pole climbing, Probably only the second day in the past six months where the combined negative Labour stories of anti-semitism and Corbyns car-crash leadership could have fallen off the news radar to be replaced by Tory infighting.
Corbyn manages to get himself on the six o’clock news with Labour slagging off the Jews again.
That surely takes a special sort of utter evil genius?
ctkFull MemberMaybe just making sure the ball is in the PLPs court? 🙂
“if I’m so bad challenge me”
teamhurtmoreFree MemberHe’s a man of principle and conviction ninfan – timing and political expediency dont come into the equation 😉
But correct – its breathtaking!! Or at best, breathtakingly clumsy language, especially after his comments/assessment of Livingston.
Cant help themselves these guys can they….
clodhopperFree Member“Corbyn manages to get himself on the six o’clock news with Labour slagging off the Jews again.”
Well well well; someone lying to attempt to defame Corbyn. What a surprise.
“That surely takes a special sort of utter evil genius?”
it certainly takes a special sort of idiocy to even attempt to suggest that Labour are ‘slagging off the Jews again’. When nothingof the sort has actually happened.
What has actually happened, is that Corbyn said this:
“To assume that a Jewish friend or fellow member is wealthy, some kind of financial or media conspiracy, or takes a particular position on politics in general or on Israel and on Palestine in particular, is just wrong.
“Our Jewish friends are no more responsible for the actions of Israel or the Netanyahu government than our Muslim friends are for those various self-styled Islamic States or organisations.”Quite how you can twist this into ‘Labour slagging off the Jews again’ is just incredible. Utterly desperate.
Maybe you just wanted to invoke a special kind of vile, bitter, hateful invective against Corbyn. Maybe you just wanted to make yourself look utterly ridiculous. Either way, I hope you’ll come to realise the stupidity of your comments, and at least admit it to yourself.
nickjbFree MemberWell said clodhopper. Much better put than I started to write before deciding not to get dragged in.
MrWoppitFree Memberutter cat fight of Tory backstabbing and greasy pole climbing
It must help take the sting off the sight of the People’s Party engaged in self-immolation, but the tendency to think that anything similar is going on across the aisle is just silly.
It’s not a “cat fight”. The Conservatives are not “tearing themselves apart”.
The contenders are maneuvering, side-stepping, engaging in sleight of hand and doing deals with each other behind closed doors (except, I suspect, Theresa May).
It’s a leadership contest. That’s what happens. When the Labour Pains get around to it, it will be no different.
ninfanFree Membercertainly takes a special sort of idiocy to even attempt to suggest that Labour are ‘slagging off the Jews again’. When nothingof the sort has actually happened.
Ruth Smeeth MP doesn’t appear to agree with you:
“This morning, at the launch of the Chakrabarti Inquiry into antisemitism, I was verbally attacked by a Momentum activist and Jeremy Corbyn supporter who used traditional antisemitic slurs to attack me for being part of a ‘media conspiracy’. It is beyond belief that someone could come to the launch of a report on antisemitism in the Labour Party and espouse such vile conspiracy theories about Jewish people.
nickjbFree MemberRuth Smeeth MP doesn’t appear to agree with you:
Have you posted the right quote? It doesn’t seem to support your point.
MrWoppitFree MemberIt is beyond belief that someone could come to the launch of a report on antisemitism in the Labour Party and espouse such vile conspiracy theories about Jewish people.
Bless.
clodhopperFree MemberHow is that ‘Labour slagging off the Jews again’? It’s one individual. The man who accused her of colluding with the media claims he did not know she was Jewish. So it really, really isn’t a case of ‘Labour slagging off the Jews’. As much as you so really desperately need it to be. Sorry to piss on your chips.
ninfanFree MemberSo it really, really isn’t a case of ‘Labour slagging off the Jews’. As much as you so really desperately need it to be. Sorry to piss on your chips.
Lets sit back and see whose version of events the mainstream media end up portraying…. 😆
molgripsFree Memberwho used traditional antisemitic slurs to attack me for being part of a ‘media conspiracy’.
Good God 😯
JunkyardFree MemberQuite how you can twist this into ‘Labour slagging off the Jews again’ is just incredible. Utterly desperate.
+ a lot
To assume that a STW friend or fellow member is wealthy, some kind of financial or media conspiracy, or takes a particular position on politics in general or on Israel and on Palestine in particular, is just wrong.
“Our STW friends are no more responsible for the actions of the cylcing industry than our Muslim friends are for those various self-styled Islamic States or organisations.”Its a monstrously preposterous view to claim that post just slagged of STW
JunkyardFree MemberLets sit back and see whose version of events the mainstream media end up portraying
The RW press will report the RW one just as flies circle shit
It wont make it correct, just or decent…have you given up so quickly trying to argue the preposterous – Smiley here for dramatice affect
molgripsFree MemberCalling anti-Corbynites part of a media conspiracy is not an anti-semitic insult!
5thElefantFree MemberLets sit back and see whose version of events the mainstream media end up portraying….
whatnobeerFree MemberToo many JambaFacts in the last 2 pages to quote them all, but this is the first one I came across. Re the SNP:
Had we voted Remain they would have pushed for the same thing
I guess this isn’t as bad as the rest, because stating the SNP want another referendum isn’t exactly untrue but to suggest they’d be pushing for another referendum because of a Remain vote seems pretty far fetched.
julianwilsonFree Member13000 people have joined the Labour Party in recent days. How terribly confusing.
NorthwindFull Member5thElefant – Member
No normal person would depict Israel and IS as equivalents at a meeting about anti-semitism.
And neither did he. Obviously.
5thElefantFree MemberAnd neither did he. Obviously.
The chief rabbi thought he did.
But sure, he could just be an idiot rather than anti-Semitic.
chakapingFull MemberIf you think he insulted Jews as a people then you must also think he accused all Muslims of supporting Isis.
So you think that?
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.