Experience timeline
Thule roof bars and bikes on the roof: strong crosswind and it failed. Bike hanging off teh side of teh car.
Rear hatch rack: Thule Clip On High. Excellent and super secure. Wont work with a roof spoiler. Needs pain protection on the top of the tailgate. Fast and easy to use, no multiple straps to adjust or fall off.
Thule towbar Velospace XT2. Why didn’t I do this sooner. Fits all bikes, no axle rubbing. Safe, takes ebikes through to fatbikes. Often come up on FB marketplace or ebay small stuff.