[Closed] WATCHMEN what was that all about?

I like it, it's not your normal run of the mill superhero film and has a story. Did you some how miss it?

Watched it in the cinema with a mate who'd read the comic books (I hadn't) he left with a gleeful smile on his face, I left bemused look and a little bit sleepy.

[url= http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%3F ]Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?[/url]

Who watches the watchmen?
If power corrupts, does absolute power corrupt absolutely?

Not seen the film yet, but the book is brilliant.

alan moore knows the score

I agree with Drac good film actually with a storyline.

One of the few "superhero" films where I actually want to know what happened at the end cos I just wasnt sure what was going to happen.

One of the worst films I've ever seen 2 1/2 hours of my life I'll never get back

Like most of Moore's output it's better as a graphic novel than as a film

Brilliant book. And thought the film was a very good version of it.

IMO one of the most spectacular movies of the last few years. I read the graphic novel first, and the movie does a great job of translating, which is probably it's biggest downfall. What works well in a graphic novel can seem long and meandering on the screen.

ps. it's not often a major hollywood blockbuster contains a bright blue character who spends most of the movie with his big blue willy swinging free. Certainly make my girlfriend laugh when we saw it at the cinema.

And one of the coolest characters ever.

[img] [/img]

Hadn't read the book/magazine before I watched it, thought the film was very very good. Would happily watch it again.

Love the comic book, really enjoyed the film too. I have watched it a few times now. I can see how it might not be for everyone though

Watch Mark Kermode's review, I think he sums it up well.

Somehow the plot got lost in too much story or something. I hadn't read the book and found it rather too long and hard work to follow which is a shame because I thik an intelligent superhero film would be great.

[i]Like most of Moore's output it's better as a graphic novel than as a film [/i]
Agreed. The author himself thinks it's impossible to make films from his books.

[url= http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/mar/16/alan-moore-watchmen-lost-girls ]His take on the matter.[/url]

ot: saw a mint first edition of [i]Lost Girls[/i] in a book shop in Geneva - eu700, [u]guide[/u] price!

Somehow the plot got lost in too much story or something. I hadn't read the book and found it rather too long and hard work to follow which is a shame because I thik an intelligent superhero film would be great

Totally disagree with this thought it was one of the few films were there has been a storyline though the whole thing and was really interesting to know what actually was happening at the end.

I liked the book and the comics but struggled with the film. I bought the DVD thinking it would be awesome. Ho hum.
I think some stories don't translate well to film, this is one of them.

Too many overlapping storylines for you?

A great film that is nearly as good as the book. Then again, I liked Sin City for the same reason and V for Vendetta as I read the comics as a kid. Far more to them than the average Hollywood no-brainer.

ground floor. comin' up

Excellent soundtrack too

I'm about 1/2 way through the book and will watch the film after
my first foray into [s]cartoon[/s] graphic novels and it's a bit weird but I'm enjoying it

The book is fantastic.

The film is good, but most of the good stuff is because it stays very true to the book (mostly). I think the film fails by ratcheting up the graphic violence, which just seemed to be there so Zack Snyder could say that he'd made a proper adaptation of the book.

I love the credit sequence montage , with "the times they are a changing'" in the background. And the prison breakout sequence is superb. Im not really clear how a better job could have been made of adapting the comic.

I crackingly good comic superhero movie with an actual story.

However, those of you raised on a diet of typical hollywood 'sound-bite' action movies may have trouble concentrating long enough to pick the story up.

😈

Is it not super-violent?

I love a lots action films and graphic novels and actions hero films...I found it rather dull too, very predictable. But it's good you guys who did like it encourage to the movie producers to produce the same old same old while pretending it's something 'new.'
When was an action hero film really different? But then again, how can they really be different when they're dealing with ideas/stereotype images that have been around since the ancient times...

far too much blue cock!

When was a[s]n action hero[/s] film really different? But then again, how can they really be different when they're dealing with ideas/stereotype images that have been around since the ancient times...

There that's better.

far too much blue cock!