Forum search & shortcuts

Is it ethical to ma...
 

[Closed] Is it ethical to make large sums of money out of people when it comes to health?

Posts: 129
Free Member
 

meeeeee

Have I read that right? Are you seriously saying that you get paid the same for 1 treatment ie. 1 filling, as you do for someone who needs 10 ?

If so, you really need to get someone to represent your professional body properly re fee negotiation.

I would respectfully suggest the same guys who negotiated the GP contract to be top of the list 😉


 
Posted : 16/06/2010 10:11 am
 tron
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Do you not read the papers? There's been a big ruckus since the new charging system came in. And I'm not a dentist, or even someone who goes to one that regularly!

I can see some of the point - there are some economies of scale, only mixing one batch of amalgam etc, only one meeting with the receptionist, pleasantries, getting them strapped down to the chair, only one lot of anaesthetic. But equally, doing 3 fillings still doesn't take the same time as 1.


 
Posted : 16/06/2010 10:16 am
Posts: 818
Free Member
 

woody + tron

yeah thats how it works, although economies of scale arent really correct because it takes multiple appointments and you cant really mix up a huge vat of filling material and do it in one marathon session. I've got a few patients on methadone who need nearly every tooth in the mouth filling + root canal work, which will take about 8 hours work, and i get 45.60 (well actually its £60 incuding the NHS top up)! But then i can get the same fee for a quick 20 minute filling on someone else. I guess its supposed to average out. However, the problem is that it actually penalises patients with well cared for mouths who maybe only need 1 filling replacing now and again - they'll pay 45.60 just for that, in the old system they would have paid about 10 quid for a filling.


 
Posted : 16/06/2010 10:29 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

What you should do is only notice that 1 needs filling each visit 😉


 
Posted : 16/06/2010 11:16 am
Posts: 0
Full Member
 

(actually, more skilled imo) than accountants, lawyers or engineers

I'll give you the first two, but drilling a few holes and filling them or getting the pliers out vs. building bloody great bridges to support water, vehicles or a combination thereof? Come on.


 
Posted : 16/06/2010 11:42 am
Posts: 129
Free Member
 

meeeee

In that case I'm not surprised that many of your colleagues only do private work and practices in 'better areas' do very well, as even the NHS work will be more profitable.

I occassionally question whether the £27 a month I pay for private cover is worth it.......until I work out the premiums paid against treatment costs and realise I am still about 3 years 'in credit' 😆


 
Posted : 16/06/2010 12:05 pm
Posts: 818
Free Member
 

Woody - another 'interesting' thing about the new system is that the fees paid to the dentist are not uniform across England.

Dentists are now paid according to how many 'units' they do. A filling works out at 3 units (and as explained above 10 flgs also work out at a total of 3 units) Each unit is given a monetary value (here it is £20) The patient pays 45.60 for a flg and then the NHS tops this up so the total is 3 units or for me 3*20

The interesting bit is that i used to work in a big city with a dental taching hospital and LOT of NHS practices and no one was really forced to have private treatment. When i worked there, each unit was worth about £25.

I now work in an area which is nearly all private, and we opened an NHS practice after getting the local health authority to provide some funding. However, the value per unit for this area (with a huge shortage of NHS practices and people travelling 30+ miles to come see us) is less at £20.5! Similar stories in other predominately private areas. And the powers that be wonder why there is still a shortage of dentists in these 'lower value unit' areas, even though there is actually more need for them! ( i moved to my current area for better quality of life - more biking and climbing 🙂 )

I know of practices who receive as little as £18 per unit, and others that are paid £27. Obviously when you are doing several thousand units the differences add up to significant amount.


 
Posted : 16/06/2010 12:26 pm
Page 2 / 2