[Closed] How intelligent is the average STW poster...

Average?

Why do you have to be intelligent to have an opinion?

If I flounce, the average IQ in here drops by 20.

Lots of folks on here who berate others for their views, belittle others opinions

Says the person who can't stand people because of their political persuasions. Wow.

Are you qualified to ask?

On what scale are we basing our intelligence ?

How are you defining or measuring intelligence?

So are these posters genuine high flyers with a wealth of qualifications and high IQs to back up their comments and views, or are they just full of hot air with to much time on their hands?

I'm the former, everyone else is the latter.

Not just here either.

So are these posters genuine high flyers with a wealth of qualifications and high IQs to back up their comments and views, or are they just full of hot air with to much time on their hands?

Hmmm... that sounds a lot like you are belittling and berating others...

I don't understand the question....

Vrey

It this the queue for the toilet?

I certainly try to comment only on stuff I have knowledge/experience of, after seeing so many folk giving guff advice.

I am a total success story though of course, I have 2 degrees and a living wage job at 46

We have a bell shaped curve though in some debates we seem to have a bell end shaped curve
However the greatest philosophers have noted that being intelligent does not make you right. Plenty of bright folk believe in god for example

Why do you have to be intelligent to have an opinion?

Moreover,

Lots of folks on here who berate others for their views, belittle others opinions, and claim to know everything about everything.

Lots of folks on here with differing views sparking interesting debate, challenging others' opinions, and actually knowing a good deal about a vast variety of subjects.

Sounds terrible.

Buttocks.

If I flounce, the average IQ in here drops by 20.

If you stay does it drop by 50? 😉

Oh, I'm massively intelligent 8) Not that it's done me any good - intelligence just makes me angrier. 🙁

23

The front page Vote results reveal - not very intelligent at all. 😉

IQ = good at puzzles.

I qualified for MENSA membership on some test years back (I suspect everyone does). They wanted a £100 a year - I'm not that daft!

I believe the real intelligent ones are those who don't post.

[img] [/img]

😉 reveals, not nearly as intelligent as you think

I'm as thick as mince, me.

I know people with IQ's the other side of 150 I wouldn't trust to tie their own shoelaces....
Others who are under 100 but have more common sense and nouse than most.
So define "intelligence"

jonba - Member
I believe the real intelligent ones are those who don't post.

I know for a fact that everything I know is true, unless someone tells me otherwise.......

Know you are just said you are

Errmm define intelligence, education and high flyer please.

Are we talking learning, creative, emotional or reasoning intelligence (for example).
Then for Education are we covering the social side of education i.e. is someone who had a privileged upbringing with private schools and has more qualifications more intelligent than someone less privileged with fewer qualifications?

Is High Flyer about wealth, like my millionaire mate who has few qualifications?

So are these posters genuine high flyers

Nope I'm rubbish at jumps...

I qualified for MENSA membership on some test years back (I suspect everyone does). They wanted a £100 a year - I'm not that daft!

Ha, me too... anyone who pays the £100 has failed the test!

I love lamp

I think your average STW poster knows about their bike, possibly does a lot of work on their own bike, aren't dead yet, tend to be a bit irreverent, generally are well meaning but as likely to be a dick about some things as anyone else in the world.
Generally if I have a bike related problem I can get help.
If I have a relationship or political issue then I'm probably chancing my arm a bit asking for help / advice.
Don't forget to vote for your lizard.

IQ measurements aren't a reliable indicator of intelligence, last time I took a test, I scored 145 and I'm as thick as a whale omelette.

And no, I wasn't dumb enough to pay £100 to find out the result.

FWIW, I find this forum to be a pretty decent source of well thought-out and reasoned opinions from a large number of posters.

The fact that those opinions and experiences don't always align with my own is what makes it interesting.

ooohh...this got just the reaction I was looking for 😉

Opinions are like arse holes........ Everyone has one but some stink!

[img] [/img]

hammyuk - Member

I know people with IQ's the other side of 150 I wouldn't trust to tie their own shoelaces....
Others who are under 100 but have more common sense and nouse than most.
So define "intelligence"

Thankfully we don't have to, it has it's own definition - one that most people miss completely.

Most IQ tests, are just general knowledge quizzes, you could score highly because you were lucky, or had lots of exposure to the subject matter or just have a good memory.

Intelligence a measure of someone's ability to learn new skills / knowledge and apply them - it's not a measure of experience or some glorified pub quiz.

If you're looking for an Intelligent STW member you need to find a poster who's may be asking for help pumping up a tyre 12 months ago because they're completely new to bikes and riding and now is offering constructive, well balanced knowledgeable advice on the subtleties of wheel building or setting up a CCDB without referring to their website for base settings.

All too often Intelligent is a label reserved for white-collar workers, and not blue-collar workers but it's not really fair IMO, I've seen guys who can apply a huge amount of various skills they've got to getting machinery working again, or create the most wonderful things out of metal and wood, but people don't generally think of them as intelligent, artisan maybe, skilled certainly but not 'intelligent' oh no you need a suit and tie or maybe even a lab coat to be intelligent.

'Common sense' is usually just someone reacting to an everyday problem with the usual response with no more thought than "what did I do last time" or "what did Mum or Dad do" you could argue that someone offering a daft or unusual response has either never been exposed to that problem before, or is at least considering all options for the best solution - 'common sense' is usually just the easiest way.

There's another kind of 'Common Sense' of course, it's code for "this is my pre-conceived opinion that I have no way of proving is correct, nor would I want to" UKippers are quite keen on "Common Sense".

I got dressed by myself this morning and haven't injured myself yet today.

Winning.

Most IQ tests, are just general knowledge quizzes, you could score highly because you were lucky, or had lots of exposure to the subject matter or just have a good memory.

Na.
Most IQ tests are to do with reasoning, and are designed to be independent of educational background. Have a look if you don't believe me.

It is true that they tend to measure a particular type of aptitude, so a high IQ is no guarantee of empathy, "common sense" (see above) , spatial skills etc.

I am not so intelligent as I used to think I was.

The trouble with Common Sense is that it's not very common.

I can tie my own laces but haven't been smart enough these last 12 weeks to change them even though they are cheap rubbish laces that don't tighten effectively.

[i]Most IQ tests, are just general knowledge quizzes[/i]

You're thinking of TV game shows.

Most IQ tests, are just general knowledge quizzes, you could score highly because you were lucky, or had lots of exposure to the subject matter or just have a good memory.

I've never seen an IQ test that is based around general knowledge? I must have been doing the thicko test.

you may be confusing IQ with QI

I ride a single speed .
HTH

[img] [/img]

Perhaps it was general knowledge and you were too stupid to notice 😉

FWIW I agree with you

Ha ha great question ! People can hold divergent opinions and argue their case forcefully and intelligently whatever their level of qualifications.

not sure about intelligence....but I am always right! 8)

A considered appraisal of my 'intelligence'...

[img] [/img]

Luckily I have looks...

[img] https://imgflip.com/readImage?iid=30453502 [/img]

Uggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg

!

If you're looking for an Intelligent STW member you need to find a poster who's may be asking for help pumping up a tyre 12 months ago because they're completely new to bikes and riding and now is offering constructive, well balanced knowledgeable advice on the subtleties of wheel building or setting up a CCDB without referring to their website for base settings.

Isn't that just a driven obsessive?

Opinions are like arse holes........ Everyone has one but some stink!

Everyone has one but shouldn't try to force it on others.

https://theconversation.com/no-youre-not-entitled-to-your-opinion-9978

What is intelligence? 😐

I've just been for a brain scan. It came back negative.

So are these posters genuine high flyers with a wealth of qualifications and high IQs to back up their comments and views

I have very little in the way of qualifications and I try to restrict my comments and views to things which haven't got much of a clue about.

That way I don't get annoyed when people disagree with me.

Because quite frankly I find there's nothing more annoying than people disagreeing with me when I know I'm right.

tpbiker - Member
ooohh...this got just the reaction I was looking for

a fair evaluation

I feature in the bell curve. Towards one of the edges.

I'll let you conclude which end.

The trouble with IQ tests is that you can improve your score by practising them.

136

The trouble with IQ tests is that you can improve your score by practising them.

You can practice at being clever? I knew it was worth trying.

FWIW, I find this forum to be a pretty decent source of well thought-out and reasoned opinions from a large number of posters.

The fact that those opinions and experiences don't always align with my own is what makes it interesting.

This. And I always have the feeling that if I actually met the people I violently disagree with, we'd enjoy a drink together 🙂

I didn't even know that STW sold posters.

Are they of log burning stoves and Audis*?

*not sure which poster would be more intelligent though

Besides all the known issues with IQ tests, you can have people who have wildly varying IQ's between the different test subtypes....eg Verbal/Non-Verbal etc.

Having ADHD or generalized anxiety can knock your mark down considerably as well.

IQ tests can be strange, I do really well in verbal and pretty well in non-verbal. However, I do really really ****ing badly with questions that look for patterns in objects. Yet I am good at maths and chemistry and most of my relatives are professional musicians. Make of that what you will.

Qualifications aren't a particularly good way of comparing intelligence either.

Apart from the fact they generally test memory better than they test intelligence, unless everyone took the same exams then it's a pretty pointless comparison.

The fun thing is that if you're intelligent, you're more likely to have mediocre idiots as children....regression to the mean and all that.

I reckon this is why wealth is poorly correlated with IQ.

Qualifications aren't a particularly good way of comparing intelligence either.

Its is a pretty good way
IIRC the higher and the better the qualification the brighter you are

Apart from the fact they generally test memory better than they test intelligence

, unless everyone took the same exams then it's a pretty pointless comparison.

You do know different exams are at the same level dont you?

For example GCSE are all meant to be the same level of difficulty as are A levels as are degrees etc

Whilst no system will be perfect, and you will find exceptions, qualification level , including grade, is a decent indicator of intelligence.

s is a pretty good way
IIRC the higher and the better the qualification the brighter you are

I had a friend who got 5 GCSE's grade C.

For a laugh I encouraged him to go to university with me and study a foundation course. He worked hard, transferred to the university of Leicester and came out with a 2:2 in Computer Science.

He wasn't bright....most degrees value good memory over IQ.

For example GCSE are all meant to be the same level of difficulty as are A levels as are degrees etc

They used to do degrees in Take That, were [i]they[/i] the same level as a degree in Civil Engineering?

The fun thing is that if you're intelligent, you're more likely to have mediocre idiots as children....regression to the mean and all that.

I reckon this is why wealth is poorly correlated with IQ.

For example [s]David [s] lord Posh son goes to eton so he gets plenty of advantage form that as well as his genes

I went for a job recently where I had to do some online intelligence tests as well as personality profiling before they'd accept me for interview. I'm really good at those sorts of intelligence tests and scored highly, a mate went through the same process and didn't score too well but well enough. Thing is he's better at the job than me - and I think comes across as brighter than me.

Testing was done by Mindmill.

I am a Bachelor of Science but present me with numbers or equations and I haven't got a clue. I think I have a number dyslexia if there is such a thing.

[url= http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dyscalculia ]Dyscalculia [/url]

I suggest you all go away and read up on Intelligence[ and types], IQ tests and memory.

yours the person with a degree in Psychology who wont be listened to on this thread.....backs away slowly

Intelligence is one of the most hereditary traits we have .75 iirc
Twins studies etc show this pretty consistently plenty of research on this

http://www.my-iq.net/iq-test-Regression-450.html

[s]yours the person with a degree in Psychology[/s] yours the person with a misunderstanding of heritability who wont be listened to on this thread.....backs away slowly