[Closed] why fixed?

it's a fashion/niche thing - they'll grow out of it

Develops souplesse and leg speed, also good for wet riding as you have better control.

Unless you're riding in your sister's jeans at which point you're only doing it because someone else has told you that a mate of their's has told them that its mildly fashionable.

more smiles per mile?

Develops ****ed knees too.

i originally tried it as seemed something different (to what i already had) and i had recently put gears on my SS. and it made a good beater. i was surprised by how efficient it felt.

now i just see it as another bike. full suss, ss, road bike, fixed. I think it is a nice balnce i have in the shed. Dont like it off road (cross set up) but i'd like to try a fixed mtb.

zaskar - Member

Develops ****ed knees too.

why so? genuine question

Try it.

Its one of those bike marmite things, you will either love it or hate it 😉

wot ski said

i have tried it (well at the velodrome a few times but not on the road), but couldnt really see any advantage of using it on a commuter bike, especially as its pretty hilly round here. Unless these guys do a lot of track riding as well and like riding fixed all the time or something.

two reasons:
1. winter fitness for roadies
2. fashion

anything else is just as well covered by a SS

ive read just as much pro/con for the knee thing - IMO its no worse than any other cycling. knee pain has much more to do with saddle height, seat post angle, crank length, riding style. Fixid/SS stops you from sitting and mashing pedals.

Easier way of modulating speed in traffic that speeds up and slows down often.
Better in the wet (engine braking on the rear wheel, no locking up)
Fitness, more of a workout on shorter rides (they say 2hrs fixed is worth 3 geared)
Souplesse and cadence,riding fixed will improve your geared riding. pro road racers spin at 80-100rpm when just cruising whereas nodders on hybrids thrash around and mash gears on the bike (sweeping generalisation)
the best bit about riding fixed is the annoyance, consternation and opinions it generates from those who don't ride fixed.

it's not 'a zen experience' or particularly difficult. people just spread those rumours to make themselves look good/hardcore/different* to those that don't ride fixed.
*delete as appropriate

What AP said - it teaches you to pedal: cadence, rhythm, smoothness of power etc. You don't have gears so if go faster, you have no choice but to pedal faster so you also get fitter because you can't slack off.

The true reason for riding fixed is the anticipation of the day when you see the panic in the face of the deviant who's just nicked your bike as he turns round to sneer at your pursuit and realises that trying to free wheel isn't a healthy idea 😀

found it was a good way to scare the shit out of the near-father-in-law when he had a go....

see a clip once where some fella had left a bike outside a store. only the bike was a fixed bmx with a lose stem. cue funnies when some kid tried to steal it...

I rode a fixed in town for 7 years, bunnyhopping potholes was pretty disturbing as was catching a kerb at the wrong moment. 66" fixed, front and rear brakes, full guards and a Rolls saddle - fixed doesn't get more sensible than that.
First time I rode out into Surrey I rode down Combe Bottom, up Shere hill then over Holmbury before going back up Combe Bottom and back in via Hungry Hill cafe (where I was very hungry)

Develops ****ed knees too.

Rubbish.

a couple of fixed wheel riders in front

Were they on penny farthings?

Fixed wheel = pedal axle is the wheel's axle

Fixed gear = like the track bikes and converted racers you see the asymetric haircut kids riding/old school roadies who, in spite of being 75, will kick your ar*e all day long*

*delete as applicable

apparently if you ride in traffic it'll make you a better smoother rider,
as you'll concentrate on the road more, and thus able to read the road better

dunno if that's true! but that's what one cycling instructor said when justifying riding fixed.

The knee thing is just rubbish.
Problem with knees is using to big gearing. To be honest most entry level, recreational bikes should be sold without a big ring.

when justifying riding fixed.

you don't really have to justify any kind of riding.
paying £65 to go round and round a muddy field in the dark is a pointless exercise as is going up and down hills when you can go round them on a flatter route but if it's what you want to do then so be it.
🙂

I guess its like running-some will knacker their knees easily while the 96 yr old still does the London marathon and smokes etc.

I do SS but use an easy ratio of 18-36 off road.

If you're fit and have no history of knee probs-go for it but use an easy ratio to start and build up to it.

zaskar 2:1 ain't that easy really.

There's a reason that the classic fixed gear is 66".
18/36 - that is easy 😯

I commute every day on a fixie. I'm so old and fat that it can't be a fashion thing.

It just feels the right thing to do, its nice & easy, no pressure on the knees - even on the Monday morning after a 3 day weekend in the lakes.

I guess its the trackstanding at junctions that makes it worthwhile.

I ride 36:15 on 27" wheels with slick narrow tyres, and its even fun over Cannock Chase - although the mudguards rattle and things fall out of the pannier on some of the bigger drop-offs.

18/36 - that is easy

I had my ar*e kicked by someone on the early season chaingangs who was riding 66" fixed....

good question and having ridden fixed a bit I still don't know the answer.

i picked up a cheap fixed wheel to stick on an old racer to dip my toe in the water and was deeply underwhelmed. Its like singlespeed really. Like someone further up said, no zen experience, just single speed but perhaps slightly easier to get over the deadspot at the top of the cranks when going up a hill. Oh and possibly the odd lovely brief moment when you see something up ahead, say red light, and instead of reaching for the brake you just pedal slower and drift to a halt.

Track racing looks fun, but i think despite rather than because its fixed.

18/36 is something around 15" 😛

I've ridden with boys on regular bikes with 66" and its only on the fast big ring stuff that it goes wrong.

@ourmaninthe north - I think what the yanks call 'fixed gear' has traditionally been called 'fixed wheel' in these fair isles. Sturmey used to make a variable-gear hub without a freewheel, so 'fixed wheel' (as opposed to 'free wheel') but not 'fixed gear'.

you can't slack off.

Course you can. It just means when you do, the bike makes your legs keep going round.

I don't buy the 'more control in the wet' idea. What exactly can you do on a fixie that you can't do with brakes?

When riding fixed, it's very difficult to stand up to adjust your shorts or something... Or to get some blood flowing into your knob when the crappy hired track bike you are on cuts off the flow.

Re - riding in the wet, the number of people I know that skid like kids in the wet because they can't modulate their road brakes - with fixed you really reduce that, and also because you can also ease off and gradually slow the bike down (as you look ahead, not like an Atherton) you get more control.
...and as far as adjusting yourself, its called practice 😉

I've tried it once on my Genesis Flyer, scared the sh1t out of me! I'm not sure if I'm brave/stupid enough to try again.

I tried fixed on my Solitude and like it, but not for riding in traffic. While I've been using my MTBs for riding to work, I've been in freewheel mose, but the arrival of a new bike for commuting (have I ever mentioned that?) soon means that I'll be able to go back to fixed on my Solitude.

Fixed is good in traffic, it makes you time your run into a junction so that you never quite stop and then you can sprint out of the lights before the cars get going. Wandsworth one-way system was always good in rush hour traffic, and Hyde Park Corner as well. Actually Old Street roundabout and Shepherds Bush roundabout are both fun.

"I don't buy the 'more control in the wet' idea. What exactly can you do on a fixie that you can't do with brakes?"

you know those landrovers with the hill descent button? the ones where it goes in a super low gear and take your feet off the pedals and let the engine do the braking? it's similar to that, how can you lock a wheel if it's still being turned round by you? with a freewheel a touch of the brakes can stop the wheel and start it skidding. that's not going to happen if you are still turning the wheels (or slowing them down with your legs).

When I first rode fixed wheel back in the 70's, it was all my dad could afford + it was a traditional set up for winter riding....gears in the summer months only!
I spent the first two years of club riding on a fixed wheel (66"), this included a winter weekend in the Breacons, crossing the roman road/ gap route in a blizzard, all done with a carradice saddle bag + plus 4's!....
The way people bang on about fixed , you would think its something new....

i was told it was invented by london couriers and then appropriated by hipsters/students.
🙂

I'm with aP & the other sensible folk on this.

I do love the reaction fixed gets from folks - sure there are a lot of people exploring it at the moment, & there are some shockingly awful fixies about that are trying to be 'oh so cool', but I love the variety it brings to cycling. In fact, a quick blast for an hour on one of my fixed wheel bikes really feels like a good workout.

When I used to do Spinn classes, the first thing we were told to NEVER do was try to slow the flywheel once it was moving, as it is fixed and you MUST always stay pedalling. If you needed to stop quickly, we were told to pull up the resistance knob which acted as a brake.
I always assumed that braking on a fixie, must be a similar sensation? I know your back wheel doesn't have the same weight/inertia as a large solid flywheel, but the Spinn bike isn't moving so you are only slowing the flywheel, not the whole bike.

I have always assumed that a fixie would put extra strain on your knees. I should perhaps try one, one day.

I've been commuting 20 miles a day fixed, on a 48:16 ratio, for the past few months.

I can now trackstand, on both the fixie and any other bike.

I feel as if I am quite a bit faster sprinting from a standing start than before.

I haven't had to walk half the commute because of a ss freewheel or freehub body suddenly packing up and leaving the cranks spinning pointlessly (my route features 6 miles of crap-laden canal path and I'm no fan of cleaning).

I've got brakes too because I ride in traffic and I'm not mad.

Now I'm considering whether to take it on the darkside 100 miler I'm planning this weekend.

I really like it, you should give it a go!

+1 for enjoying fixed. Not sure why tbh, just enjoy not having to think about gears, or worry too much about cleaning. Hills really aren't that bad either. Certainly makes you think ahead in traffic. Built up an old Raleigh a while back but it's for sale now as getting a Tricross Singlecross to cover off/on road duties (freewheel offroad & fixed on with spare wheels).

when i get back on mtb it takes a moment to remember that i don't have to pedal and that i have a rear brake....

fixed feels different. had turned the wheel so i could use the freewheel (knew i'd be riding drunk). really didn't like it at all. much less 'connection' with the bike.

try it and see but give it time to adjust.

kerbs still scare the shit out of me..... need to learn to hop.

It is quite difficult to fart riding a fixie.

It's funny you should say that BJ, because the same thought occurred to me after a long delicious relief on the way home last night.