[Closed] Strava adiction

You only get on the leaderboard once with your best time.

As long as it's a public segment then I think as other people load rides it'll start using it - not sure if it processes all historical rides to match the segment or just new ones, tbh.

Update

the answer is, about 5 minutes - I'm now 7th of 11 😆

should have kept it private and retained the KOM 😉

That's a lot of computing isn't it ? - all recorded rides being compared to ewly created segments, everywhere in stravaland ??

(or is that what modern mobile phones could do in 5 minutes anyway ?)

Oh, and I've printed off a screenshot wwaswas - they can't take that away from me ( 😥 )

You upload your ride to the site, the site does the computing.

yeah, I know - but if the site is doing retrospective comparisons for all new segments that seems massive to me

(the mobile phone thing was more "or is it trivially easy for a server to do that these days ?")

I've just created a segment - bit longer than most in my area (only 2 miles though). I've logged 3 rides on it but only 1 shows up on the "leaderboard" (I'm the only person there - KOM, YEAH !!!!)

How/When will strava notice that the segment exists and fill in my other efforts (and everybody else) ?
Or doesn't it work retrospectively ?

on the left there is an option for my results. it'll show you all the times you've logged a time against that segment.

gribble, jambo: ta. I'm at the point where "saving the cost of a Garmin" is getting me halfway to the cost of a new iPhone!

As long as it's a public segment then I think as other people load rides it'll start using it - not sure if it processes all historical rides to match the segment or just new ones, tbh.

I don't know about 'all' however I have created segments that I have then seen back-filled with historic data.

on the left there is an option for my results. it'll show you all the times you've logged a time against that segment

Dunno scaredypants, but considering how bad Strava is at picking up my rides on segments I created myself it doesn't seem like it's [i]that[/i] trivial a job!

2nd on the infamous Taylored Cycles Swoop in Leigh Woods last night.

BOOOOOM!

On my steel hardtail too, 8 seconds quicker than on my Zesty!

I'll find those 2 seconds easily and get that KOM!

I've been pretty p'd off with the performance of the Strava app. I've ridden a certain downhill segment on pretty much all my rides recently and it's only picked up that segment once. Which happened to be the time when it was so slippery that I slid down rather than rode. Now it's dry and I'm flying it doesn't seem to pick it up. Going back to motion x then upload by gpx file until I can find a 2nd hand Garmin.

Yeah I've had strava miss out a few of my segments as well. Its especially annoying when you've busted a gut on a climb only to upload it and find it hasn't registered.

Never had that at all frankly.

I murdered myself last night on a climb, and it didn't pick it up, thats using a garmin and importing it via the strava website. I was gutted...

Warton - You can make the segment and it 'should' find the nearest match.

first ride with strava today, addictive is def the word 😀

EDIT: My KOM disappeared :'( guess because uploaded lots of addresses as private/invisible that cover the segment?

My bestest segment so far;

[url= http://app.strava.com/segments/1223464 ]http://app.strava.com/segments/1223464[/url]

Janesy, i did that, but it still hasn't included it....

I murdered myself last night on a climb, and it didn't pick it up, thats using a garmin and importing it via the strava website. I was gutted...

What's the usual accuracy of GPS on a Garmin, or smartphone? (Garmin say within 15 metres http://www8.garmin.com/aboutGPS/).

And Strava must have some kind of parameter built into the code to define when two tracks within a certain degree of closeness are, or are not, regarded as riding the same segment.

I guess if for some reason the trace recorded doesn't pass near enough to the 'official' start/end point, the segment won't get credited.

It's just a toy IMO.

I had this recently.. I road up coxgrove hill which appears to have 2 segments logged against it.. Mine only registered the 1 being 'coxgrove alternative'

http://app.strava.com/rides/6587892#123531187

http://app.strava.com/segments/739372

The most common reason a segment doesn’t match on a ride or run is because of GPS drift that occurred during recording of your activity. When we determine that a segment matches your activity, we look first at the start and endpoints, and make sure your data passes through those zones. Second, we make sure that at least 75% of the data in between matches the segment data. If any of these cases come up false, the segment will not match your activity or appear on your activity.

<willy waving> Been out with the local chain gang recently and bagged this one

http://app.strava.com/segments/1188457

they do seem to be two distinct tracks for that coxgrove one.

[url= http://app.strava.com/segments/1162507 ]http://app.strava.com/segments/1162507[/url]

My personnal challenge segment for the year. Hardest i could figure out.

http://app.strava.com/segments/933453

To say I rode this would be a massive lie! Still all KOMs count 🙂

So then, has anyone reported people for iffy segments/times?

I'm no speed demon but this bloke is 6 seconds faster than me over 0.4 mile [url= http://app.strava.com/rides/6665135#124617952 ]segment[/url] which isnt outside the realms of possibility but does[url= http://app.strava.com/rides/6665135#124617952 ]43.8MPH [/url] sounds fishy to anyone else?

Second, we make sure that at least 75% of the data in between matches the segment data.

How do they define a 'match'? There's the rub.

I've been using it now. It really is quite addictive. I've got a few KOM's on the MTB, mostly on the downward stuff, I don't really pay much attention to the start/finish points, so some of my times are all over the place.

My work commute also seem to be used as a training route by some animal roadies too. I'm not slow I don't think, i'd go so far as i'm probably at the fast end of the average scale now due to increasing fitness, yet i'm being chopped to bits by a select few. I did a bit of Googling & found out most of them race Cat 2, so that's probably what's doing it.

Still, give me something to aim for.

it's here https://strava.zendesk.com/entries/20950148-segment-matching-issues

scaled - Member

So then, has anyone reported people for iffy segments/times?

I'm no speed demon but this bloke is 6 seconds faster than me over 0.4 mile segment which isnt outside the realms of possibility but does43.8MPH sounds fishy to anyone else?

Look a bit closer at the map with Satellite on for both of you.
His track has stopped a fair bit sooner.

As someone said above it's a toy when "racing" against others.

I'm doing my best to wear the HR for all rides and runs this year and im getting some interesting stats.

209 is my highest suffer score on the windmill hill brutal 10k run! a fair bit higher than some of my 3 lap mtb races which also hurt

So has anyone got any EPIC suffer scores to share?

Dont you need to pay to get suffer scores?

There was a code floating around for a 3 month premium membership, otherwise yes, I think you do.

got a suffer score of 262 on a loop we did in the dales...it was brutal

[url= http://app.strava.com/rides/6026862 ]ouch[/url]

419 and then the GPS battery ran out 🙂

[url= http://app.strava.com/rides/6099975 ]http://app.strava.com/rides/6099975[/url]

Anyone got Team sky's number?

[url= http://app.strava.com/segments/1212693 ]I got a 34.2mph average the other day [/url]for the chain gang ride in Brizzle 😯

I've got a couple KOM in a few sections i've ridden and a few top 20 of 160ish people who've ridden the same trail so I'm happy

Been out with the local chain gang recently and bagged this one

You're 5th, that didn't last...

So then, has anyone reported people for iffy segments/times?

I've not, but I've seen people who have been. One of the trails in the Surrey Hills has a very dubious leader - [url= http://app.strava.com/segments/695402 ]30 seconds quicker than 2nd...[/url]

how would they fiddle that - downhillish & off road ?

surely people don't edit all their waypoints ? 😯

I'd be amazed if that time was right, considering Roo is pretty much at the top of all the leaderboards, to put 30s into someone on that track isn't really feasable.

He doesn't look to be a very fast rider either, the ride that segment was from was 17 miles in 2 hours or something. He's got some weird KOMs though it must be said.

But yes, it seems highly dubious that the gap between 1st and 2nd is the same as between 2nd and 153rd...!

You're 5th, that didn't last...

exactly... that weekly chain gang is getting faster every week

that weekly chain gang is getting faster every week

Hugo Humphries is a decent Junior racer, good target.

there's an elite monutain biker called llewellyn holmes that rides for strada that turns up every week.. do you know him?

I don't find the "explore" section of Strava very good, it never shows all the routes and its not very easy to find them....