[Closed] recommend me a cross bike

Pick a colour. Find a bike that matches.

surely not any frame geometry is suited to a cross bike?

If you're just going to comute on it - find a frame, traditionally 1 - 2cm smaller than your road bike size if you're going to race, and then build up from there.
Why not go to your LBS and ask their opinion?

Scott CX Comp, Moda Leggato (bit over budget tho') and Genesis Vapour are all great do-it-all cxers - have a look at the Genesis Croix de Feur

Chris

[i]surely not any frame geometry is suited to a cross bike?[/i]

Eh?

If you are buying a 'cross bike' then you'll get the geometry it comes with....

As above if you race it, then it becomes more important, but just to go to work on, you'd be better off on a bike that takes mudguards straight off.

May i suggest the Surly Cross Check...

[url= http://www.singletrackworld.com/forum/topic/cyclo-cross-choices ]look at this thread too[/url]

What do you want from a commuting bike? For example, you might want mud guards, water bottle mounts, ability to run panniers, off road ability, comfort etc. etc.

Everyone has a different set of priorities. I really like the Scott CX I have and find it great handling. Before that I had a Trek X0. As a commuter, the Trek was better, but the Scott works for me as a miles better race bike and I love riding it more.

Personally, if I was just after a commuter, I'd probably get a tough touring frame.

Today I rode in on my bmc cross bike (purely because with nicely aged michelin mud tyres it works in slushy/icy conditions), however for normal commuting I have a Trek Portland with full guards and panniers.

Agree
You don't seem to notice the subtle differences that you would with a choice of road bikes.
I did recently have (RIP) an old stell cross bike, it was too dated for racing but still lovely to ride and more forgiving on MTB routes than it's modern counterparts.
For what you want;
Genesis Kona or ultra cheap Graham Weigh frame with a Tiagra groupset, Dead kit and budget wheels. They have mental clearances and take guards.

Liking the look of the surly, the scott and the genenis.

I normally commute on my road bike, but its getting trashed and I cant fit panniers to it.

I defo want dropped bars and the "racer" style, ability to fit panniers and mudguards would be good (not too fussed about the mudguards as I usually wear waterproofs when its bad). if it could look cool that would be a bonus too 😀

what you really need is a touring bike.

why do you want a 'cross bike to commute on, get a tourer with full guards and racks, ah, but you want to look cool, ignore me

Like i say, check out the Surly.

It does just about everything and is super comfy.

A tourer may be overkill for a shorter commute - or so we find from experience anyway.

Boardman Pro CX. You'll need to be quick though I think.

http://www.boardmanbikes.com/cx/CX_Pro.html

Failing that Kinesis and Empella are pretty big in the race scene.

Cross bikes that take racks and guards include Kinesis Crosslight T and the Condor one.

mudguards are a world away from wearing waterproofs. really, *so* much better. fit them well and choose teh colour well and they don't hurt the looks of a bike, certainly not to other riders.

makes commuting far better. IMO, natch.

Love my Jake the Snake. It takes a rack too, and I have been known to commute on it 😉

Nick

Ridley Crossbow comes in under £1k - capacity for panniers & guards if so desired.

Lovely bit of kit IMHO.

why do you want a 'cross bike to commute on, get a tourer with full guards and racks, ah, but you want to look cool, ignore me

I know **** all about cross bikes, but the edinburgh bikes revolution cross looks like a nice reasonably priced option,

JoB - Member
why do you want a 'cross bike to commute on, get a tourer with full guards and racks, ah, but you want to look cool, ignore me

+1

Touring will never be fashionable though...

I like my surly Casseroll - no cantis to seize up with winter salt, nippy light-touring geometry.

The best of cross and bikes...
[img] [/img]