Help me decide plea...
 

[Closed] Help me decide please...

Posts: 3355
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Firstly lets set out the ground rules.

1. I only have space for 2 bikes

2. I have little cash.

3. The wife says I need at least 2 bikes or I'm grumpy if one breaks and I can't ride.

OK, now that's out the way I shall continue...

I have two bikes at the mo, my 'good' bike, a trek 9.8 hardtail, reba's and XTR/XT mix. Nice bike, like riding it, and a 'hack' On One Scandal 29er. rigid, geared with a mix of deore, raceface and erm, 105...(plus whatever I could find in the shed)

Bought the scandal about 4-5 months ago, intended as an early morning ride-then-stick-in-the-shed-to-clean-later bike. trouble is, since getting it, I've used the trek once.

I'm toying with the idea of upgrading the scandal a little, with some bits from the trek, then splitting and selling off the trek, then buying a cheap (something like the B'Twin) road bike for occasional roady rides and getting me back and forth the 1 mile trip to work (currently using the very mucky scandal!)

So, Am I nuts? Should I just leave be, or is it worth trying to grab a change.

Advantages I can see include:

1. I like riding the 29er (I'll put some sus forks on it)
2. a roady will mean I'm a little cleaner when I turn up to work (with appropriate mudguards natch..)
3. I'll not have one bike sat in the shed doing nothing.
4. I may smile more (unlikely though)

Disadvantages:

1. I may not be able to run a negative or equal balance on the swap over..(that's quite important for wife's approval)
2. I'll only have a road bike if the scandal has a mechanical..

help


 
Posted : 17/01/2014 10:15 am
Posts: 5559
Free Member
 

not sure you need a road bike for a 1 mile ride you could do that on anything

Get what you will use most often and need most in this scenario a road bike is unlikely to be the answer

Get a cross bike and a FS MTB would be my solution if i only had two bike tbh.


 
Posted : 17/01/2014 10:28 am
Posts: 24776
Free Member
 

The wife says I need [b][i][u]at least[/b][/i][/u] 2 bikes or I'm grumpy if one breaks and I can't ride

[img] [/img]

Somewhere between the two.....There's your answer

Upgrade the Scandal with the pick of the bits from the Trek, if a 29er is your favourite now. Keep the Trek as a mudplugger, maybe even convert it to a SS. And get a cheap road or CX bike anyway. You can find space somewhere.


 
Posted : 17/01/2014 10:33 am
Posts: 3355
Full Member
Topic starter
 

You can find space somewhere.

hmmm, nope that's not going to work..

CX bike would fit nicely alongside the 29er.

When I say the roady will be used to get to work, it would also be used if I fancy a road ride. I don't do road rides much now as I don't like riding knobbly tyred bikes on the roads 🙂

so, I guess next is recommend me a cheap as chips CX bike or roady, budget will be no more than £350 (hence the B'Twin mentioned..)


 
Posted : 17/01/2014 10:49 am
Posts: 24776
Free Member
 

CX season will be over in a couple of months, pick up a second hand bargain. keep your powder dry until then.


 
Posted : 17/01/2014 10:53 am