Ok I always dispute this but it depends how rough the riding is perhaps. I did get this problem until I made the chain as short as possible.
Chain was, is, and will always be as short as possible from day 1 on any of my bikes. The issue I had with a Top only guide is by no means a lone case. I know several others who’ve experienced the same, and come across many others on this forum and others who have had the same issue. This is no “willy waving contest” either, there’s people I know on here run a top only guide and get on fine with it that are certainly quicker riders than I am, but I suspect they’re probably a lot smoother too, never back pedal, and can get away with much lighter tyres/rims/frame/forks etc. than I could too because of these facts.
We’re all individuals, what suits one person’s needs doesn’t suit anothers, but based upon personal experience I could in no way shape or form recommend a top only guide.
Road chains are fine, running an Ultegra on mine currently. the side plates are a slightly different profile, but they’re exactly the same width.
Learn something new every day! I’d been told by “someone in the know” (ie. mechanic in a bike shop) that road 10spd chains were actually narrower… Hey ho!
LOL
I tried a 36 for a bit, but realised I barely ever used 10th cog, and that there were rare occasions where I wished I had a slightly lower 1st gear still. Therefore the 32T went back on. Again, we’re all different… Some people climb hills fine on bloody singlespeeds!