I was happy with my WTB Rocket V but then went on a search for a saddle with more padding in the nose for steep climbs.
The Phenom SL was great but had some very alarming sharp plastic bits at the back which didn't inspire confidence when descending.
I found the Charge Spoon very comfy but underpadded on the nose for my liking.
The Prologo Vertigo Max had too much of a cradle shape (see above comments) for my liking which meant it was only comfy in one position and one position only.
Have eventually settled for the WTB Pure V. I got an OEM one on my Marin which is very soft, but more importantly has some decent padding on the nose. I got an aftermarket one for my other hardtail which was firmer and lighter (and looked smarter) and has been ideal for messing around through to marathon racing.