Just thought I’d let everyone know of the success I’ve had in fitting an XTR M9000 rear derailleur to a 1×10 setup without modification.
I found that I was having some issues with my Hope 40t T-Rex “holding” onto the chain when shifting down, upon inspection I could see that the cage of my XT Shadow+ derailleur was the problem and was catching on the back of the T-Rex sprocket. I looked at the OneUp Rad cage as a solution, and from pictures on the web I could see how it worked by off-setting the upper pulley. However I recognised that the same offset was present on my old STX derailleur, so I stripped it with a view to swapping its cage with the XT Shadow one, unfortunately the older derailleurs have a wider mounting pin, so without lots of time consuming filing and cutting screw threads it wasn’t going to swap easy. So I started looking at all Shimano rear derailleurs on the web, and realised the new XTR M9000 had a significant offset to its upper pulley. I also found some information that suggested the cable pull of the new XTR M9000 was only 0.2mm more than existing 10 speed Shimano, so I thought I’d have a gamble and see if it would work, worst case I might have to put some washers under the cable clamp.
I duly purchased an XTR M9000 RD and fitted it and found that it worked perfectly in all gears, the pulley offset cured the shifting problem, and also gave a much better chain wrap around the 11t sprocket as well. I’ve been running this setup for about 5 weeks now and have covered about 500 miles, initially in some real sticky mud and I have to report that the RD has shifted perfectly every time.
Setup as follows:
Cassette – XT M771 Cassette with Hope T-Rex 40t & the 15t & 17t sprockets replaced with an XT 16t.
Shifter – Saint M820 10 speed (all Shimano MTB 10 speed have the same cable pull, so should all work).
Chain – Shimano XT 10 speed
Yes I’ve probably spent 3 times as much than buying the OneUp Rad cage, however the XTR pulley offset is greater so provides more of a benefit.
As a final note, until I did this no recent Shimano Shadow 9 or 10 speed RD has ever provided such smooth shifting as the old STX, and now I know why – the Shadow RD upper pulleys have no offset! Only changed to Shadow type to get a clutch to stop chain slap (I just can’t stand any drivetrain noises).
If anyone interested I’d be happy to post some pictures or diagrams up on Sunday.