Arrrggghhhh cant decide, its doing me 'ead in !

For my new black Soul build, XT everything else but XT or SLX chainset, heart says XT eyes say SLX look nicer……..

SLX, spend the saving on beer!

APF

SLX, plus the XT cranks look ****….

SLX I reckon

SLX

SLX

Just to be a bit different…XT if going for 3-ring setup, SLX if going for double and bash.

Hmm – just had SLX and managed to kill it quite quickly. So this time I went for XT – which now also has a steel middle chainring.

To compare the two…

XT:

SLX:

SLX, cheaper, just as good and only fractionally heavier, looks better too 😀

I run XT but only 'cause I got a package deal with a full groupset.

IMHO the SLX looks a lot lot nicer, very XTR ish 8)

When my XT wears out, I'll be replacing it with an SLX

I bought SLX, they is way betterz.

SLX do look better

SLX Here.

If everything else is XT spec, it make sense to get XT cranks to complete it.

slx cranks on ribble cycles are £60 minus bb or £8 more for double and bash version. Bargain if you ask me.
http://www.ribblecycles.co.uk/sp/mtb-bmx-bike/Chainsets-Shimano-SLX-M660-9-Spd-Triple-Chainset-ex-BB/SHIMCHAM300

slx

Well I prefer XT and will be sticking to them now! I do have spare SLX crank arms if I ever need them though.

I wouldn't say SLX is "better" – the only weakness of the XT (alloy middle ring) has now been addressed. Looking at the two side by side, the XT looks better finished. The weight difference is marginal but then I only paid slightly more for my 2010 XT chainset so IMO, it was worth it.

They're functionally interchangable so SLX as it's cheaper.

Cheers all, i just cant help thinking that the Souls here:

http://www.cotic.co.uk/product/soul

Would look better with SLX on, performance wise i dont think there is a lot in it and as already mentioned SLX is £60 cheaper than XT at Ribble, its not really about the money but £60 goes a long way.

Surf-Mat – Member
Well I prefer XT and will be sticking to them now

Yeah but you're buff & well ghey! 😆

Get the SLX and spend the rest on bits that make more difference.

I've had SLX but XT came on my current bike. There is no functional difference so choose on price and looks (so SLX then).

xt looks alot nicer, slx looks like a cheap and tacky version of xtr, at least the xt has its own look going on 😆 xt all the way!

IMHO the SLX looks a lot lot nicer, very XTR ish

Get slx if you think a toyota mr2 looks like a ferrari.

SLX +1

Had the decision to make recently, went for SLX

Just in case you're having trouble visualising it, here's some SLX on my black Soul:

To be honest I don't have a strong preference, but went for the SLX mainly on price. Can't fault it for performance or looks so far, too soon to tell about longevity though.

SLX FTW

Heart says XT.

Brain says SLX.

Mark Datz..where are you…???

slx iz wikd coz itz wll az good az xt's an iz well les buck ad som fevers to mak it wurk be''er, no shit innit….i speekn 4 manwells 2.

Represent.

Oh and Slayer rock BTW.

deffo XT coz dat naokfreek sez slx innit

Sum dix at skool cant take a jok and got angree all the teechars satrted piking on me and then I had to promiss not to use intarnet but now its kool again

SLX looks a lot better and we all know that's what counts!

i went for Xt 2 days ago because its lighter and IMO looks better.

SLX, XT are gross

And SLX are stiffer

xt looks alot nicer, slx looks like a cheap and tacky version of xtr, at least the xt has its own look going on xt all the way!

true but xt looks like a nicer version of deore:

stevede

slx cranks on ribble cycles are £60 minus bb or £8 more for double and bash version. Bargain if you ask me.
http://www.ribblecycles.co.uk/sp/mtb-bmx-bike/Chainsets-Shimano-SLX-M660-9-Spd-Triple-Chainset-ex-BB/SHIMCHAM300

oh and if you use the code "TRIP7" you get an extra 7% off on top, £55 for an SLX crankset, hell at that price i've just bought one!

BB isn't included though, not that that bothers me, HOPE bb's all the way 😉

I have one of each and there is only 25g difference between right crank arms with 3 rings fitted, Hope this helps.

I've just bought XT but I needed a crank for tomorrow's ride. Had I had time I would have gone SLX.