You need to talk to roverpig,have a look at his “which bike to sell” thread on the next page
No don’t do that. I think I’ve just sold the Smuggler and don’t want to sell them both, so I think I’ll be keeping the Five. I am happy to share some thoughts on it though 🙂
I did some back to back testing of this old 26″ Five against a modern 29er (Smuggler) and what was really striking was how little difference there was.
I did a 3.3 mile loop with 400 foot of climbing. Overall time for the Five: 26:04 with an average heartrate of 151bpm. Overall time for the Smuggler 26:13 with an average heartrate of 151bpm. The Smuggler was faster up the timed climb, but my hearrate was higher and I obviously rested elsewhere on the loop to make up for it.
Times on the two descents were spookily similar. One had some steep tight turns that have been covered in loose rocks then some rooty sections. The other was flat out. Technically the Five was 1s faster on the tight section and 1s slower on the flat out, but that’s well within the margin of error.
Now I’m sure that this similarity has a lot to do with the fact that I’m a talentless idiot. What matters is my limited ability and lack of nerve rather than the bike. I dare say that a rider who could push either bike to its limits would notice more of a difference, but for me the bike just isn’t that important.
Having said that, there is a big difference in feel. The Smuggler feels more composed and soaks up the trail better. The Five feels like I’m closer to the edge and gives much more feedback. Which you prefer is up to you of course.
Finally, Orange clearly still like these numbers as the new Four looks a lot like a modern copy of this older Five.