A soakaway is to hold water until it can percolate into the soil. As such only the part above the water table has any effect. If you dig a hole, it will fill up with ground water to maybe 400-300 below the surface, depending on your geology.
Dig a hole and see how it fills up, of course this will be affected by time of year and recent rainfall, but you get the idea.
If your have a high water table a wide shallow soakaway is much more useful. The more gap you can incorporate into it, the better it will work. Professional jobs use specially made plastic frames and are mostly void.
Does that help, or am I just ranting?
APF