I bought a Phenom sadle in November and after 3 days riding there was holes worn through on both sides so I had it replaced but now after 4 weeks it’s got a hole apearing in it. I ride in Endura shorts which I wouldn’t think we’re that abrasive. So is it just me.

I’ve had one for 6 months and a few hundred km. No sign of wear whatsoever. Ate the hold appearing where the inside of your thighs rub against it?

Yes about 1 1/2″ back from the nose. I had a Toupe for 4 years before it holed.