Have any of you used the magic Mary too? How do they compare?
IMO they don’t, Shorty is as good as the Mary at everything and better than it at most things. Mary is a good tyre but Shorty is fantastic.
They’re both still big, knobbly tyres- they can do whatever you ask, they work fine in the dry and on hard stuff but there’ll be a lot of times when something faster will be nicer and grippier. But if you want one tyre and your riding includes challenging gloopy offpiste stuff then I can’t see past the shorty, it is fab.
Vigilante seems like it might be a decent option if you want slightly better allrounder manners and slightly worse wet… Not sure about that, I’ve not got a good handle on mine yet. Heavy as a rock though.