- Academic types, how to reference a reference in a reference…
Hi all, I’m writing an essay in which I want to mention a piece of information I’ve read in a paper, however, the writer of the paper is referencing another paper in which that author is citing another author. How would I write this a) in the body of my essay and b)do I need to mention all the sources in the reference list or just the work I have read?
In the body would it be ok to put something like this:
“blah blah blah…”(Sackett et al, 1997 in Van De Luitgaarden, 2009 p247 cited in Galpin & Huges 2011 p 151)
Thanks,Posted 4 years ago
Two aspects to my answer:
Firstly, should you really be citing this? It is third hand evidence and it would be better to read the original content. Can you access the original to read the quote in context?
Secondly, does you university not have a guide to citations? Something like this: Cite them rightEach institution can have its own conventions and you will need to follow them rather than the views of STWPosted 4 years ago
Thanks all. Midlifecrisis, it’s not a direct quotation, it’s discussion of an idea in a source that is then discussed in another work and finally mentioned in the one I’ve read. So the one I’ve read cites as follows:
“(Sackett et al. (1997) in Van De Luitgaarden (2009) p247)”
I’ve looked on the pages of the uni’s support for learning guide to citations and it’s rather general, simply stating that the school my course is in expects the Harvard style and gives general guidance about how to insert quotations and reference in the body of an essay. It doesn’t mention secondary, or indeed tertiary, referencing.Posted 4 years agowoodlikesbeerMember
As above, find an alternative source. It’s not good practice to referance second (or third) hand material. You run the risk of mis-quoting which is never good. It does happen though. A colleaue of mine has been referred to over 20 times. The silly thing is that the paper was never written, let alone published. The paper was simply listed in a proposed special edition that never appeared. This undermines the peer-review process. That’s marine science. You appear to be in social sciences but I presume it’s the same.Posted 4 years agobokononMember
Is there any specific aspect, different information in any of the sources you are referencing? It’s always best to exploit your quotes (direct and indirect) as much as possible – so which of the papers has the most relevant discussion of the idea to your paper – I’d cite that one, and if it is the third one in the train, then cite them in sequence as above – but if word count allows – then identify the aspects that each of the references has added, and relate them back to your work.Posted 4 years ago
The topic ‘Academic types, how to reference a reference in a reference…’ is closed to new replies.