Will CJ Stander he cited this week? The end of his Itoje spat where he chased across the pitch to smash him, and punching Farrell on the floor (Farrell was holding on, but you can’t just punch people.
He very clearly had an open hand, so I doubt it.
I’m a big fan of Stander - he did seem to be the wrong side of emotional control today.
This years England team have me undecided. I can’t decide if EJ is trying to ensure positional flexibility within his squad, or is just pig headed in selection.
Why take Mconnochie to the RWC, then not select him this year when we are short of wings? JJ actually played well today, but he wasn’t really tested defensively.
What is the long term scrum half plan ?
Never a penalty try as there was cover coming across, a penalty most likely.
Offside in general is not reffed, but the game doesn't penalise the attacking side in general, there are far more penalties given away defensively. The attacking players continually enter rucks from the side to clear out.
I suspect the no arms bit was because he was trying to charge down the kick by the way!!
Are your cataracts troubling you today?
Peyper is a shit ref and was particularly poor today I thought.
Jones’s selection are very odd and he does have a habit of selecting players and discarding them.
God knows what the scrum half plan is. Mitchell is there as an apprentice but doesn’t look like he’ll get a shot. Youngs was OK today, but that means he’ll be piss poor next week.
Are your cataracts troubling you today?
Well the ref, assistant ref and tmo didnt agree with you so, well, you know
He very clearly had an open hand, so I doubt it.
Sean Connery would approve, I'm sure.
I saw an open hand as well and he was hitting Farrells arms trying to get him to let go ( then into the body)
I have no idea what Farrell thought he was doing. Ok hold on for a bit if you must but Farrell gave away a pen that led to Ireland scoring. Idiot
but that means he’ll be piss poor next week.
That'd be fine as long as he's better for the week after... 🙄
That’d be fine as long as he’s better for the week after… 🙄
Ha ha. Ain’t gonna happen; Youngs has one good game in ten. He’ll be shite for the rest of the 6N.
Scrum half is one area where Jones really hasn’t developed his squad. Care is currently in good form and has a decent number of caps, Spencer should have had more of look in as should Robson. Simpson has also gone well since moving to Gloucester.
Whatever the stats seem to say Ireland were smashed, England seems to have worked out that we have an inability to cope with a simple ball kicked in behind. Sexton was awful and the extensive strapping on his leg seems worrying. On the plus side our U20s look like we have some good players coming through.
The most telling stat for me was how many times the commentator picked out Stander prior to the Farrel moment
Twice, IIRC, once for his hand bags at dawn moment with Itoje and once for managing the ball at the back of a scrum.
He is usually one of the most commentated on players in the Irish team. Was allowed to do virtually nothing by England yesterday.
Good for Engand to win, but on reflection disappointed they did not properly finish off Ireland and at least get the bonus point.
Good for Engand to win, but on reflection disappointed they did not properly finish off Ireland and at least get the bonus point.
They declared at half time didnt you hear?
England didnt look that great, if Wales were playing well I'd be confident, as it is I expect Wales are in for a tough afternoon next weekend.
England did nothing in attack bar kick(very well) and either try to drive over from short range or hope for a good bounce. England were also really niggly all game.
Blitz defense was good tho - scoring against them will be difficult.
England did nothing in attack bar kick(very well) and either try to drive over from short range or hope for a good bounce. England were also really niggly all game.
Still scored more tries than Scotland this tournament though...😉
I’m still surprised that they managed to beat Ireland. I still think they lack a killer instinct...if the AB’s were on top like that there would be no let up and a shed load more accuracy.
and don't forget that the Ford Farrell axis just doesn't work....
But might that be because they knew that type of play might work best?
Was is sheer luck that they found Ireland had trouble with the kicks behind or was it a plan?
I thought most of the niggle came from Ireland and there attitude to entering rucks.
https://twitter.com/Smallclone_/status/1231596338946678784
looks fine can’t see anything wrong with those three entries......
I saw them during the game and was surprised TMO didn’t pick up on it.
I’ve seen talk in a couple of places now of future games being affected by covid-19. Thoughts?
Ads
Didn't / doesn't work ball in hand tho. OUtside backs hardly saw a pass and when they did it was way behind the gainline.
I think the kicking was a plan and executed very well indeed
First one in the side. All had arms involved. whats the issue?
Last one is direct to the head!
To be fair TJ I'd like to see Farrell dropped and maybe slade and Tuilagi in the centre's with Ford at 10. Farrell needs taking down a peg or two. EJ will never drop him though.
whats the issue?
In the side, straight off feet
But might that be because they knew that type of play might work best?
Was is sheer luck that they found Ireland had trouble with the kicks behind or was it a plan?
It worked last 6N too. The way Ireland defend means that you can prosper from the kick through if down well.
As soon as the ref allows it at the start, it’s going to happen all game. The tackle laws have become ridiculously overzealous, whilst the ruck is allowed to be a war zone.
Anyone doubting whether May was intentionally taken out in that earlier clip, take a close look at Farrell in England’s first 2 tries.
1st try - Taken out by Larmour as he chases through. Miles away from the ball and a clear yellow.
2nd try - taken out off the ball by the Irish centres.
Englands attack was very good for a change, how can you say it wasn't? Loads of variety, Back three and Tuigali inside and outside Ford taking it up, the threat and use of Fords kick over the top, the kick chase produced results and the talisman Sexton was put under pressure. Essentially England picked out the less experienced Irish players and forced them into mistakes, whilst holding the line.
Sure there are many more spectacular tries scored in the world but that was not a bad attacking game by any means, and let's remember Ireland are not a bad side at all. The very fact all the off the ball mentioned in the last few posts has happened is a sig of a team desperate to slow the attack.
However, the problem with England is despite all the talk of leadership they play to a formula. When its right as it was on Sunday and against the AB's we look really good, but when its wrong or nullified there's no changing it and we get the SA game or second half of Sunday. Essentially on Sunday England kept on doing the same as usual, and lost out to Ireland because they changed their game plan slight to stop bashing Englands defence through the backs and to get the ball into Englands half and use the forwards. Ireland adapted, England didn't.
If we play the first half game against Wales with a strong defensive, we'll win. If we play the second half game, Wales will win.
The other thing I thought I spotted was that the English defensive line was much more lacsidasical in the last 20 mins giving Ireland more space to play in.
Kryton57 +1
When things go Englands way, then they look good but when the opposition find a way of nullifying the England game plan, England simply don't appear to have a plan B. Nobody on the paddock appears to offer true leadership.
When things go Englands way, then they look good but when the opposition find a way of nullifying the England game plan, England simply don’t appear to have a plan B. Nobody on the paddock appears to offer true leadership.
Same could be said of Ireland. They have a certain way to play and if you nullify that they’re all at sea.
Ireland make a choice to fly up in the line, leaving space in the backfield. England’s kicking is the response to that. It seems Ireland’s way to defend kicks through, is to take out the chaser.
I do still wonder if EJs apparent stubbornness is part of a plan to develop flexibility within his main squad. There will never be an out and out 8 or wing on the bench, especially with a 6/2 split. He needs other players to be able to switch roles, so is giving experience/flexibility.
Or he is just a stubborn sausage!!
Liam Williams is to leave Sarries with immediate effect and return to Scarlets.
I’m guessing the first of a few.
I’m guessing the expensive imports will all run.
Same could be said of Ireland
I'll try to find the link to something I read but this is where its felt the AB's win the game - they are out an out much better in the skills / loose game than any other team, so when it gets loose they play instinctively with and around each other, while the NH sides specifically are playing patterns. It makes them all the more unpredictable for the oppo, whilst actually an area of predictability for their team mates.
Sarries are in big trouble now with the mooted £2.5 million salery cap in the championship after the RFU decided to cut funding massively
Tell you what. I'd rather have the other six nations troubles right now than Scotlands. A coach who is a diddy who is wasting the best players we have had. Several of our best players not getting a game for the national side for no good reason. An experienced and good coach lost to the scottish game.
Its just an effing shambles
I agree with the posts on Englands "way" I think it stems from having a dominant scrum and second phase at the breakdown. When other teams can cancel that out (SA) then I am not sure what your plan B is. As things stand you lot would be terrifying with a 9 who could box kick for May.
@ tjagain,
Your 'best player' is apparently disruptive and believes team rules don't apply to him. He needs to grow up and become a team player or put himself forward as player/coach. IMO.
Thats only one side of the story piha. There is a lot more to it than that and its a managment falure to allow it to get to that.
No one who knows Russell has anything other than to say that playing for scotland is very important to him. He always trains hard and helps lead the team
He is not the only casualty of Townsend / dodson anyway/ George Horne is on fire and has been for a year. Cannot get a start. Ritchie Gray looks like he will no longer play for Scotland. Jones dropped. Ritchie Gray the coach lost to Scotland. Sean Lineen shuffled out. Craig Chalmers is a pariah for critising the SRU. Darcy Graham not getting to start in the WC despite being on fire.
totally confused tactics and selection from Townsend
Dodson getting paid far more than any other 6N CEO and getting paid more than the three top earning players in Scotland put together
Its totally dysfunctional
Toby Booth taking over the Ospreys this summer.
Not sure that’s a great idea because he’s not set the world on fire at Irish or Bath.
Toby Booth taking over the Ospreys this summer.
Not sure that’s a great idea because he’s not set the world on fire at Irish or Bath.
Given the lack of funding they were never likely to get a top class coach.
Adams out for surgery and North looking likely to be out, Liam might get a game for Scarlets this weekend. Not sure getting smashed at Twickers would be a good intro for God Dammit!!!
When does Booth start, they could be a burnt out husk by the time he arrives!
