[Closed] One love gig

If that's what you really believe, that you're actually that cynical, then I genuinelly feel sorry for you.

I don't think anyone who watched a single second of her performance last night would think it came from anywhere else but the bottom of her heart. You can't fake emotion like that. It was a young woman who has obviously been enormously emotionally affected by what happened

But If that's what you want to think .... Hey ho... maybe she should just gone and moaned about stuff on the internet instead

For me it was far too soon and inappropriate for the grieving parents and family members that lost loved ones in the attack. Cant even imagine what they must of thought about it all.

Well a lot of them were there as they had the area at the front reserved for them, and the ones interviewed seemed happy to be there sticking two fingers up to the terrorists

Maybe they should all have been sat in a dark room, weeping?

For me it was far too soon and inappropriate for the grieving parents and family members that lost loved ones in the attack. Cant even imagine what they must of thought about it all.

For me, the fact it was done only two weeks later was one of the most powerful messages of strength, love and solidarity that could have been given.

I didn't even know it was on. Thanks to STW I can hate Robbie Williams for appearing ex post facto.

[i]For me it was far too soon and inappropriate for the grieving parents and family members that lost loved ones in the attack. Cant even imagine what they must of thought about it all.[/i]

Breakfast TV this morning featured a mum & daughter who witnessed the suicide bomber - watch it on iPlayer and you'll find out.

For me, the fact it was done only two weeks later was one of the most powerful messages of strength, love and solidarity that could have been given.

Absolutely.

Heck, I'm even mildly impressed by Chris Martin doing Don't Look Back in Anger, and I hate the **** usually

Edit: I take that back, I've just heard what he did to Sit Down

....i wouldn’t suggest you should do otherwise.

No. Obviously, you would never do anything like that.

Why would you even watch it?

why would you wilfully sit through that sugar coated pop dirge?

Just because something is for a good cause why do you have to force yourself to watch it?

...sit through a couple of hours of teeny pop just because everyone else is.

I bet her input went as far as saying, Manager I want to do something for the people who were there, then her manager sorted the rest £££££

Well of course it was. Did anyone really think she'd be going through the Yellow Pages, looking for PA rental?

I'm sure it's done her career the power of good. Queen couldn't get themselves arrested after playing Sun City under apartheid; they play Live Aid and they are back to being national treasures. That doesn't mean it's not the right thing to do.

Ariana G is now a lot more famous (and rich) than she was.

Famous yes, but famous now to people who are highly unlikely to buy her music anyway. And richer, how?

For me it was far too soon and inappropriate

The whole point of it was to get on with things and not let terrorists stop people doing what they do. I think you've missed the point of it being as soon as it was.

The music wasn't my thing, I particularly hate coldplay, not just dislike, but I watched it and found parts of it very emotional.

For a 23 year old fronting something like that it impressed me.

I didn't really know who Ariana Grande was other than another teeny popper with a fascination with themselves. But in the wake of what happened, and to put together that concert in such a short space of time is more than impressive when a lot of other artists would have hunkered down in their mansion talking about how it "affected them".

I'm sure it's done her image no amount of good, but the fans don't care about that when they get a selfie with the lass, and to them a little sunshine is better than what they were subjected to the last time they went to see her live

For me it was far too soon and inappropriate for the grieving parents and family members that lost loved ones in the attack. Cant even imagine what they must of thought about it all.

I know a few of the parents that were there on the night of the bombing, with their children. They were also in the audience last night, with their children. Along with my daughter who insisted on going. Both my girls also went to the Courteeners Gig. It wasnt too soon. In fact, in my humble opinion the timing was perfect. I didnt even know a lot of the artists, but I sat watching it mostly in tears last night.

Reading some contributions to this thread tonight has genuinely made me sad.

Back to the bike forum for me.

I didn't watch, as I didn't know it was broadcast, but I want to thank binners for his commentary on this thread. Have a pie or a pint on me.

@FunkyDunc - you know how to piss on the chips.
Plenty of posts attempting to put you straight.
I won't waste my time.
A little common sense would have told you to keep your cynical views to yourself.

The whole point of it was to get on with things and not let terrorists stop people doing what they do