Forum menu
iphone 4 -v- galaxy...
 

[Closed] iphone 4 -v- galaxy s -v- desire hd

 IA
Posts: 563
Free Member
 

Would be nice to know where the antenna is on the HD desire as on my 5800, it's on the bottom of the handset so I have to talk upside down.

Eh? that makes no sense?

Anyhow, it's on the bottom of nearly every phone so they can meet regulations about radiated power into your head. Being a bit further away from your head makes a big difference.


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 5:23 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Eh? that makes no sense?

Anyhow, it's on the bottom of nearly every phone so they can meet regulations about radiated power into your head. Being a bit further away from your head makes a big difference.

Hows that not make sense!?

Right but only 3" extra away from your head. WTF so not much difference then.

bit bitey my comment there but there you have it. 😛


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 5:39 pm
 IA
Posts: 563
Free Member
 

Why does the antenna being at the bottom mean you need to talk upside down, that makes no sense.

4" or so compared to 1" say makes a big difference. Power drops with the square of the distance, so it's not 1/4 the power into your head, it's a 16th.


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 5:44 pm
Posts: 31206
Full Member
 

Keep nagging at her to get the ****ing bumper. And I'm probably getting something else.
If apple fixed the ****ing prob, the iphone 4 would have been brilliant and outsold HTC easily.

No problem with it here, even if I deliberately bridge the antennas and squeeze. I suspect they quietly fixed it in later builds. Apple did/do offer free bumpers or a choice of free third-party cases to every iPhone 4 owner - maybe she should get one??


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 6:17 pm
Posts: 3573
Free Member
Topic starter
 

phones for you - got a great deal.

just getting to grips with it - it seems excellent so far and the screen is LUSH 🙂


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 7:41 pm
Posts: 78437
Full Member
 

Got my crappy Galaxy replaced this week with a Desire (non-HD). Very impressed so far.

I can't be bothered responding to a lot of the nonsense in here, but to those saying "the iPhone is the best, end of" I'd say, get over yourselves.

The iPhone is a good phone, no question. It's also responsible for a lot of other manufacturers stepping up to the plate, and for that I applaud it also. But is it the best phone ever? The answer to that question is a big fat "it depends."


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 8:36 pm
Posts: 78437
Full Member
 

Oh - re: screen size vs resolution, I have reasonable eyesight, I'll take the highest resolution screen you've got in the smallest form factor you can muster, thanks.


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 8:38 pm
 IA
Posts: 563
Free Member
 

Res vs. form factor is an interesting one one, rather than mentioning screen size.

E.g. my X10 has a 4" screen, noticeable bigger than an iphones 3.5". Yet the phone itself is nearly exactly the same size (couple mm longer, close enough to fit in the same cases etc).

I think when you're dealing with touch screens size matters for usability. It's easier to reach all of a 3.5 screen with one hand, less so with a 4" one.


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 8:44 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I have just upgraded today to a Desire. O2 wanted £59 for it so went to Carphone Warehouse and got it for free on the same tariff I was on previously!
Had a play and seems really easy to use. Only downloaded two apps so far, talking tomcat and google starmaps.


 
Posted : 16/10/2010 8:47 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

The Lecht Rocks - go on then, how much? 😉


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 1:30 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I have an HTC Desire and love it, my wife has an iPhone 4 and loves it.

The iPhone is defo slicker etc and nicely intergrated, you can do far more on the HTC though and if you're at all techy and want to install your own custom roms etc then HTC is way to go.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:03 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

whats the differece in battery life?


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:42 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

whats the differece in battery life?

I'd prob have to give the iPhone the edge here - but with both phones for any reasonable usage you'd be charging every night. Both have plenty for a days good use.

On Android there's a lot of tools you can get to help re batt life and some roms are better than others. Not sure about iPhone.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:48 am
 iolo
Posts: 194
Free Member
 

I got an iphone 4 3 weeks ago as my 3G died in my pocket when I got caught in some serious rain.I loved the 3G - a fantastic phone and I never had a problem with it.
The iphone 4 is the worst thing I've ever had.
I don't think I've had a single call not dropped (if I can get signal at all).
I've just bought a bumper for it but really can't see why we have to do this.I would like a phone to actually make calls without having to buy a flippin cover.
There is an obvious problem with this phone! I am an apple fan but really should have just got a 3GS.
Until this reception problem has been resolved I would suggest you steer clear!


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:52 am
Posts: 3573
Free Member
Topic starter
 

used it all day yesterday and last night and it needed a charge.
the internet via wi-fi is incredibly fast.
intyegrated social apps are brilliant.
but why didn't they use a standard micro-usb for charging / interfacing ????????????


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 8:36 am
Posts: 3712
Free Member
 


[b]What's the SatNav like on the iPhone4?[/b]

Tom Tom, CoPilot, Navmii, GPS Drive, skobbler, Nav free, waze...

Are they free?
(I guess 'Nav Free' is.)


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 8:42 am
Posts: 20
Free Member
 

Got the Galaxy S and really like the phone over the Iphone. Android is very good and the music sound is brilliant(for a phone). The major issue is that if you are running Windows7 64 then you may have trouble getting the Kies software to recognise the phone. No one seems to be working on the problem and we have the usual situation of vendor blaming OS and OS blaming vendor. Where o where is the harmony lol


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 8:50 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

but why didn't they use a standard micro-usb for charging / interfacing ????????????

Are you talking about the Desire? That is a micro usb - that is the standard now!


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 9:13 am
Posts: 31206
Full Member
 

I've just bought a bumper for it but really can't see why we have to do this

You don't. You get it free from Apple.
http://www.apple.com/iphone/case-program/

What's your reception like in your area?
Borderline 3G is worse (for all phones) than decent GPRS. If you are on the edge of a 3G zone then just turn off 3G.

Are they free?

Skobbler and NavFree are free - based on OpenStreetMap data.
Waze is free - good for traffic info but relatively new to the UK and needs more users before the map gets usable.

TomTom et al are around £20.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 9:38 am
 iolo
Posts: 194
Free Member
 

Having to turn off 3g is just a faff you shouldn't expect with a top end phone.
I do a lot of mileage with work and the phone's as bad in good 3g signal as it is in gprs areas.
I never had a problem with my previous iphone.
You have to face the fact that the iphone 4 is not a good phone - end of.
The other toys on it are nice but it should at least make and answer calls without constantly being cut off. Absolute bloody rubbish.
I would not recommend it to anyone.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 9:56 am
Posts: 31206
Full Member
 

iolo: sorry but various independent reviews performed during "antennagate" show the reception on the iPhone 4 is considerably better than on the 3G, which fits with my experience of a 3G, two 3GS and a 4. That was the whole point of putting on a large external antenna.

Just a thought, have you had any carrier updates through iTunes? These can sometimes improve things.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 10:10 am
 iolo
Posts: 194
Free Member
 

I've done all updates.
My previous iphone had full signal at home.
I have to keep this pile of crap on the window sill to get any signal at all!
Seriously, I am not an apple hater (hence the reason I upgraded to an iphone 4) but its really no good in its current state.
Don't bother until this gets resolved.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 10:24 am
Posts: 31206
Full Member
 

Have you had "carrier updates" tho? i.e. NOT iOS updates, like these:

[img] [/img]
http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1970

If you have and it is still crap then I'd take it in and see what they say. The antennagate issue only affects reception on some handsets, when you [u]hold[/u] them in a certain way. On a windowsill or sitting anywhere else your reception should be better than a 3G.

(I'm on O2 v8.0 by the way)


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 10:45 am
 iolo
Posts: 194
Free Member
 

I've done that.
I might just have a dodgy one but I'm not impressed.
Really wish I hadn't bothered now.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 10:51 am
Posts: 31206
Full Member
 

Take it into Apple then.

I took in a 3GS after it got screwed up by an update.
One month out of warranty and they still just gave me a new one on the spot.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 10:56 am
Posts: 78437
Full Member
 

Is it actually a bad signal, or just showing a bad signal?

I'm no iPhone expert, but my understanding was that at least in part the signal meter was showing poor signal when it was actually fine.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 3:26 pm
Posts: 3573
Free Member
Topic starter
 

locations and google maps on the desire hd are just brilliant.
also the camera is exceptional too............
it's not the build quality of he iphone but the interface, the apps and the open architecture are great......
HTC get's my recommendation !


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 3:34 pm
Posts: 31206
Full Member
 

I'm no iPhone expert, but my understanding was that at least in part the signal meter was showing poor signal when it was actually fine.

The "antennagate" software thing was actually the opposite. The original software showed a good signal when it was actually quite weak - so even a small drop in reception, caused by bridging the antennas, looked like it had a huge effect when you were already in a poor area.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 3:37 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

So t_l_r, - what phone did you come from?
What was the deal u got from p4u?

Is the HTC showing any bugs already?

thanks.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 4:01 pm
Posts: 3573
Free Member
Topic starter
 

no bugs - 1st smartphone.............it's great 🙂


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 5:55 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Yes but how much was the tariff? ? ?


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 5:57 pm
Posts: 3573
Free Member
Topic starter
 

18 months @ 35 quid. unlimited text and internet. 300 mins phone - easy.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 6:48 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Wowsers! - you got an ok deal there. 😉

Although I'm sure you could of saved £5 pm if you opted for a 24month.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:34 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

the_lecht_rocks - Member
18 months @ 35 quid. unlimited text and internet. 300 mins phone - easy

What network?


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:36 pm
Posts: 3573
Free Member
Topic starter
 

yeah i could but thats more expensive over the term innit,


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:36 pm
Posts: 3573
Free Member
Topic starter
 

vodafone and number tx'd in less than 4 hours/


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:38 pm
Posts: 78437
Full Member
 

I'm sure you could of saved £5 pm if you opted for a 24month.

... and paid an extra £90 in total.


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:39 pm
Posts: 31206
Full Member
 

If you are on O2 check your contract small print. You can often move to a different deal after just 9 months!
(which means 24 month contracts don't have to cost more and can actually be cheaper)


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:39 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I'm with T-Mobile but liked the deal Vodafone are offering so will do some bargaining next week and see how flexible they can be.

Whats surfing the net like, can you browse stw ok on it?


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 7:47 pm
Posts: 3573
Free Member
Topic starter
 

yes - super super quick over wifi


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 8:02 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I'm due an upgrade with Vodafone been using a htc hd2 for the last year so i thought i would try an iPhone 4 got one sent and its super slick easy to use and there are loads of apps but i really didn't like the lack of customization even simple things on my hd2 like using mp3 trimmer to make and select a custom ringtone is a chore with the iPhone and i like plugging my phone in the pc and just dragging and dropping files in seconds also for me the lack of widgets and info on the homescreen is something on my htc i use and rely on everytime i go to my homescreen it reminds me of calendar events and tasks without setting reminders and without having to remember to go into the calendar app
Don't get me wrong the iPhone is a really nice phone but imo its not worth the extra you have to pay for it I've ordered a desire hd which works out £200 cheaper over my 2yr contract


 
Posted : 17/10/2010 11:15 pm
Posts: 78437
Full Member
 

I'd change phones if I were you, it looks like all your punctuation keys are buggered as well.


 
Posted : 18/10/2010 11:44 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Does anyone have a Desire HD on pre-order? any idea when they will be released?


 
Posted : 18/10/2010 12:07 pm
Posts: 4130
Free Member
 

I think I fixed my GF IP4 prob with skype - skype has a prob of cutting out on iphone4 a lot.

Used other VoIP while not as good as skype they work well in fact I might get one as none of the HTC's I can get have face pointing cameras.

Not looking forward to the recption probs though.


 
Posted : 19/10/2010 9:41 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Torminalis - Member
Does anyone have a Desire HD on pre-order? any idea when they will be released?

mines pre-ordered and should arrive tomorow which is the release date,

this is what finaly sold it to me, looks amazing, and isnt as restricted as an iphone


 
Posted : 22/10/2010 12:37 am
Page 2 / 3