[Closed] XTR or XT?

i have full XTR drivetrain on my Nicolai. light shift action and reliable but I reckon X0 is snappier and faster.

Medium cage will work fine on a 1x10. I think the 35 you are looking at is probably the capacity rather than the maximum sprocket size.

Whats the difference between capacity and maximum sprocket size?

If you're sponsored, XTR. If you're paying, XT.

You'll not notice the difference.

Xtr in the shifters if you want the super nice feel, xt parts beyond those. You won't feel so bad about a bent mech then.

Also wanted to go for medium cage as I run 1x10 but the range of that is apparently 35t on the cassette?

Will be absolutely fine, running a medium on my 2X10 setup with 24-36 rings and 11-36 cassette.

Would go for XTR shifters and XT for everything else.

Just looking at the zee shadow plus mech, anybody got any input on those? My brain says xt but the 15 year old kid inside me that used to wish I could have the high end stuff is mighty strong!

I run a XTR shifter and 10 speed short cage Saint mech with a 36t chain ring and 11 to 36 cassette no bother at all. I also have a XT shifter and medium cage XT mech with the same gear combo. The XTR gives a better more positive shift than the XT. Both mechs are clutch type.

XTR if you can afford it - It's definitely nicer but not massively so. The shifters in particular feel nicer but it's not night and day.

Hi, I run XT 10 speed on my trek remedy. I used to run the chain and cassette as well but fond the shifting was not as smooth, once changed to SRAM 11-36 cassette with kmc x10 SL chain the shifting is super smooth and work really well with the rental chainring. Only thing I would change is the shifters for xtr as they look better built.

My brain says xt but the 15 year old kid inside me that used to wish I could have the high end stuff is mighty strong!

If your happy to replace it in the event of a crash then go for it.

Zee is basically an SLX mech with a short cage.

Capacity is the difference between sprocket sizes, so if you are running a 1x10 with a 11 to 36 casstte you need a mech with a capacity of 25 (36 minus 11) or more.

Im running XTR shifter and mech on a 1x10 setup. The shifter feels lovely and mech shifts fine. I also have a SLX shifter and mech setup 1x10 and I can honestly say that the mech change feels the same. The difference is in the shifter. Still like my XTR for bling and weight factor though!

Cool I think I'm going to go with the xtr stuff, I've got enough in my secret little fund, I am curious to try the zee stuff when I build up a hardtail next year tho, I have heard good things about KMC chains but also herd they don't like certain cleaning products is this true?

In my opinion there is no difference in feel between XT and SLX apart from the shifters. So if there is no difference in feel with XTR and XT apart form the shifters, then surely XTR shifters and SLX everything else is the way forward.

When new, there's not really much difference in 'feel' between XT and, say, deore shifters + mech. Both systems will shift pretty well if setup accurately. However, the deore system will develop slop and will start to perform badly after a while. This process seems to take a lot longer on higher spec stuff, presumably because the quality of bushings/bearings/pivots/springs etc is just better quality. Just because SLX feels like XTR now, doesn't mean it will after a year's worth of gritty rides.

Full XTR here, and if I was to go economy at all it'd be the cassette.

[quoteFull XTR here, and if I was to go economy at all it'd be the cassette.

+1 I'll be going XT when my xtr wears out. The rest of the kit however is top class, just shifts soooo well 🙂

Really don't like the feel of the latest XTR... My SLXs are really nice and XT is similiar, but XTR goes back to classic Shimano vagueness and disconnectedness. Oh and really not a fan of the double-shift thing, too easy to do it by mistake. Maybe I'd get used to that, who knows.

It all works but I wouldn't have it on my bikes.

I feel the love from my shifters, not as smooth as my LX verions it might suprise you to hear; quite harsh but straight in..if you get me.

I've not had much luck with the yumeya chain, Scram (with holes) a world (better) apart.

The less said about the XTR ti(AKA Cheese) cassette the better.

My personal opinion is XTR is just a money spinner, if you pardon the pun: can you really tell the difference between XT/XTR when the entire drive train is covered in UK winter mud, grass etc

I beg to differ, looks great in the car park tho.....which in Triathlon is THE most important factor.

Love and kisses.

If you're sponsored, XTR. If you're paying, XT.

You'll not notice the difference.

Having both on different bikes I can confirm the wrongness of this post.

If I had to economise I'd make the rear mech XT but the shifters & front mech XTR. XT cassette too.

Mr P's comments are spot on too.

Strangely enough I've had nothing but problems with my XTR RH shifter - keeps jamming and both leavers go completely loose and you can't change gear at all. A right PITA.

Not that impressed by xtr mech, seems to need everything else set up perfectly. Big fan of xt shifters, way better than deore/slx , and surely xtr shifters can't be much better?