[Closed] Which crankset?

Do you still want to keep it a Shimano free zone? I've got 970 XTR cransk on one bike and RaceFace Turbine LP with brank new rings on the other bike and I know which is better by a country mile.

The bike is currently a Shimano freezone, and I was wondering if you guys have any suggestions?

I suggest you buy some Shimano cranks. You can't get better for the money at whatever price point you choose. That's for a HL 5-Spot mind. If it was DW or faux bar you'd obviously need different cranks to an HL.

Middleburns.

I'd steer clear of Race Face based upon my own experience... Shonky bottom brackets and a crank interface that gave up the ghost causing irreparable wobbles after just eighteen months.

It's Shimano all the way... Although I do quite like Truvativ's stuff of late.

Agree with Johnners, SLX or XT and stop being so precious.

😉

I would recommend middleburn. RS7's with a proper square taper and a top quality BB - TA, Royce etc.

Quality, if you have a problem you can speak to the man that made them and he is helpful. RS7's have lifeteam warrenty.

Light and quite well priced against XTR

+1 for RS7's

Top quality and very pretty. Mine are square taper to and as long as you tighten up your crank bolts enough they are amazing. And as above top quality customer service. And British tooooooo.......

My bikes are also Shimano free zones........

i tried some middleburns and they 'felt funny'. different q factor or something?
have had truvativs and they blow goats IMHO. BB failed on one set and the other set never stayed tight until the splines became worn. mate of mine runs cheap hossfelt ( sp? ) ones and likes 'em though, so YMMV.
i use shimano.

Fifteen.G for something a little different(and light):

[img] [/img]

I like the look of those Fifeteen.Gs, anyone, running them yet? Middleburn are also a possiblity, is there any news on the possible integrated axle version yet?

Truvativ BB's are made of cheese. Just switched to a 2 ring SLX and really impressed at the quality for the price. Merlin have some really good deals on XT at the moment

Fifteen G's look great - XTR weight (well near as dammit) / XT price.

Aren't those Fifteen G cranks BB30 only? If not then I want some...

Where can you buy the Fifteen G cranks/BB from? Whats wrong with a BB30?

Nothing wrong with BB30 at all, except my frame isn't compatible.

5 bikes 3 SLX 2 XT

They're screw in cups, with BB30 size bearings according to their website.

Cheers for that... I didn't realise they were screw in cups. Many thanks.

Used XT on this years bike - done 1300 miles on it and the rings are worn but still OK but I've changed the bottom bracket. Much better than previous Shimano attempts and Middleburn rings. Complete crankset inc BB are £120 @ Merlin till Sunday.

Not a trendy choice but On One have got the FSA V Drive at 65 quid. It's not the prettiest but it lasts a long time. When I bought one a couple of years ago it was top choice on MTBR and I can't fault it. I've swapped rings and BBs but otherwise it's going fine.

Just bought an SLX from Melin for £85 which I think is good value.

Not really sure what's the difference between SLX and XT other than an handful of grams, different design and £40 odd quid.

Sorry to hear about you guys with no Shimano on your bikes. Hope it's better soon. 😉

i've got 2x Truvativ Howitzers on my DH and normal bike, much better sealed than the shimano and RF BBs, just changing the normal bike one after 3 years, inc 2 strathpuffers.

not light, but damn sturdy adn long lasting.

those 15Gs look nice 😀

I've got SLX one one bike and it's a great crank-set, BB is lasting up well at 12 months so far including lots of wet Welsh rides.

Got a Raceface Evolve XC on t'other, the BB died a horrid death after 10 months of muddy, wet, sandy Delamere forest. It's now been repalced with a Pro-lite stainless BB for £29, winner, smooth as chocolate and hopefully not as soft

"Not really sure what's the difference between SLX and XT"
SLX replaces LX, so a bit heavier and an bit cheaper.