Forum menu
From 3x to 1x
 

[Closed] From 3x to 1x

Posts: 0
Free Member
Topic starter
 
[#7120562]

I've never been one for following the trends, far from it, but after a bit of research I've been wondering about changing my set up from it's current 3x9 to 1x"something". As far as I can tell the benefits of simplicity, de-clutter the crank area (so hard to get the gunk out of the front mech all the time), less chance of chain fouling up and all the rest of it outweigh the loss of the granny ring and outer ring. The frame is a Marin mount vision (2008). It's not a 'trail' bike in today's 27.5 terms but slapped a hans damp on the front, nobby nic on the back and it's just fun all the way and that's surely got to count for something, I'm not getting bogged down in the wheel size faff, I've go a nippy HT so this one's for fun (fast fun ๐Ÿ™‚ )
99.99% of the time I'm in the middle ring (32T) and I could probably count the number of times I've hit the granny ring on one hand, the outer perhaps on two! I'm pretty light so it doesn't take much to get up the hills or gather speed on the down!
Is a 1x10 mech with 'clutch' absolutely necessary? if that's the case, and unless I've got it wrong in my mind, a move to 1x10 requires pretty much a whole new rear gear system (not to mention the drive ring to something like a race face NW). Just checked and my cassette is a 11-34, my assumption was a 10spd cassette would give a larger inner cog though I notice they still only go up to 34 and 36T which sort of negates their need... Hope do a 40T ring, does anyone use anything like that or does 36T do the job fine?
seems like I've found a can of worms and it's rather entertaining to think of the possibilities once it's opened!


 
Posted : 09/06/2015 8:41 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

after a bit of research

That's your answer, right there :o)


 
Posted : 09/06/2015 8:58 pm
Posts: 21643
Full Member
 

Or just get a narrow/wide ring and try it 1x9


 
Posted : 09/06/2015 9:02 pm
Posts: 2883
Full Member
 

I went 1x on my hardtail by just ditching the 2 unused rings and putting a 32t NW up front. Not needed a clutch mech, yet, and the original cassette hasn't been too limiting. Might go to the Praxis works 11-40..? If dropping the chain becomes a problem maybe a guide before a Clutch mech.

So before jumping in and swapping everything over in one go, do it bit by bit. You might find things work out just fine.


 
Posted : 09/06/2015 10:14 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
Topic starter
 

valid points. I think it's a bit easier on an HT as the chain stay length doesn't change...on most fs it does change a bit as travel goes up/down...


 
Posted : 10/06/2015 11:18 am