Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
  • Who or Whom
  • womp
    Free Member

    Which would be technically correct in this sentence….

    Can you confirm who this applies to ?
    Can you confirm to who this applies ?
    Can you confirm whom this applies ?
    Can you confirm whom this applies to ?
    Can you confirm to whom this applies ?

    twicewithchips
    Free Member

    Last one, but I wouldn’t put a space before the question mark.
    IIRC whom is used when the answer is ‘him’ and who when the answer is ‘he’ (whom is the object form of who).
    Prepositions are bad things to end a sentence with. (see wot I dun there!)

    BigDummy
    Free Member

    Can you confirm who this applies to ?
    Can you confirm to who this applies ?
    Can you confirm whom this applies ?
    Can you confirm whom this applies to ?
    Can you confirm to whom this applies ?

    I think…

    Smudger666
    Full Member

    Bad grammar is something up with which I will not put!

    BigDummy
    Free Member

    IIRC whom is used when the answer is ‘him’ and who when the answer is ‘he’ (whom is the object form of who).

    Agreed. So [can you confirm] who/whom this applies to?

    It applies to him (not he) => whom

    🙂

    womp
    Free Member

    Cheers , I knowed STW would not fail me, as they say “who you going to call… errr hang on

    orangespyderman
    Full Member

    Prepositions are bad things to end a sentence with. (see wot I dun there!)

    Actually, there’s nothing wrong with it. It’s an entirely artifical and somewhat pompous stylistic constraint, not a rule of grammar.

    See :
    http://blog.oxforddictionaries.com/2011/11/grammar-myths-prepositions/

    and

    https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/grammar/ending-sentences-with-prepositions

    MrSalmon
    Free Member

    I’d also say the last one, but I don’t think there’s anything necessarily one with the last but one either. Didn’t know the him/he reasoning though.

    Tallpaul
    Free Member

    IMO 1 and 5 are fine. 2 and 4 are dodgy, but I wouldn’t correct them. Only 3 is outright incorrect. I clearly won’t ever get a job with the Grammar Police.

    MrSalmon
    Free Member

    I’d correct 2 and 3 for sure if they cam across my desk. Maybe 1 as well but I’d have to be feeling a bit more pedantic.

    copa
    Free Member

    First one. There’s never a need to use whom, unless you’re trying to sound all legal.

    Northwind
    Full Member

    “Whom” is on the way out anyway, give it a couple more years and only pedants, costume drama writers and Miss Jean Brodie will even remember it.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    To whom am I giving it? ‘Whom’ is a person to which something is being done (giving). Otherwise it’s who.

    Who is it? Just a question, without something being done to anyone.

    seosamh77
    Free Member

    What is really ment… Who’s getting hit with this shit? 😆

    maccruiskeen
    Full Member

    Womp or Whomp?

    perchypanther
    Free Member

    Womp or Whomp?

    Wampa

    Nico
    Free Member

    None of the above. Confirm is the wrong word. “Can you confirm it applies to Fred”, or “Can you tell me to whom it applies”.

    Whom is quite formal* and in many cases “Can you tell me who it applies to?” is perfectly good.

    * I think it is something to do with being the object. “The rule applies to Fred” has the subject of the rule and object of Fred. “Who came to work yesterday” – who is the subject and there’s no object.

    Pedantic? Your welcome!

    Scapegoat
    Full Member

    If you want a pure grammar answer, it’s case sensitive. Who is nominative , whom is accusative (direct) or dative (indirect) (simplified to objective in English grammar as there is no distinction between the two).

    maccruiskeen
    Full Member

    Surely this is a question for Child Prodigy Simon Fisher

    CharlieMungus
    Free Member

    Can you confirm to whom it is that this applies

    howsyourdad1
    Free Member

    who gives a shit

    not whom gives shit

    deadkenny
    Free Member

    Doctor Who

    or

    Doctor Whom

    niksnr
    Free Member

    What if it’s a ‘she’?

    sirromj
    Full Member

    who gives a shit

    not whom gives shit

    To whom does one give a shit?

    What if it’s a ‘she’?

    Confirm who this applies to!

Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)

The topic ‘Who or Whom’ is closed to new replies.