It’s for a Monstercross bike so fast is a key consideration, although I don’t find the crossmark (ace tyre) particularlly slow, just after something a bit narrower.
I had 26er Burts and while they are great for what they are I feel that the Specialized Renegades have a wider window of use.
I have the 29er 1.95 Controls and don’t feel I sacrifice any grip compared to 2.2 Ikons (generally considered a grippy if slightly slow XC race tyre) but they are of course a bit faster. The Renegades have performed really well whether it be rocky, damp, rooty, whatever.
You probably lose some comfort over a bigger volume tyre, but like the Burts, they are very supple so make up for it in ride quality. Since the Control casing on these extends uder the tread, as well as the sidewalls I’m hopefully they hold up better than my Burts around the tread. The tradeoff for this is that they are 1100g/ pair in the control version- so not hugely light.
The 2.3 Renegades look interesting (if they actually come to the UK) but I think you’ll need a decently wide rim to get the most from them as they don’t have the greatest sidewall stability in reviews online