Forum menu
Ahem.
I have a [i]friend[/i] who claimed some expenses. When they were paid into [i]their[/i] bank account [i]they[/i] noticed that the amount was FAR FAR in excess of what they had claimed. Something like 12.5 times as much, well into a 4-figure sum.
My [i]friend[/i] knows what [i]they[/i] should do about this, but has seen something similar happen before to one of [i]their[/i] family and indeed to [i]themselves[/i] in the past, knows how dumb some companies can be, and so [i]they[/i] are temped to put the money in an ISA, sit on it for a bit, and see what happens.....
What would [u]you[/u] do?
😀
If he moves the money - he can't claim he didn't know about it
It's often a bank error that gets reversed though
I don't know such things never happen in academia 😉
should you keep someone else's money? where is the dilemma?
I'd pay it back promptly. Sorry. 🙂
Companies aren't stupid, and auditors are even less so.
PP's moral maze...
[img] 
[/img]
I once cashed in some shares and recieved double the payment. We moved the mponey after a few weeks into a savings account and said if it is still there in a couple of years we would consider it ours (Lots of hastle with the co so didnt feel like stealing). Anyhow it took them a good 12mths and they came back with a request for the return of their money (A few grand). Thankfully we handnt touched it so just returned it to them.
Imagine getting that call and not having the money there cos he has spent it. I bet it would feel 10 X worse than the feeling he has now about getting the extra
If I find any shiny bike bling in the garage when I get home you are in serious trouble.....
LOL at Ms pody. Mind you peter, she said nothing about a multistrada 😀
Eh? This is nothing to do with ME! It's my [i]friend[/i]
And my [i]friend[/i] wouldn't be silly enough to do anything like that. Oh noooooooo.
I would pay it back and sleep well 😉
Once a few years back, in a different job, where I used to get paid monthly by cheque. I got a pay cheque in my name for £1.6m the pay slip was made out to my normal monthly wage, so a monumental error.
Payrol had paid me what a supplier should have received that month by mistake.
I had a Director and security in my office within seconds of telling payroll of their mix-up over the phone!
They obviously trusted me 😉
Agree with Ski. Think if you did keep the money you wouldn't be able to have a clear mind. I would return it.
if your friend is a permie for this company then they should own up
else sit on the money for a bit but don't spend it for at least a few years
big companies aren't stupid when it comes to financials just slow and thorough so they will notice sooner or later.
is it ethical to spend work time thinking about an answer ?
permie
Is this an Australianism?
is it ethical to spend work time thinking about an answer ?
Indeed. My [i]friend[/i] thinks not, and will therefore only take action out of work hours, when, unfortunately, the cashiers department is closed. Drat.
Should pay it back and as said above then sleep well
Mind you we do need new carpets and as you are not around because of the hours you spend at work (over 55 hours a week...) maybe I should take it from your friend as compensation. Oh what a dilema
right I'm a honest sort or a chap
but if 1.6m Stirling got payed into my account
Swiss bank &buy buy 😈 for shore
sorry ski 😉
4-figure sum??
if it was, say, a 6-7 figure sum then i'd say definitely keep the money, leg it to a different country and change your identity.
Would you though the the fettler?
Its one thing saying you would and another actually doing it.
I know a friend of a friend who after a bank credited him £400k in error did a runner, think he managed to keep free for two years before the dosh ran out and they caught up with him.
Now his life is in a real bad place 😉
Yea you called me?
would think hard about it!
have read to much espionage/crime stuff & already have an alternative id set up 😉
have a word with accounts and ask if your friends pay is correct, don't tell them theve paid you too much.
otherwise see if you can bulk buy bbb10 tickets.
My Wife would probably do a runner though if it had happened now.
would she include me in the plan is another question?
😉
You lot are waaaay too honest!
Keep it, a few grand might not be noticed. Simply be prepared to give it back if they ask for it. Happened to me once and I ended up keeping it. Nothing ventured...
Guys, I've already orgainised paying back the £976 I've been overpaid.
Always knew I would. Just a bit of gentle leg pulling. 🙂
Madness!
I've already orgainised paying back the £976 I've been overpaid.
is that all ? I have so much money I wouldn't have noticed that :o)
You just earnt some MASSIVE karma points!
you had better hope MrsP hasn't already ordered the new carpets then 🙄
I'd have had a new chainset and some flash wheels before she had the chance to order carpets! It mine, all mine, I tell ya!
I have so much money I wouldn't have noticed that :o)
And I bet you're still riding round on that shonky ripped up saddle though, you pikey!
😉
PP YOU LIED TO US! Obviously you have no friends if you have to make them up!
Personally i'd have kept hold of it and sat on it for about 18 months, if no one claims it back schweet, if they do at least you've managed to get some interest off it!
Obviously you have no friends if you have to make them up!
Yes. That's right. Of course I don't. 😉
Personally i'd have kept hold of it and sat on it for about 18 months, if no one claims it back schweet, if they do at least you've managed to get some interest off it!
Turns out they'd mixed my claim up with someone with the same surname. I'm sure they'd have found out when he started shouting!
This happened to the missus and we did the honnest thing and paid it back. The house still needs redecorating but atleast we can sleep well at night.
And I bet you're still riding round on that shonky ripped up saddle though, you pikey!
no, it's been replaced - but any fule noes that one does not become rich by spending...
Obviously you have no friends if you have to make them up!
yes, that did undermine the credibility of the story!
[father ted]
that money was just [b]resting[/b] in my account
once got overpaid by a months wages at work (first proper job when i was 17)- took it all out the account in case it was a mistake and clamied back. walked around with a grand in my pocket for three days - was too scared to leave it anywhere - then found out it was my holiday pay for the first year!! 😮
Premium bonds are perfect for this situation. You can get the money back quickly but while you've got it there's always the chance of a prize.
soma_rich - Member
You just earnt some MASSIVE karma points!
Ha. Ha. Ha.
Did I? I think not.
I've just got home to find the £5k bathroom we thought was PAID FOR isn't. They made an error in the bill and we owe them £91.
Karma? Yeah, right.
[i]Did I? I think not.
I've just got home to find the £5k bathroom we thought was PAID FOR isn't. They made an error in the bill and we owe them £91.
Karma? Yeah, right. [/i]
You wait, it will come back this week sometime.
One word. Audit.
🙂
Oh, one more word. Morals
🙂
Presumably the 4 figures include the pence?
Return it.