Forum menu
True, but Trump leaving office is no guarantee that it will be fixed either
Got to agree. It's difficult not to think that Trump got in because a lot of people were already being failed by existing politics and possibly even our acceptance of current systems.
Those Tweets up there. Not working for anyone else?
Those Tweets up there. Not working for anyone else?
Its a bit random. Some work but usually you have to click on the 'x people are talking about this' link underneath to go to the original tweet and then you can see it
Should be a cautionary tale for the UK: the consequences of unchecked capitalism and a astronomically large wealth gap. Unfortunately we ve got/ we're getting hitched onto this
The US is third world in so many regards.
Anyone who thinks this is a result of a trump government however is sadly incorrect. Police officers were killing innocent black people during the Obama regime, the only difference was that he wasn't more or less championing it on Twitter.
In fact it's almost better that the current buffoon is so open with it, it means they can't hide behind misunderstood policy and grey areas, he is just outwardly, obviously and publicly racist.
It is the Western equivalent of Saudi Arabia / Russia / China etc etc, they have so much in common politically.
The thought of living there is terrifying
The thought of living there is terrifying
I agree, good ol USA is off the scale nuts right now. Police brutality, school shootings, COVID, right wing malitia/racists, a President who makes things worse every day. They seriously need to sort their shit out, quickly.
Anyone who thinks this is a result of a trump government however is sadly incorrect.
Some blame can be clearly laid at his feet, he's both encouraged shooting of protesters (US Citizens) and he's clearly abdicated all responsibility for taking any sort of leadership, or calming role.
As a very distant observer I don’t understand what’s going on, Clearly the cop was wrong and has been rightly arrested and charged. I don’t understand why that then turns into riots. If people want to protest peacefully then great, let them as they have the right to do so but why the violence, why the looting? As others have said the USA appears very divided but that seems to be more on wealth than race. Look out how sport is now dominated by non white people earning lottery salaries, same in the entertainment sector, music, acting etc. The previous president was black so clearly it is possible to get to the top if you have enough money behind you
I think what we’re seeing is an uprising of the lower classes who have been abandoned, exploited and abused by a rich (mostly) white minority who care only about themselves. Their ‘agenda’ is living in a society with some basic human decency where people aren’t left to rot and aren’t treated as sub-human because they’re black or poor
Not sure it's the start of a revolution, but I think dazh has it here - it started as a race issue, it's become a wider social issue.
As a very distant observer I don’t understand what’s going on, Clearly the cop was wrong and has been rightly arrested and charged. I don’t understand why that then turns into riots. If people want to protest peacefully then great, let them as they have the right to do so but why the violence, why the looting?
Years of anger and repression coming to the surface. The cop has been charged, the other cops who were with him haven’t and the charges levelled at him aren’t severe enough. I’m not sure how you can’t understand it to be honest. The people have just had enough. The place has been a powder keg for years now. Trump, Covid, unemployment, police brutality and the steady rise of the far right have set it off.
Look out how sport is now dominated by non white people earning lottery salaries, same in the entertainment sector, music, acting etc.
Look at that ... and look at the size of he American prison population and who it consists of - and compare it the prison population of 'all of the rest of the world'
Not sure it’s the start of a revolution, but I think dazh has it here – it started as a race issue, it’s become a wider social issue.
Hedge fund owners have been predicting a social revolution for years due to wealth/social inequality Link last year at Davis (Tudor Jones has a ted talk up from 2015)
AOC scares the shit out of them
The cop has been charged with third degree murder and second degree manslaughter. The others are pending investigation whilst all the evidence comes in and time to analyse it.
The charges seeem appropriate.
How is this getting off light?
If people want to protest peacefully then great, let them as they have the right to do so but why the violence, why the looting?
How naive? Peaceful protest has evidently not worked. What the point in protesting peacefully if no one is listening? Always amazes me that people tolerate and excuse violence when it's perpertrated by emloyees of the state, yet howl in outrage the minute a protestor breaks a window. Millions in the US have nothing left to lose, they've been left with no jobs, no income, and no protection from covid, and if they step out of line they risk being shot by a gun-toting idiot in a uniform. I'm amazed that many of them are still protesting peacefully instead of taking up arms.
A lot of people on both sides? Heard that phrase before somewhere, Not sure if that is what you meant boomerlives.
I meant exactly that.
While some people see an excuse to loot Target the original reason to be on the streets is being eroded.
Some others hide behind a riot shield and a badge and use the opportunity to crack some heads and meet out what they think justice is.
Neither are right. Both think they are on the side of good.
It's all distracting from what BLM are trying to get across
The charges seeem appropriate.
Depends (I had to google this as I'd never heard of it before), 3rd degree murder fits in with the "he was just doing his job" narrative. It's used when a persons actions result in a death but they're indifferent to that. e.g. used to convict drug dealers when a user dies, there's no need for malice or intent.
2nd degree murder would be that he intended to kill George Floyd. It's a tough one as with (minutes (or was it 9?) of him begging that he couldn't breath could be argued that the officer knew he was killing him.
It also downplays the racist element. Even if you don't think the cop was overtly individually racist (but the justice system is and therefore individuals get conditioned by that). As racism would make it more malicious.
It’s not just about George Floyd, him being murdered by police was just a recent example with clear footage that was enough to trigger off protests . There’s been a load of other incidents but footage either doesn’t exist (cops not turning on body cams or the footage getting ‘lost’) or is poor quality or from a bad angle that allows for debate over what happened so the police haven’t been forced to take action and the cop has just ended up on a short period of paid leave. Even if they do get sacked they are often quickly reemployed by the force in a neighbouring county, it’s a joke. The police union has way too much power as well
I don't think the cops were charged until after the film became public and after the protests.
I don’t think they would get a conviction out of a second degree murder, you yourself are having a hard time deciding on it.
He will most probably only be convicted of manslaughter.
Charging a cop is complex and takes time, by forcing the police to charge him quickly I think they will have a worst case.
The charges seeem appropriate.
How is this getting off light?
He knelt on a man’s neck until that man died. Said man begged for him to stop and repeatedly outlined that he couldn’t breathe. This went on for nine minutes. He murdered him, second or first degree should be the charge. How did George Floyd pose a threat exactly?
There are also other (eight I read) reports against this officer of overtly racist behaviour. They should be launching the book at that cops face with a trebuchet and making an example of him. They won’t though and the cops in the US will carry on acting as the racist thugs they are. Without some serious changes with how the police are held to account in the US this sort of thing will just continue to happen.
I used to hang around here a bit in ye olde dayes - working from home means I'm visiting again.
Currently living in Richmond VA. Quite a lot of trouble over the weekend, from windows smashed to a bus and buildings set on fire. There are hundreds of legitimate reasons for people to protest about race and violence and they range from casual to systemic.
Moving here from the UK blew my mind on a lot of levels. Seeing police with almost no skills between "shout" and 'shoot" is so different from British police and their methods. A potentially armed population does change things, but not that much.
The institutionalized racism isn't always obvious to a white man who didn't grow up here. Some is, some isn't. I've worked to treat living here like a field trip and never stopped trying to learn. In some ways, America is quite like the UK. In so many other ways the differences are astounding. A lot of the problems here are the same as others around the world. A lot are uniquely American, and America has layers upon layers to try and get through, and not everyone wants to get through them.
Police brutality, especially white police on black citizens, is endemic and has been for decades.
Peaceful protest is an oxymoron. Martin Luther is rightly eulogied for his enormous contribution.
It is a myth however that it was peaceful protest that bought about the Civil Rights legislation. Do we really think it would have passed without the threat that was posed by Malcolm X and particularly the Black Panthers, who took up arms against the police and seceded from the state, setting up a parallel social infrastructure.
What's the demand Inkster?
chrismac
Subscriber
As a very distant observer I don’t understand what’s going on, Clearly the cop was wrong and has been rightly arrested and charged. I don’t understand why that then turns into riots.
MSP
Subscriber
I don’t think the cops were charged until after the film became public and after the protests.
I think this is what sparked a lot of the original protests because it looked like no action was going to be taken. Perhaps if he had been immediately arrested (and charged) the situation would not have escalated as badly.
chrismac
SubscriberAs a very distant observer I don’t understand what’s going on, Clearly the cop was wrong and has been rightly arrested and charged. I don’t understand why that then turns into riots. If people want to protest peacefully then great, let them as they have the right to do so but why the violence, why the looting? As others have said the USA appears very divided but that seems to be more on wealth than race
This isn't the only time this has happened. This happens a lot more than you see reported. It turned into mass protests.
Some of the violence comes from those protesting. Some of the violence comes from others attaching themselves to the protesting for other reasons. Some of the violence comes from the police. There's more and more news coming through of groups, some right wing, whose people have been out there mixing it up. In my local city there's footage of a group of white men armed with rifles out last night. Friends in the city say those protesting largely went home, and they saw lots of young idiots taking advantage of the situation after that. Police are using baton rounds, mace, tear gas, armed vehicles etc and very aggressive tactics.
Why can't America be divided on wealth AND race? Seriously, I never appreciated the racial aspect until I lived here.
We can debate what the straw was that broke the camel's back but this was inevitable, as someone mentioned earlier, the hedge fund managers have been expecting it for ages.
Would it have made a difference if the four policemen had been arrested and charged immediately? Maybe, but it would have only postponed the inevitable, until the next video goes viral.
The problems are far more systemic than that, from the voting in of police comissioners, funding the police through fining the public, so they prey on the poor and the Black especially, to the militarization of the police, the prison industrial complex, massive Republican led voter disenfranchisement and the political gerrymandering of districts creating a 21st Century version of segregation.
Don't expect peacfull protest and opening up a 'conversation about race' to achieve anything. As Malcom X said: You've got to make unreasonable demands to make reasonable gains'
inkster
MemberDon’t expect peacfull protest and opening up a ‘conversation about race’ to achieve anything. As Malcom X said: You’ve got to make unreasonable demands to make reasonable gains
Yep. There's a reason people remember Rodney King's name, 20 years on. And corona has proved once again how much the US appraises things in terms of economic impact.
This is worth reading for some context:
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/minneapolis-police-rendered-44-people-unconscious-neck-restraints-five-years-n1220416
Resources for anti racism learning here. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ko1dRVSUtpDntIZ5SrewALLhcMDuhe69Om31oOHIkh8/mobilebasic
It's not a question of good cop bad cop, they're only doing the job for which they've been trained and equipped. In a crisis you get an extreme response. A few die, many intimidated, some apologies for a bad apple and a promise that it won't happen again till next time.
mehr
Subscriber
The ****Mayor of Simp City
@jusalotofpain
This video of Grand Rapids PD firing a tear gas canister at an unarmed man (right after they maced him) point blank to the face needs to VIRAL. what in the actual **** are these pigs doingEmbedded video
By playing this video you agree to Twitter's use of cookiesLearn moreOK
24.7K
03:05 - 2 Jun 2020
Twitter Ads information and privacy
18.5K people are talking about this
Posted 27 minutes ago
That is shocking. You can tell by the ricochet how fast that thing is moving. I hope the bloke was ok.
Yup, always the same! 'Lessons have been learnt' is always my favourite!
May have been said before but the difference now is that the police etc have been given a green light to do what they want and now, thanks to Trump, even the City Mayors etc have been undermined.
If many of you are wondering why the cops in the US seem so especially prepared to use violence, violent methods and treat most citizens as if they're going to kill every cop in sight.... You could worse than look into the activities of Lt Col. Grossman and his training methods that have been adopted by many many US police forces; not least (you'll be no doubt hugely surprised to hear) the Minneapolis Police Dept.
Killology - why cops in America want to kill you first and ask questions later
Killology – why cops in America want to kill you first and ask questions later
grim reading. worse is that i got served an advert for a belt phone carrier that looks like a gun holster - I wonder what demographic could happily walk around with one of those on...
Policing, protest and changes to COVID-19 control measures ...
This paper responds to a Home Office commission to SAGE/SPI-B Security and
Policing Sub-Group for expert advice about the COVID-19 risks from public protest in
the event that lockdown is eased. The commission was received on Tuesday 28th April
2020.
Now the US military are flying helicopters at extremely low level over protesters, in contravention of FAA rules, the crews are fully armed with night-vision equipment, and it seems the FBI are involved, plus the US Coast Guard have been flying an unarmed Reaper drone as well.
https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/33802/military-helicopters-descend-on-washington-in-bizarre-very-low-altitude-show-of-force
The UK model of police enforcement has been very restrained. Our expectation is that this approach of engage, explain, encourage and enforce has helped support high levels of legitimacy for police action and Government policy among the public. The associated strong levels of ‘self-regulation’ seem likely to be carried forward.
you do realise when spoken with a Southern US drawl it sounds like “blast ‘em with tasers”, right?
https://twitter.com/jysexton/status/1267456621615218694?s=21
The most accurate summary of why trump has gained power in the USA from a Georgia professor, well worth a read (will only take a few mins)
Now the psychopath-in-chief has peaceful protestors tear gassed just to allow him free passage to stand in front of a church with a Bible in his hand to pose and pontificate. Scumbag.
https://apnews.com/09f54acd0aadf861ea3aadc5b79c0fd8