MTBR and Pinkbike I like for different reasons (loads of good info in the MTBR forums) but in both cases the screen is a little too busy for viewing when you should be working in an open office
I agree about how busy some forums look, I've always liked how simple this one is and it's been great to see that carried over into the update. Maybe that's why this forum is so full of old giffers like me! Lol
For technical bike chat with people who seem pretty clued by I find mtbr pretty good. You’ll sometimes get manufacturers on there replying as well.
Some great stuff on mtbr and it's been going ages - but have you ever seen a more fragmented forum? 130 sub-forums on mountain biking sounds like a deliberate joke. Still, if you want to know what tyres for 29er gravel fat bike ridden in the state of Arizona, they'll be someone there to tell you.
Still, if you want to know what tyres for 29er gravel fat bike ridden in the state of Arizona, they’ll be someone there to tell you.
Pretty sure someone would be along to advise on here if asked...
You generally can't fault this place for someone being able to help out with something entirely random and off the wall.
Having said that, no one has been able to tell me what the theme tune to mine heist on Netflix keeps reminding me of.
Having said that, no one has been able to tell me what the theme tune to mine heist on Netflix keeps reminding me of.
Dire Straits innit.
That opening bit is very Knopfleresque. Telegraph Road maybe?
It's certainly not what it was. You do get the occasional good thread but they are getting fewer and farther between. True, it's still my go to place for advice but for entertainment or a gentle bit of time wasting, no. I pop in now and again from the office but very rarely from home.
Can't put my finger on what it is, maybe it has just run it's course.
>Politics/religion/any other big argument doesn’t bother me because I stop reading when I get bored
+1
>Well, with the greatest respect kind sir, I think this place is about the most respectful internet forum I’ve come across.
+1, in a league of its own.
>It does feel like people are contributing less.
Yep, site visit numbers might be up but the Chat Forum (only part I look at) is much quieter after the great cock up (upgrade) recently.
>Can’t put my finger on what it is, maybe it has just run it’s course.
Self feeding cycle, people post less, so less to respond to, so you come here less frequently and post less etc. Making the whole forum unusable for a month or more was an interesting business decision.
Making the whole forum unusable for a month or more was an interesting business decision.
Intentional. The word you're looking for is intentional. It's all going according to plan. Apparently.
I'm not convinced traffic is up. IIRC the one day Mark referred to as being "the busiest ever" was also the day that The Beast From The East hit. Far be it from me to suggest there just might have been a correlation.
You must take into account the term “busiest ever” and 1.5m views per month... because those figures are misleading, thay maybe true, misleading by intimating that it is a common everyday occurrence.
The forum isn’t STW, it’s a sub segment. The main site page will have views and impressions, these can be identified are recurring (same user) or single impression.. stretch that out to the forum segment and there will be a log of all current users logged in, and unique visits.
So, add both together and you may indeed hit those figures once, maybe three times a month.. but in plain view are the post count on the forum alone and we do single this out because we use this segment most. We all know posts are down, users we know and have known for some time are no longer here. Few posters are new and we see threads last longer without response.. views we have no idea and can only speculate on the amount of folks that pop in, get pop ups or redirects or other forum issues then leave immediately.. Yes they may come back to see if it’s all clear, so another impression, but if they get hit again that’s pretty much it for thier UX.
Seasoned posters hang around a lot longer obviously, but even those are thin on the ground lately.. we can only speculate as to whether it’s the forum issues or they’re just bored.
Make your own informed decision on that.
Unusable for a month but some how people are/were still posting. Seems unusable is bit of an exaggeration.
Having said that, no one has been able to tell me what the theme tune to mine heist on Netflix keeps reminding me of.
Do you mean Money Heist? The Spanish one? I' watching it now but it doesn't seem to have a theme tune. Or is it at the end?
Unusable for a month but some how people are/were still posting.
Nothing like a healthy dose of sarcasm to keep your more respected long term subs paying forum members happy, eh Drac?
😉
<div class="bbp-reply-author">shermer75
<div class="bbp-author-role">
<div class="">Member</div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="bbp-reply-content">Having said that, no one has been able to tell me what the theme tune to mine heist on Netflix keeps reminding me of.
</div>
<div class="bbp-reply-content">
Do you mean Money Heist? The Spanish one? I’ watching it now but it doesn’t seem to have a theme tune. Or is it at the end?
Yes, I do mean Money Heist. Opening credits as the lyrics start. I feel like there needs to be one extra note and then it would be something else. It's really bugging me.
</div>
>Nothing like a healthy dose of sarcasm to keep your more respected long term subs paying forum members happy, eh Drac?
They quite clearly don't give a shit about forum members, they're just chasing the 1.5m random bods who browse a page, see 234 random ads / 67 pop ups and then go somewhere else thinking 'WTF was that?'. I assume they somehow get money from that and it's the new business model.
I subscribe £12 per year to a motorcycle forum (BMW).
Now that is a lively place.
No swear filter and lots of banter.
Sections for touring, technical, for sale, and The Pub amongst others.
Yes it has frequent posters and lurkers. I'm probably in the middle.
Easy to post, quote, link and upload pictures.
Nearly a picture to every post!
This forum is absolutely fantastic. Knowledge, humour, empathy, dignity, sympathy, innovation, all mixed in with ignorance, apathy, small-mindedness, anger, regret, aggression and idiocy.
To me it's a fair representation of the human condition. At the end of the day it's a bunch of people of all ages, backgrounds, experiences and beliefs (assuming of course that they are all Audi driving, IT middle managers from Woking) thrown together as a result of their love for (occasionally hatred of) mountain biking.
It's made me laugh so hard I've spilt my tea/beer/pina colada on the keyboard, so angry I've put my size 12 through the screen and sent Chipps the bill, sad enough I've occasionally found the room getting a trifle dusty and surprisingly often its made me feel good about people and humanity in general. There's also been a lot of good advice, some of which I've taken onboard. And I've learnt a fair bit about bikes along the way too.
I really, really hope that it has many, many years to go and that the characters, personalities and Lings that make it what it is continue to do so.
I really hope this place gets back to what it was but they've got their work cut out.
The rollout was a total **** up, there's no other way to describe it. That pushed people away (I don't believe user numbers).
The new version may be responsive / mobile friendly but it wasn't that bad before but it now comes with ads everywhere* (gotta make money, get it), that it feels really clunky, especially with poor page load speeds.
> don't show people a message saying they're not logged in without putting a login link in the message <
That said, for advice and general politeness, this place is hard to beat, even if it is heavily populated with audi driving, orange riding, quinoa eating Guardian readers.
* I don't use an ad blocker because I'm interested in how different brands use different formats and approaches
I’ve just visted. MTBR for a quick look, I think I probably have signed up years ago. Seems there really is 130 different forums to post on, loads of ads especially that wide banner on the right. Loved the retro 90s look off the forum layout and font style though.
> don’t show people a message saying they’re not logged in without putting a login link in the message <
This.
It's the simple things. It's really not that difficult (only it seems that it is for STW). I wonder if there have been some personnel changes within the web team at STW. The intuitive usability of the site, which always seemed to be a conscious focus just seems to have evaporated. Make it easy to use or unless compelled, people won't use it.
My work offer remote access to network drives via VPN, and would prefer everyone to store their work there rather than on Dropbox et al. However, half the time the VPN is as slow as this site, and the other half the time you need to work on a file with an external collaborator and simple file shares don't allow that. So, despite us having a nice secure in-house set up, because it's a PITA to use, we still all use dropbox.
Loved the retro 90s look off the forum layout and font style though
Yeah, me too. It's good to see some things aren't changed just for the sake of it.
They must have some proper high-end techies working on their site though, what with having a "last post" column
Screw the last post functionality.
I want spam statistics and to know when to say happy birthday to strangers on the internet.
Yup but after 17 hours I’d struggle to remember who posted last DezB so that is a handy feature.
Yup but after 17 hours I’d struggle to remember who posted last DezB so that is a handy feature.
Are you missing the point or ignoring it?
This forum is absolutely fantastic. Knowledge, humour, empathy, dignity, sympathy, innovation, all mixed in with ignorance, apathy, small-mindedness, anger, regret, aggression and idiocy.
Spot on.
And I agree the entertainment value has dropped off a bit, I try to keep it light and fun (when I'm not debating the merits of tyres or flaming Tory ****wits), but there seem to be fewer contributors with the same attitude recently.
Still nowhere quite like it for obscure tech Qs or route inspiration though.
I've just had a speculative mooch of the non-forum part of this website. Reviews of £1500 wheels, £6000 bikes. Quite a niche target audience for that? I don't imagine that even a high percentage of enthusiastic mountain bikers would consider spending that much money. Certainly not going to attract the average person thinking about taking up the sport.
Are you missing the point or ignoring it?
Just being his usual hilarious self 😆
Are you missing the point or ignoring it?
None of the above.
I used to be on Rotorburns a lot. It was just like here but with swearing and rude pictures.
Now it is really dead. Shame.
I now get my rude pictures and jokes on the chat bit of a motorbike forum that is mostly full of racist arseholes.
The actual motorbike bit is quite good for the adventure stuff.
They must have some proper high-end techies working on their site though, what with having a “last post” column
Poor DezB trying to get another laugh from the same joke.
Cycling UK Forum is ok, but can be a joyless place - no fish puns in techy threads, be warned! A few of the more genuinely knowledgeable people from here are regulars.
MTBR - Too American. The level of blind fanboi obsession and the constant push for the new is wearing.
YACF has lots of useful info, crossover with the Cycling UK crowd, but feels less formal.
Retrobike seems fun.
Not tried any others.
Apart from here I'm on YACF, Bearbones and bikepacking.net.
YACF feels quite Audax oriented.
BB and bikepacking.net are obviously bikepacking oriented.
Only really dip in to MTBR if a search takes me there, as noted above 130 sub-forums is daft: I'm surprised there isn't a handlebars sub-forum (maybe there is). Cycling Uk is another one that I'll only really visit via search - hmm six sub-forums for classifieds. 😉
The question is, do any of the other forums repeatedly, give you the chance to win an Amazon voucher or new phone?😀
According to a post the other day MTBR does.
[i]CountZero wrote:[/i]
Still, if you want to know what tyres for 29er gravel fat bike ridden in the state of Arizona, they’ll be someone there to tell you.
Pretty sure someone would be along to advise on here if asked…
Do they make fat 29er Conti Vert Pros?
You don't get the same mix of humour and pedantry anywhere else.
Most of those that have left I really miss, for various reasons. Some I'm glad have gone.
Maybe a clearout of regulars would freshen the place up a bit? I know I've posted nothing new since 2016, I've run out of fish puns and struggle for new tunes on the association thread. 🙂
Sadly, we're losing the technical knowledge and practical hard won experience too, the depth and breadth of which I've not found anywhere else.
Of course, this game better with as many players as possible and current functionality is affecting forum usage.
I don't know how this usually plays out on other forums, but it will be interesting to see the state of play once the dust's settled.
All a bit sad really.
I’ve run out of fish puns
You shoulda had a couple in reserve.
You shoulda had a couple in reserve.
Well, there's coelacanth, but I'll doubt I'll elver get the chance to use it now.
I’ve run out of fish puns
Brill.
I"ve been on many forums in the past, both cycling and non-cycling. This was and still is the best. TBH the main thing detracting from it is the loud and disproportionate whining of a vocal few about stuff that isn't really a problem. Whilst they are easy to ignore I'm becoming somewhat bored of the constant whinging and as a result have been here less often recently. It's like when you get a miserable grumpy sod at a party who doesn't like everyone else having a good time so they do their best to ruin it for everyone else. It's very sad.
...and then there’s those who open threads simply to whinge about the whingers. Probably the same people who “reply all” asking people to stop replying all
It's the people moaning about the moaners I just don't get....
somewhat bored of the constant whinging
Quality whinge about whinging there. I'll be in the kitchen at this party.
The classifieds certainly seem quieter these days... but they do on bike radar too
