[Closed] Is this racist and if so, why?

Yes.

I could tell you why, but I'd rather wait for the stw moral bastion that is elfin.

Pretty borderline. It uses a stereotype - "black men are called winston" and its implied that that means white men can no longer use Winston as a name as it has lost its value.

Not worth getting hot under the collar about tho

I think even Elfin can see that it is partly mocking the educational standards today and partly mocking the habit of the lower socio-economic groups to latch onto particular names or brands in a way that the higher echelons of society don't. Hence it is mocking the social injustices of the British society.

Or is that just my interpretation?

EDIT - TJ immediately assumes that if someone isn't white they are black* - does that make him racist or just a lazy thinker? 😉

*I was brought up to think the opposite of white is yolk.

It's about a racist as my son's Bindi-gate incident.

No,

Loose stereotyping, an observation based on race, but as it's neither derogatory nor inferring superiority for any race I wouldn't call it racist.

Were traditional white names such as Winston not adopted by the immigrating Afro-Caribbean community as a means of ingratiating themselves with the locals?

I think we have to distinguish between accepting differences and negative racial stereotyping. The fact that Winston has been perceived as adopted as a name by some ethnic groups is neither positive or negative so I am inclined to agree that it is not racist.

Its borderline IMO, you could take offence, but you'd have to work at it.

And i'd argue that the posho's are just as likely to latch on to certain names and brands, just different ones.

It uses a stereotype - "black men are called winston" and its implied that that means white men can no longer use Winston as a name as it has lost its value.

Former: agreed it's a stereotype but as it's nt necesarily negative then it's not necessarily racist.

Latter: I think you've inferred that...to me it's not necessarily implied in the joke....RACIST! 😀

It uses a stereotype - "black men are called winston"

That's not really what it's saying though is it, the stereotype here is more "people called Winston are black."

I don't really hold with the Daily Mail attitude that you're automatically being x-ist as soon as you point out any difference between two demographics. I don't really think we need to be reaching for the pitchforks for a joke that hinges on someone in history having an unusual name. Is it any different to saying "Why was Bruce Lee famous? Because he was the last non-Australian to be called Bruce"?

Incidentally, racist or not, I'm struggling to think of a famous white Winston other than Churchill, so it's not wholly outrageous. The only other Winstons that leap to mind are Zedemore in Ghostbusters and a Lenny Henry character.

[i] but you'd have to work at it.[/i]

Ah, so on STW it will definitely be racist!

It's a joke way past it's stereotypical sell by date - I've never met a black man called Winston, the only Winstons that spring to my mind are Churchill, Smith and my old schoolfriend Becky's cat.

Which was a big fat tabby BTW...

What about Winston Cadogo?

you could take offence, but you'd have to work at it.

It's the sort of throwaway nonsense that people get outraged by on behalf of someone else. If anyone -were- to take offence, I'd say they were almost certainly white(*); I doubt very much that a black person, even one caled Winston, would find that offensive (and if they did I'd suggest they M/WTFU).

(* - ooh, meta-racism)

Whilst on the subject, anyone know the history of the name Delroy?
Historically seemed to be a popular black name, but I was wondering where it originated?

and partly mocking the habit of the lower socio-economic groups to latch onto particular names or brands in a way that the higher echelons of society don't

Oh yes they do.

Racist? Marginal IMO. It's stereotyping based on race though not inherently negative.

and my old schoolfriend Becky's cat.

Which was a big fat tabby BTW...

Was it black?

my old schoolfriend Becky's cat.

Which was a big fat tabby BTW...

Ah, but was it a black tabby?

What about Winston Cadogo?

Who?

*high-fives tree-magnet*

Not worth getting hot under the collar about tho

Not worth you getting hot under the collar about, or not worth anyone else getting hot under the collar about? Who should not be getting hot under the collar?

Whilst on the subject, anyone know the history of the name Delroy?
Historically seemed to be a popular black name, but I was wondering where it originated?

Google says it's French.

What about Winston Cadogo?
Who?

You Winston, you loose some.

[quote=TSY]ingratiating
did you mean that or did you mean integrating?

What about Winston Cadogo?

Who?

Winston Cadogo (sp) was a character from a sketch on Not the Nine o'clock News which involved an overly racist Policeman called Constable Savage.

on a different note. one of my black work mates met one of my black friends and when my mate introduced himself as leroy my work mate laughed and said couldnt your parents think of a name so just gave you a black name

now is that racist ? 😉

Charlie - either, or... your point?

It's contextual.
It's ok on here, or in a round of jokes at a dinner party, because we all understand that there's nothing malicious meant by it, but if it was said in the pub, then it could be easily overheard by a workman having a beer, and it might reinforce any racial stereotypes or prejudices he held.

and partly mocking the habit of the lower socio-economic groups to latch onto particular names or brands in a [s]way that[/s] [u]different way to[/u] the higher echelons of society[s] don't[/s]

That's more like it, Tarquin.

Isn't that Dr on TV who does all the genetics and children programs called Winston?

Not sure but trying to think of other Winstons

[i] it could be easily overheard by a workman having a beer, and it might reinforce any racial stereotypes or prejudices he held.[/i]

Er, so, cos [i]he's[/i] racist, then the joke is?

That's Robert Winston you're thinking of.

Er, so, cos he's racist, then the joke is?

Keep up at the back. This is exactly why Sacha Baron Cohen hates Jews.

Charlie - either, or... your point?

My point? I wasn't making a point. I was asking a question.

I'm lost

One of our cats is called Winston.

He's black.

Maybe as an acid test I need to show him a cigar and a car. If he smokes the cigar I'm not racist, and if he steals the car I am.

😉

Okay Charlie... what was the point behind your question? 🙄

lols at Bez

well you would be desmond 😉 (see what i did there)

Actually I can't be bothered.

what was the point behind your question?

WTF? Why the Spanish inquisition? The point behind my question was to find out if you meant that folks were adopting traditional white names as a means of integration or ingratiation. That's all, You've said "either, or" and that doesn't clear things up for me, but to be honest I'm not that bothered any more.

Maybe as an acid test I need to show him a cigar and a car. If he smokes the cigar I'm not racist, and if he steals the car I am.

If he does both, then you must be in South London

[i]well you would be desmond (see what i did there)[/i]

Yes, you made a borderline racist joke. I worked hard to realise that.

there was a black woman on the tv yesterday, stating how because she gets racial and sexual discrimination she is the most oppressed of......

ive got no idea what the silly cow was going on about, i switched it over, thats not what i pay my license fee to hear.