Forum menu
Is it ethical or le...
 

[Closed] Is it ethical or legal to overtake a car thats going slow in a traffic jam

Posts: 341
Free Member
Topic starter
 
[#7283264]

So imagine youre on a single lane road and the driver in front of you suddenly decides to allow 600feet plus to the car in front of him, all while travelling at less than 10 mph, so you pull out and overtake much to the annoyance of mr pratt , who makes his anger known by flashing his lights repeatedly, sounding horn, shaking fist and making obscence jestures all at less than 10mph and then driving within 4 foot of your bumper.

Thankfully i was just a spectator last week but witnessed it again today.

What advice could the forum collective offer


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 8:53 pm
Posts: 1083
Full Member
 

If it really was 600ft then fair enough I reckon.

Do you mean one lane going each way, or a single track road?


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 8:56 pm
Posts: 18593
Free Member
 

He's going at the same speed with a bigger gap which requires less concentration, requires less stop start and wastes less fuel/clutch plate. I do it in most jams but accept that some people won't understand and overtake. Most however are happy to follow along not having to brake or accelerate.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 8:58 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

No probs with it. You snooze, you lose.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 8:59 pm
 lerk
Posts: 185
Free Member
 

So, Were you the overtaker or the overtakee?


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:00 pm
Posts: 66112
Full Member
 

I have no idea why you would tbh. Whther it's acceptable or not, I don't know, it just seems daft to do it, it's a big gap but it's not a meaningful gap


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:02 pm
Posts: 1
Free Member
 

Who cares who's right. It's driving hence everyone acts like idiots


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:02 pm
Posts: 50252
Free Member
 

a bigger gap which requires less concentration, requires less stop start and wastes less fuel/clutch plate.

600ft plus at 10mph? Silly. There's leaving a sensible gap and then there's just being silly. That's the latter.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:03 pm
Posts: 4732
Full Member
 

Nothing illegal, just what's the point?
Plus leaving a large gap means less stop/starting.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:03 pm
Posts: 5300
Full Member
 

No different to pushing in front in the queue in the supermarket. It's just rude. In fact I can't think of a single reason why you would, other than to look like a dick.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:07 pm
Posts: 3508
Free Member
 

Dunno about ethical or legal but it's just [b]Pointless[/b] IMO.

I do the 'leave a gap' thing to eliminate all the stop/start, but more like a couple if car lengths.

600ft is just daft!!


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:09 pm
Posts: 18593
Free Member
 

200m is a lot. I'd normally go up a gear at about 40m and rely on the engine management system to marginally increase speed and maintain/close the gap. I'm not the only one to do it in this part of the world. However, start-stopping and constantly sitting 5m behind the car in front is pointless, tiring and wasteful.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:09 pm
Posts: 8330
Free Member
 

why would you...it will gain you nothing as you the have to wait behind car infront

some people are just impatient dicks however..


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:10 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

600ft == 180 metres. There's a gap and there's interstellar space.

Smoke him.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:11 pm
Posts: 341
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Single carrigeway road one lane each direction 60 mph speed limit


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:12 pm
Posts: 19543
Free Member
 

600ft gap at 10mph? ๐Ÿ˜ฏ

That bloke shouldn't be driving if he gets piss off with people filling in the gap.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:12 pm
Posts: 18593
Free Member
 

Smoke him.

You'll be too far in front and getting smoked yourself stuck up the bottom of the car in front.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:15 pm
 br
Posts: 18125
Free Member
 

With a gap that large at that speed you'd kinda think that the driver is either going to turn off or doing something else as well - mobile etc.

So no problem with the overtake.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:17 pm
Posts: 18593
Free Member
 

I'd have no trouble with the car in front leaving a 180m gap if the accordion movement indicated the thing causing the jam were kms away but 180m in the last 200m before traffic light would be anti-social. You can often see the jam for kms ahead, what's the rush or the problem with a gap?

The overtakers can overtake though and rejoice in having gained a place in the queue and the right to breathe the fumes of the car they end up sitting behind.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:19 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

As long as you beat him on STRAVA then it's legit (douchebaggery of the highest order but legit)


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:19 pm
Posts: 46086
Free Member
 

"The moving segment"


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:26 pm
Posts: 5300
Full Member
 

The size of the gap is irrelevant really. You're still all stuck in the same queue. Very occasionally people do leave a gap that is perhaps a little larger than needed....by a fair margin. But people actually think it's OK to push in front?

For those that do, I'd genuinely like to know what you think you gain from it?


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:30 pm
 Bez
Posts: 7441
Full Member
 

the driver in front of you suddenly decides to allow 600feet plus to the car in front of him, all while travelling at less than 10 mph

Given the numbers, and that this is really about how it's perceived from behind rather than actual synapses in the guys' head, I question your definition of "suddenly".

I can't think of a single reason why you would, other than to look like a dick.

This.

It's all context dependent, of course, but personally I've grown tired (mentally and physically) of dragging my clutch and wasting fuel just to maintain some sort of expected proximity to whatever's in front of me, so I don't bother shuffling up with every baby step forward that the queue takes. It's not as if pretending to be roped to the bumper in front gets anyone anywhere quicker, so whilst an [i]actual[/i] 600ft gap would be pretty hardcore laid-back, jumping into a gap is just dickwaddery.

But yes, it's legal. There's no law against being a massive bungnut.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:36 pm
Posts: 39735
Free Member
 

Ive seen someone try to overtake an audi rs4 doing this in a transit.

Rs4 clocked him and shut the door. Car behind him shut th door

The transit was left looking like the dick he was for a few cars before he got back in. Oh how we laughed.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:40 pm
Posts: 7124
Full Member
 

What makes you think the overtaking was the cause of the anger? Perhaps it was something entirely different?

The guy being overtaken (let's call him Jeff, because that's his real name) was on his way to the vet with his dog, Buster. Buster had been a happy, bouncy, slightly manic labrador, until a few hours earlier, when he'd been badly attacked by a huge alsation/rottweiler/wolf cross with an owner as uncaring as he was irresponsible. Now, Buster was dying, in the back of Jeff's car, his blood slowly seeping into the seats.

Jeff turned round to check on Buster, but it was too late. Buster looked up at him, not understanding what was happening, feebly wagged his tail one last time, and then his eyes glazed over, and he was gone.

Jeff slowed down to just 10mph, his eyes filled with tears at the loss of his lifelong companion, remembering when he first brought home his tiny puppy, the times they'd been together, and how it had so needlessly ended.

Just then, a car roared past him. He glanced up - and saw that the driver was the owner of the dog that had killed his beloved Buster. Fury and rage overwhelmed him. Jeff is not a violent man, and so all he did then was to shake his fists. But an icy cold fury came over him. And he knew that he would not rest until Buster's death had been avenged.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:41 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I was in a traffic jam type queue last week - leaving a reasonable gap in order to avoid having to brake etc., but nowhere near 600ft, and probably doing 20-30mph. Got overtaken. I used my horn, but didn't act like a dick and gave him space to pull into. A few miles later, overtaker pulls off road on which traffic is queueing on, having gained almost nothing at all.

[quote=project ]Thankfully i was just a spectator last week but witnessed it again today.

So which one were you today?


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:42 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I, too, would like to know what folk think they've gained other than a single car space.

I think it demonstrates how personal some people take day to day road events. You're sat behind someone that is behaving in a manner you're not happy with and he's holding you up - 'smoke him'...!

A quick glance in the mirror and a "**** you" slips from your lips.

Done it and felt like a prick. Grew up and started leaving gaps.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:44 pm
Posts: 18593
Free Member
 

Further confirmation Audi drivers are... law breakers. You all know the rule, don't accelerate when being overtaken.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:45 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Oldnpastit - I'll have some of that shit you're smoking, fella.

A wasted talent there, methinks.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:45 pm
 Bez
Posts: 7441
Full Member
 

*nominates oldnpastit's post for "Best Written Article" in the Readers' Awards*


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:46 pm
 Bez
Posts: 7441
Full Member
 

Further confirmation Audi drivers are... law breakers. You all know the rule, don't accelerate when being overtaken.

It's just a Highway Code rule, you're not inherently breaking any law by doing it.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:48 pm
Posts: 6362
Free Member
 

200 yards gap is a bit big but the overtakee is still a selfish sod .
2 or 3 cars lengths would be in my book the sort of distance I leave in 1mph traffic eg queuing for lights. You never ever get close enough to the car in front to stop you manoeuvring round it.
As far as I am concerned, if you don't have your own blue lights flashing, you should wait patiently rather than save a few minutes.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:50 pm
Posts: 5346
Free Member
 

I've had the guy behind me overtake when in a stationary jam a gap of approx 4 car lengths appeard in front of me; I couldn't see the point of starting the engine just to creep forward a bit. He stared and shook his head like [b]I[/b] was the idiot as he crept past.

****ing tool :mrgreen:


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:51 pm
Posts: 39735
Free Member
 

Regardless it was funny- as i cycled past the ratrace clawing their way to the office getting steadily angrier with each


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:52 pm
Posts: 3900
Free Member
 

Further confirmation Audi drivers are... law breakers. You all know the rule, don't accelerate when being overtaken.

Especially while checking your very important Emails...


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:54 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

[quote=Bez ]

Further confirmation Audi drivers are... law breakers. You all know the rule, don't accelerate when being overtaken.

It's just a Highway Code rule, you're not inherently breaking any law by doing it.

Breaking a HC rule is usually good evidence for a careless driving prosecution though - I should think closing up a gap when being overtaken easily qualifies for at least that.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 9:55 pm
Posts: 1083
Full Member
 

Bloke up here just got convicted of dangerous driving for doing exactly that, although there was also oncoming traffic (far enough away that the overtake was safe had our hero not been a dick, before anyone asks ๐Ÿ™‚ ).


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 10:05 pm
Posts: 6131
Full Member
 

In that example I would close the gap if I was 40yrs younger, nowadays I just smile and say get on with it if you think you are getting your kicks ๐Ÿ˜ณ ๐Ÿ™„ ๐Ÿ˜‰ the road I travel regularly from Gretna to Dumfries is like whacky races most days!!

Just the other day I was in a bit of a tail back, lots of agri machinery about at the moment. Kia Sportage comes up behind me. I had clocked that amongst the lorries, cars, vans and tractors there would be little point in trying any overtake. Anyway, on the only long straight Mr Sportage decides to give it a go! It just happened to be his lucky day, he cleared all the traffic just as he hit the chevrons for the next blind bend having overtaken 10-15 vehicles!!


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 10:08 pm
 Bez
Posts: 7441
Full Member
 

Breaking a HC rule is usually good evidence for a careless driving prosecution though

In the context of inconveniencing a self-important bellend in an expensive car, maybe, maybe not. But in many other contexts, no, not really.


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 10:11 pm
Posts: 66112
Full Member
 

trail_rat - Member

Ive seen someone try to overtake an audi rs4 doing this in a transit.

Rs4 clocked him and shut the door. Car behind him shut th door

A trio of *ers, *ing at each other, it's so beautiful ๐Ÿ˜†

(I didn't know that was in the swear filter btw! You live and learn)


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 10:23 pm
Posts: 0
Full Member
 

So, someone leaves a massive gap, for what ever rule. Someone else passes them (Assuming no risk / dangerous overtake) and what do we have?

Who cares! One car is now 5m behind where they might have been, 1 car is 5m ahead.. Neither have "gained" or "lost" anything.

It's pretty easy really. If you are the sort of person who gets "upset" about being overtaken, then try and keep up with the flow of the traffic! (even if that traffic is stationary.....)


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 10:29 pm
Posts: 25941
Full Member
 

Depends on the driver who's leaving the gaps IMO.

If they are doing it to continue at a more sensible, steady speed then fine, but that involves allowing the gap to grow & shrink as appropriate.

I've seen plenty who just leave a massive gap and hold it even when the queue in front has stopped. Imagine if we all did that, the queues would be bloody gargantuan, and so those drivers deserve to be overtaken (and have their licenses rescinded).


 
Posted : 22/08/2015 10:32 pm
 Sam
Posts: 2390
Free Member
 

Allowing such a massive gap only worsens the concertina effect and thus the traffic jam.


 
Posted : 23/08/2015 7:15 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Just the other day I was in a bit of a tail back, lots of agri machinery about at the moment. Kia Sportage comes up behind me. I had clocked that amongst the lorries, cars, vans and tractors there would be little point in trying any overtake. Anyway, on the only long straight Mr Sportage decides to give it a go! It just happened to be his lucky day, he cleared all the traffic just as he hit the chevrons for the next blind bend having overtaken 10-15 vehicles!!

I used to do this when I had a powerful car, got into the habit of doing it even when I was in a Euro shopping trolley. Stopped doing it when I saw someone try it past a load of hay bale lorries doing ~20mph travelling from Hereford to Brecon during harvest season. There's a bit of road that is straight for a good mile but has hidden dips. The road did indeed look clear but there was a tractor hidden in one of the dips and the overtaker didn't see it until way too late. I didn't see the impact as they'd gone out of view but the noise was awful. Driver was killed instantly, rod was closed for a few hours.

Of the original Q, if it's one car and the gap is huge then I'd still overtake if there was plenty of space to do so, otherwise I'm happy to just relax and pootle along with everyone else these days.


 
Posted : 23/08/2015 7:55 am
Posts: 78473
Full Member
 

I'd probably take an overtaking opportunity. Not necessarily because it'd immediately get me anywhere with a queue ahead, so much as anyone who feels the need for a 600' gap at 10mph is probably going to carry on bimbling along at 10mph long after the queue clears. Plus if the queue is a tailback behind a slow vehicle, they'll sit behind it until the heat death of the universe.


 
Posted : 23/08/2015 11:18 am
Page 1 / 2