Not trying to scaremonger, but the leading edge of that looks a bit dangerous. I've seen a big chunk of a lasses thigh sliced off by the corner of a wing panel of a car that hit her, and that was one that was flush. Yours is sticking out a bit, particularly the lower corner. I'd suggest fixing that.
Could be an MOT failure for that exact reason too. Any sharp edges sticking out. [edit: beaten to it]
£150 sounds reasonable to me. Even if the wing is not replaced, it's compensation for any effort fixing it, the loss in value on the car, and the fact that you have to drive round knowing there's a big dent in it, looking like a scruff.
In fact just get a second wing and swap it, on a banger it wouldn't bother me if it was a odd colour. You might get lucky and find the same colour.
IMO she just wants a receipt as proof of settlement so you can't then claim it later on.
Just agree then email receipt for her payment to you in respect to damages caused and her payment satisfies you in full.
She paid and sent a really nice email apologising for the damage etc
Sent an email back received with thanks etc
some really stupid comments on this thread
if i had done that damage to someones car and they said just give me £150,iwould honestly be over the moon.
I'm really struggling to imagine how opening a car door has done that!
Did she repeatedly slam her door into your wing to do that?... Or is the wing made of cheese?
Driving one of these maybe?
[img] 
[/img]
I think you are lucky to get away with her paying up. Do a bit of googling and its more 50/50 fault.
Patronising mode - maybe next time you will give parked cars a bit more room
Huh?I think you are lucky to get away with her paying up. Do a bit of googling and its more 50/50 fault.
Rule 239 of the Highway Code states that motorists “MUST ensure you do not hit anyone when you open your door. Check for Cyclists or other traffic.”
I accept that you should try to anticipate someone opening a door but there's no way you can predict every time and it is not possible to leave a doors width on UK roads
FunkyDunc - MemberI think you are lucky to get away with her paying up. Do a bit of googling and its more 50/50 fault.
Patronising mode - maybe next time you will give parked cars a bit more room
wasnt possible if I had swerved out of the way id have taken other cars out !
Rule 239 of the Highway Code states that motorists “MUST ensure you do not hit anyone when you open your door. Check for Cyclists or other traffic.”
correct !
bearnecessities - MemberI'm really struggling to imagine how opening a car door has done that!
Posted 2 hours ago # Report-Post
cloudnine - MemberDid she repeatedly slam her door into your wing to do that?... Or is the wing made of cheese?
i was doing about 15mph when she opened her door
wasnt possible if I had swerved out of the way id have taken other cars out !
Playing devil's advocate for a moment,
If there wasn't room to pass safely, you should've waited for a break in traffic, no-one's suggesting you should swerve wildly into oncoming traffic. Really you shouldn't have been so close in the first place.
I remember being taught that on my driving lessons. I appreciate that it's often impractical advice, on our roads you'd spend half your life waiting behind parked cars and there's plenty of back roads where there isn't that much space even without other traffic. Point is, they could potentially have tried to argue that you were too close if it went to the insurance.
Bet it knackered her door!
At first I thought you were both parked and you were being a bit of a git, but if you were moving and she didn't look properly, it could have been serious. I had someone do that to me once when cycling. I went up and over the open door, bending it sufficiently that it wouldn't close. Few scrapes to the bike. She went ape shit at me saying your husband would go mad and didn't know she'd borrowed the car.....
I was too shocked to do much but ride away shaking my head.
If there wasn't room to pass safely, you should've waited for a break in traffic, no-one's suggesting you should swerve wildly into oncoming traffic. Really you shouldn't have been so close in the first place.
Or perhaps she'd parked badly narrowing the road available, so he was passing slowly and carefully? Round here you'd be waiting all day if you had to give 1m or whatever clearance when passing.
Here's to you bumping a posh motor or your car dying and costing you double.
Enjoy spending her £150 eh
Enjoy spending her £150 eh
I would only expect money I'd paid out for repairs - you're not doing her any favours.
Haven't read the whole thread as I'm getting dizzy with the moral high ground rubbish but looking at that pic, and this is a genuine q, is that wing not an mot failure due to bits sticking out which may cause harm to ped's. If not a failure at least an advisory. ❓
some really stupid comments on this thread
if i had done that damage to someones car and they said just give me £150,iwould honestly be over the moon.
^ this. To me, if someone damages your car, you should be compensated to the cost of repairing the car to the condition prior to the accident...it you don't want to get the car repaired and are happy to drive around with a damaged car then thats your prerogative but that still doesn't mean you shouldn't be entitled to the cost of the repairs.
Fwiw I think the person who damaged the car got off lightly...bodywork repairs are expensive regardless of age/value of car
Why should you expect compensation for an incident which hasn't caused you any bother?
OP states he couldn't care less about the aesthetics of the car and wouldn't be using the £ for repairs due to this. He also suggests the other party may not be exactly flush as she couldn't afford it, which makes demanding the money even more strange IMO especially this time of year...
Actually no **** that let's hope for a world where we are compensated with money every time some steps on your toe or bumps into you in the street....
So yeah enjoy your spending your hard earned 😳
My car is going into the body shop on Monday for a similar dent on the rear wheel arch - nowhere near as bad (just a dent, nowhere as deep, no cracking or paint damage), but same shape. I don't know how it happened for sure, as somebody did it while it was parked on a supermarket car park, and decided to leave the dent, some white paint off their car, but not their details. They must have used some force to do that to a stationary vehicle, because the wheel arch is reinforced. The chap in the garage used his Cluedo skills - white 4x4 letting its heavy door smash into it was his conclusion.
Cheapest (but recommended) place quoted £220, most expensive place quoted £336. I'm still bloody furious about it. Supermarket sadly didn't have CCTV covering that area of the car park.
Mrs Toast - Member
My car is going into the body shop on Monday for a similar dent on the rear wheel arch - nowhere near as bad (just a dent, nowhere as deep, no cracking or paint damage), but same shape. I don't know how it happened for sure, as somebody did it while it was parked on a supermarket car park, and decided to leave the dent, some white paint off their car, but not their details.
Seems to be a lot of it around. My wife's one month old car is currently in the body shop having it's rear wing and bumper replaced and painted after a lorry/bus side swiped it whilst it was parked. Unsurprisingly no details, so it's costing us £350 excess and increased premiums. Actual quote was well north of £1000.
I know it was a lorry or bus because all the damage is rubber from a wheel up to a height of about a metre.
Happened to mine when I'd had it 6 days. I'm still fuming now and it happened 9 years ago!
As OP said motor is a bit of a banger - One could just pull that dent out and t cut - happened to me once and I told the bloke in question 'no drama' and to be more careful in future.. Said offender was really appreciative of my chilled approach and thanked me - in the grand scheme of things we all need to be more understanding of one another - One of the few advantages of running old bangers I'd say .. No sense in taking car to an insurance brokers body shop and putting a shiny new panel worth a grand - that's more than the value of the car ... It's our 'sue me' culture that ultimately drives up insurance premiums ..
I had exactly the same when a lady went into my bumper. Offered to settle out of insurance. She would only pay the bodyshop doing the work in the end, to "prove" it had been done and i'd not kept the money and left the bumper. Work cost £160.
Insurance would have put a new bumper on it and she'd have lost her no claims.
I ended up taking a day off work and was without the car.
Next time i'll go through insurance, twas a right faff.
**** doing them a favour. Been here done this and for the attitudes shown in this thread for folk against you being paid and not fixing it..... Its your property that has been damaged by her idiocy so why shouldnt you expect her to pay - your cars now worth considerably more than 150quid less in value when you come to sell it! Thats why he should be entitled to keep the money and not fix a low value banger.
Insurance next time
Just stick it into the body shop and get it fixed . Youll be no worse off and yout car will be in its ore crash state.
Why should you expect compensation for an incident which hasn't caused you any bother?
OP states he couldn't care less about the aesthetics of the car and wouldn't be using the £ for repairs
Until it fails its MOT anyway.
Take the money dont get it done why should you ? She damaged your car so its worth less its up to you whether you fix it or not .
Until it fails its MOT anyway.
Maybe employ a bit of common sense and knock in any protruding metal beforehand?
But then looking at the pic of the damage it doesn't appear to be an issue anyway, plenty worse out there MOTd
Mot not due till next July
I'll be knocking it out tomorrow morning oh and my fee is £150 !
cruzcampo - Member
I had exactly the same when a lady went into my bumper. Offered to settle out of insurance. She would only pay the bodyshop doing the work in the end, to "prove" it had been done and i'd not kept the money and left the bumper. Work cost £160.Insurance would have put a new bumper on it and she'd have lost her no claims.
I ended up taking a day off work and was without the car.
Next time i'll go through insurance, twas a right faff.
Couldn't make this up, I posted this yesterday afternoon, did I jinx myself?
Out in town last night a car cut me right up from the right hand lane, scraped all down the front wing and bumper. She tried to drive off, then denied she'd hit me. On seeing the damage to my car and hers she then begged to go outside of insurance, she'd had a black box fitted to carry on driving, and had already gone through 2 claims this year. Then trying to give me details of a local bodyshop who would polish it out for £100!
As I sit here now I wonder should I go through all the faff of time off work, no car for 2 days again while local bodyshop does it, and the faff of chasing her for money, or just go through insurance and get a courtesy car?
I'd go through insurance on that purely because she's clearly a bloody menace.
Push for a courtesy car too.
Unlucky!
That's got to be a clear case for insurance though...for several reasons.
OP is clearly ripping the arse out of it. Whether that is a good or a bad thing depends on your morality. I'd be knocking a receipt up and giving her that.
all this reminds me of
"middle aged woman in a multi-storey car park, has seen a space open up and pulls past the space to reverse in. In the split second she is past the space, the bloke in the sports car whizzes into the empty space, jumps out of his car and as he walks away says "thats what you can do with good driving"
woman looks him in the eye, selects reverse and slams into his car
"thats what you can do when you dont care about your insurance premiums"
wanmankylung - MemberOP is clearly ripping the arse out of it
Hardly ! My time is worth £150 thats time not spent with my children/diy stuff enjoying the weekend.
unfitgeezer - Member
Mot not due till next July
I'll be knocking it out tomorrow morning oh and my fee is £150 !
😯 I think you should keep that to yourself... I doubt you'll get many takers especially at that price.
Hardly ! My time is worth £150 thats time not spent with my children/diy stuff enjoying the weekend.
If your time is worth £150 then the only valid economic decision that you could possibly make would be to take it to the place who gave you the £150 quote. That way you're up the price of materials etc.... You are ripping the arse out of it, there is no point whatsoever trying to deny it.
Not read all the posts but why not go get a proper quote. If it's more than the £150 then email her a copy and say after proper assessment the price has increased to £xxx and as this is more than you told her it would be and she agreed to pay then say you've just accept the £150 as loss of value for the damage if she is happy with that instead of 'wasting' more money to get it fixed properly.
If it comes back as less then be honest and say on second look they can fix it for less but point out you need the money before you will do get the work done in case she backs out.
You let people **** your shit up for free then george ?
It will cost 150 pounds to put right
Its up to him if he wants to fix it or not , but either way it will cost her 150 pounds to make it go away. (Or more down the insurance route)
Of course it's upto him if he wants to fix it or not and it's right that he gets the repair paid for. That bit that is wrong is the bullshit moaning about his time being valuable then not sending it to the garage to get it repaired. He's ripping the arse out of it. I'd be sending it through the insurance route.
taking it the garage means no car for 2 days
im not moaning btw
Got any pictures of this damage? Because two days in a bodyshop would get a lot of damage fixed.
try reading the pgs 1 & 2 from the beginning !
Reduced value of car at sale will be more than 150 quid .
Think of it as compensation for that then if your unable to be rational.
Of course could go down insurance and it will cost her alot more......and equaly him as his car will be written off
Reduced value of car at sale will be more than 150 quid .
The car is described as a "commute old banger " I'd guess the OP has a smarter car for when not doing the daily commute and this old banger is used for such so that any possible damaged caused daily drive would be of no concern.
The car has fulfilled it's intended purpose.
The value of a car like this would be based on its mechanical condition rather than its aesthetic appeal. No?
