[Closed] Would you buy on of these??

I bought one once... you're right, it is fairly useless... now resides in my enormous pile of tried and discarded mudguards, I've given up on the search for one that works and looks half decent 😆 I'll just deal with mud and assorted shite being flicked up into my face 😯

Didn't stop Steve Peat using one.

couple of guys I saw on sunday had them, seem to work alright.

wont be swapping my neoguard for one.

[i]Didn't stop Steve Peat using one. [/i]

If got them for free and was paid to use them I'd use them too.

You should see my home-made front guard. It's made from a bit of plastic reinforcing from a cheap give-away backpack a bit of old inner tube gaffer tape and some cable ties. It works though. I've got Magura forks and the double arch means I can fit it directly to those keeping it closer to the tyre than those moto-cross style ones. I've another bit of the plastic behind the seat tube and running from the bottom bracket up to the seat stay bridge which also keeps a lot of mud of my feet and my water bottle. Not pretty but effective and as I commute off road all year round I'm willing to sacrifice aesthetics for practicality.

post some pics when you get a chance