[Closed] What nice, steel hardtail frame?

soul...end of

Cove Handjob ?

You mean [u]apart[/u] from an Inbred?

Couldn't really go wrong with this could i?

http://www.on-one.co.uk/i/q/FROO456/on_one_456_steel_hardtail_frame_2011#basket

[s]or a 'normal' inbred.

on-one aren't really allowed to say this, and probably neither am i, but a 'normal' inbred is fine with 120mm forks.[/s]

i didn't see the price on your link, that's a bargain.

Ragley or cotic

For under 100 quid, you can't go wrong with a 456 at all.

They're not light, or the last word in modern materials and geometry, but they're solid and reliable and ride pretty well for what they are. And a 120-130mm fork is about ideal on them too, they can take longer but it relaxes them too much IMO.

Cotic Soul would be nicer, but gonna be more expensive. If you can find a Genesis Altitude in your size also, try one, very much like a Cotic Soul but a bit cheaper.

I have a Ragley blue pig x, it rides beautifully and is so adaptable with the 44mm ht and 30.9 seat tube. Most versatile frame out there I can think of .

+1 for Genesis Altitude. Love mine 🙂

I'm 6'1 would an 18" 456 be big enough?

Nothing wrong with an Inbred or 456 but they're not what springs to mind when looking for a [i]nice[/i] steel frame. They're great value, solid performing, honest bikes but nice? Nah. TBH I don't think either really rides like the idea you probably have in your head of what a steel frame is like either- lots of metal in them, makes them relatively stiff and dead-feeling compared to your Soul or similiar, IMO.

Speaking of which, that's what the answer is- a Soul or one of the Soul's very sincere flatterers.

vegman - Member

I'm 6'1 would an 18" 456 be big enough?

maybe...

i'm 6'1" (and-a-half), but i've got 36" legs (gooch to ground), and needed a very long seat post to get comfy on a 18" inbred.

if your legs are a bit shorter than mine, you should be ok.

thanks, I've got shorter legs than you so I've gone for it!

cool, please post some photo's on here when you've built it up.

(mainly so we can tell you that your lawn needs mowing / fence needs painting/ garage needs tidying)

inbreds seem a little bit old-school on paper, but they love a set of wide bars and a shortish stem, especially if you're man-size.

I have an inbred and have just got a Soul . The Soul is a bit lighter with a better finish but they ride quite similar but the Soul seems to be smoother and feels more comfortable fit wise for me. The 456 is a no brainer to be honest it is almost disposable at £99

Soul or Prince Albert.

Sanderson Life or Breath. Trust me 😉

on-one aren't really allowed to say this, and probably neither am i, but a 'normal' inbred is fine with 120mm forks.

They were revised a couple of years ago, in line with the CEN regulations. So it's now certified for 120mm forks. The 456 passed the CEN tests without modification at 160mm.

I have a decade virsa and am on my third frame in two years. i now have the beefed up version with a thicker seat tube (the previous two frames cracked on the seat tubes) and bigger head tube. its a great frame to ride with 100 or 120 mm forks but i would say the build quality and finish of the frame are a bit pants i.e. the seat tube is a sloppy fit (decent easton seat post) so the post creeps down and the paint chips even if you look at it funny. a shame and i kind of wish i had bought something else.

I have a 19 inch cotic soul with hope headset and qr seat clamp?

Rock Lobster 853 ?

Curtis. My S1 is a thing of beauty.

Just bought a Sanderson Life, it's pretty good.

ttf

Hi guys - looking to begin a new "all round" mountain bike build up

[b][u]and not horrific looking[/u][/b]

Duffer

You mean apart from an Inbred?

Do you see where you went wrong there? Same goes for you fd3chris.

I used to have a Sanderson Life, which I liked, but it always felt a bit upright and high when things got steep and rocky. Now I have a Genesis Latitude (after having a full suss in between) and I've got to say that for most of the rides I do I love it. It feels strangely controlled and comfortable in the really rough stuff, it copes well with natural riding in the lakes and the Peaks, and for North York moors type riding it beats anything else I've ridden. Dunno, it seems like a very well thought out frame for 'natural' XC riding, and for 'midfield' racing (I did the manx E2E and Hit the North on it).

If there's a downside it's that it's not as nimble and 'flickable' as other bikes I've had. I actually had to practice bunnyhopping a fair bit when I first built it up. My brother, who normally rides a spesh SX trail and a BMX, didn't get on with it at all when he took it for a spin round Lee Quarry. So if you're mostly into 'man made' riding it might not be what you're looking for.

I'm 6ft and have the large size it's definitely as big as I could sensibly go. Running 120mm Rebas, would work fine with 100mm though.

For reference I once rode a demo Cove Handjob and really couldn't get on with at all. One of the more disappointing bikes I've ridden. A lot of folk love them though. Horses for courses etc

Get an old Kona, it'll be better than all of the above.

Pipedream Sirius is a good choice.

I like the look of the Kona steely .

Ragley Piglet!

I've got a Genesis Altitude 30 frame (853 steel) 19" if you're interested?

Genesis Altitude is a nice ride. Light enough and covers the gound well for general xc type duties. Also pretty able on rough downs with a decent fork up front.

Get an old Kona, it'll be better than all of the above.

Erm, not if you want to run any modern kit on it. Good as they were, rose tinted specs need taking off methinks...

Anyway... Before I bought my 853 Steel Genesis Altitude, a mate of mine had not long had one. I asked him what it rode like... His answer was "like an old DeKerf, or a Steel Kona, only you can run longer forks on it, use disc brakes, and it's a bit stiffer"... Instantly sold it to me!

Only sold my 853 one (after 3 years of ownership) when I found a Ti version for sale very cheaply on here...

FWIW though, the Altitude does ride very similarly to the Cotic Soul.

I haven't ridden a Soul, but on paper they do look to have very similar geometry at least. Love the way Altitudes ride though. Lively on climbs, responsive on singletrack & positively encourages you to give it a thrashing on the downhills too. Great all round bike IMO... Just like a Soul apparently...

Went from a 18" 456 to a 15.5" Prince Albert and Im so much happier. Im 5'9" so was kinda inbetween the 16" and 18" 456. All in all think the PA is a better frame and looks better in either green or orange , also the little gimmicks of being able to spin the quick release on the rear end is cool.
A few of my mates have Cotics and they look nice but whether they justify the extra coin I'm not so sure.

Went from a 18" 456 to a 15.5" Prince Albert and Im so much happier. Im 5'9" so was kinda inbetween the 16" and 18" 456. All in all think the PA is a better frame and looks better in either green or orange , also the little gimmicks of being able to spin the quick release on the rear end is cool.
A few of my mates have Cotics and they look nice but whether they justify the extra coin I'm not so sure.

[i]I've got a Genesis Altitude 30 frame (853 steel) 19" if you're interested? [/i]

I might be. Care to send me some pics and info on condition?

Still very much smitten with my Cotic, from a price perspective I'm very happy that I went that extra mile.

I had an 853 Explosif, great bike, but not as good all rounder as my Soul.

Def worth a test ride, the geometry just seems right. Most people that through a leg over it say the same thing.

This one...[IMG] [/IMG][/img]

Hummingbird:

[url= http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6095/6307046316_5379a43b14.jp g" target="_blank">http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6095/6307046316_5379a43b14.jp g"/> [/img][/url]
[url= http://www.flickr.com/photos/udder/6307046316/ ]Hummingbird[/url] by [url= http://www.flickr.com/people/udder/ ]bent udder[/url], on Flickr

Just really nice angles. Does gears and singlespeed. Perfect handling at 120mm. Also has a rigid 29er fork option, which is very pleasant as well. It's very adaptable, in short - which you either will or will not be looking for. If I had to sell all but one bike, I'd be keeping the Singular. Or maybe plumping for the Ti version...

[url= http://www.singularcycles.com/news/ ]Sam[/url] may have a few left in your size at £260, but if not, I hear rumours of a new version in the works.

That said, Cotic Soul is a smasher. And if you want to go custom, a custom Curtis looks (and I imagines rides) AMAZING. Especially in clearcoat - they are very, very nice looking bikes.

IHN, in work at the moment but I'll send you some pictures of the frame when I get in tonight. Cheers