[Closed] Road pedals: look or shimano? (sorry)

Have a look at Time's iClic system.
Recently switched to it from Speedplay and Shimano systems before that, and am liking it!

I have always used Look (using 9 degrees of float, red cleats) and have not had any problems, either with knees or reliability. I used to use SPDs on my MTB, again with no problems, but switched to Time and never looked back.

To be honest I never put much thought into it, I bought Look at the outset 10 years ago and have never seen any reason to change.

Time. (I actually have NO experience of their road system, just like their MTB stuff, and I'm feeling contrary.)

using Time RXS? pedals are now 4 years old and going strong. They use a brass cleat rather than plastic so seem more durable than the Looks i used to have

The Look carbon jobbies I used to have creaked like mad, binned them for dura ace spd-sl's far far better and completely silent.

Time iClic are serving me well, although the cleats need changing a bit more than I'd like...

I had look pedals and struggled to unclip with them. Switched to Shimano Ultegra's and 4 years later I am still very happy.

I'm using Shimano 105 SPD-SL pedals; I never see the point of buying fancier ones. Pedals get a hard life, especially in the wet and the winter, and 105s work just as well as Dura-Ace for a very small weight penalty. SPD-SLs are essentially Look pedals with more sensible walking stubs, so last for ages and are quiet.

I first went for Time RXEs, as I love Time MTB pedals.

I HATED the road pedal; I wore through cleats double quick, broke bits off of the pedals repeatedly and never liked the engagement. Replaced them with some entry level SPD-SL units and never regretted it. Now use 105s.

Had no problem with Look Keo's. I use Campag groupset on the road so Shimano would be a bit of a no-no!

Switched to speedplays.it's not so much the amount of float but how 'free' it is.Add in the double sidedness and extra cornering clearance and it's a winner for me .

I have Look KEO with grey cleats. The kids use SPD-SL. To be honest, the Shimanos are easier to clip into than the Look. But there isn't a lot in it.

Look KEOs on my fixed wheel commuter. Starting uphill. At a junction. In the rain. Can be "challenging"

EDIT: ANd be sure to buy cleat covers. Available for both Look and Shimano.

Cheers for the replies. I think Time and speedplay are out on cost really. Sounds like 105 shimanos are the sensible choice.

i-Clicks for me. Lovely pedals.

Keo2Max carbons for me. Excellent pedals, although I'm currently lusting after the KeoBlades...

I'm currently lusting after the KeoBlades...

I love my Times, but I concur with the above. 🙂

Shimano all the way. You need cleat covers with the Look ones whereas the Shimano ones last a lot longer without needing covers

I use Speedplay and love the amount of float.

Used to have Looks on the road bike, but swopped to SPD,s as you then only need one pair of shoes, also with SPD, the cleat is sunken into the sole, where as with Looks the cleat fits on the sole, making you walk like a duck, and theyre seriously uncomfortable to wear when walking even short distances.

cleat covers....do you fooook.

Used Looks for 15 years .....the first system and simply never had any problems. Cleats wear but no worse than any other manufacturer.

You can get keos cheap as chips now and their cleats are cheaper than shimano's

(the paltform is miles bigger than an spd and the shoes are miles stiffer -there's no comparison)

SPD-SLs for me (despite being a Campagphile) - all of the pedals work fine but for me, SPD-SLs have the advantages that they're reasonably priced and also that the cleats last ages because the working surfaces aren't the bit you walk on.

Keo 2s great choice great value.

Shimano for MTB, Look for road.

iClics work really well, BUT you can't service or re-grease the bearings. They lasted about 6 months.
Moved on to Look Keo2 Max now, early days but they seem OK.

just bought Time RXS as my first venture into road pedals on the back of using Time's on mtb - seem ok so far

If I were to do it all again I would have spuds on road and mtb.
Use Looks in the summer and they are not any bettter than the spuds I use all winter.
Save the cash and spend it somewhere you'll notice a difference
IMO of course!

Cycling Plus has a review of pedals this month, they like the Shimano PD R540s, I use them and as you can get them so cheaply (Ebay) it's worth starting with them to see if SPD SLs are for you.

Speedplays, even if you don't want the float they're still light, double-sided and have good clearance

and the shoes are miles stiffer

You use the same shoes for look and shimano cleats.

Shimano for me, zero float cleats, set them up properly, you only need float when they are set up wrong.

Been on Look for years, previously on SPD-SLs, I'm thinking of changing back. Shimano cleats last far longer, the bearings are better and the pedals don't creak/click, which both my sets of Keos do periodically! Look are lighter though.

Shimano for me, zero float cleats, set them up properly, you only need float when they are set up wrong.

Absolute bollox.

Absolute bollox.

Nah its not, but you go on quoting common myths learnt on forums rather than based on facts if you like.

The knee and ankles should track in a straight line, not wobble about as they move through a revolution of the pedals.

The knee and ankles should track in a straight line, not wobble about as they move through a revolution of the pedals.

Some of us unfortunately dont have perfect form and or injuries/bad knees. Having no float and bad knees is a recipe for painfulness, set up right or not.

Get whatever is cheapest or whatever you like the look of, as proved on this thread different people have different experiences (Mrs k has replaced spd-sl's which started clicking, I use time, didn't like shimano and time cleats last for ages, Look are fine etc, etc) so how your going to get a clear answer is not obvious.