[Closed] Lurcher vs Scandal weight?

I can't find the pic for proof, but I'm pretty sure that my On-One Scandal frame weighed 1,360gms.

Medium, early model.

Thanks Epi. I think the early models were actually scandium rather than bog standard aluminium. That's a light frame at under 1400grms!

I have both, not a lot between the 2 - the lurcher is a 'nicer' ride IMO

skellnonch - Member
I have both, not a lot between the 2 - the lurcher is a 'nicer' ride IMO

Then it must be very nice indeed. 🙂

My Scandal 29er v2 29er came in at just under 4lb...very similar to the Lurcher and I couldn't see the point in paying extra. Dirty Harry is frame to choose if you're after weight saving over the Scandal imo

Out of curiosity I weighed a couple on my Kitchen scales and the weights were:

19.5" mk1 scandal 1 1/8" steerer sliding drop outs 1680gms
19.5" mk2 scandal tapered steerer & geared swap out drop outs 1820gms

Mine has the track ends, so it looks like there's a wee penalty for sliders.

For comparison, I have a Kona Scandium frame with sliders and it's 1,860gms.

Dirty Harry is frame to choose if you're after weight saving over the Scandal imo

Not seen any "pro" reviews of the harry and only 1 owner review. ANyone ridden scandal/lurcher and a DH?

Andy that's ideal. So looks like a V1 Scandal is about 100grms more than a Lurcher and the V2 a few hundred grams.

Much as is like a Lurcher, in hoping I might find a Scandal cheap.

Yeah epicyclo sorry the mk1 is the "track end" horizontal version with the built in mech hanger. I much preferred the mk1 as it was a lot let harsh with a 27.2 seat post and just seamed to ride less harshly overal.

In addition to the bigger head and seat tubes on the mk2 it had those big extra long chainring bolts holding the swap out drop outs in place. I guess that's were the weight is.

I ended up selling both for a Mariachi, which was a much more comfy ride overall.

slightly different geometries tho aren't they?

Barely, DH is slightly longer eTT for similar frame size. iirc DH very similar geometry to niner air 9. End of day they're all xc bikes so not much difference between

Just looking at the weights above again, it appears that the V2 Scandal is only 80grms less than the new Parkwood (admittedly that's the 1900grm claimed weight).

So really looks like i'd be after either the Lurcher or a V1 Scandal (or a DH)

My vert dropout medium Scandal is around 1650g. Not heavy but not all that light either. Would buy a 1100g Chinese frame if weight was important rather than an On-One...

I have been thinking about a Chinese frame. I was originally thinking about running SS so horiz dropouts would have been preferred. I could run a tensioner if it came to it.

Most of the Chinese frames come in at around the same price as the Lurcher, but with the chance of customs fees on top of that. They also seem to have short ETTs for the size (or at least the cheaper ones do).

I have a look on ebay. Maybe someone on here has a Scandal or Lurcher in 19.5 hanging up in their shed they'd like to pass on 🙂

(off to search ebay before the missus gets up 🙂 )

If I were buying again then I buy from Carbonality. Lots of people seem very happy with their frames. If 26 is your bag then they used to have sub 1kg frames. Around 1150g seems like the lightest now in all wheel sizes at the mo though. I don't think anyone I've come across has been hit for import duties either.

I was convinced I wanted Horizontal dropouts but when the Scandal I have came up for sale with vertical dropouts I couldn't resist and actually get on very well with the Yess tensioner. If you go for a BB30 Chinese frame then you have the option for an EBB with 24mm spindle cranks if you really wanted.

The ETT is a big deceptive too some times since frames of different STA's and headtube lengths but the same ETT measurement will not fit the same. You have to take the full geo in to account...