[Closed] Hanger broken on commuter HOW MUCH???!

I've got a HT Carrera Zelos frame 18" you can have for £40 posted???

Isn't that what hangers cost?

£20 to fix a broken bike seems very little to me, at least you didn't wreck the mech.

£20 for a bit of cast aluminium seems like a **** of a lot to me.

I don't normally balk at stuff like this, but seriously, the cost of manufacture compared to retail is off the scale.....

[url= http://derailleurhanger.com/?ppcseid=2094&ppcsekeyword=derailleurhanger.com&mmtctg=68252477&mmtcmp=2480597&mmtmt=2&mmtgglcnt=0&gclid=COKLuOWm_qYCFYVjfAodFhyjbA ]These guys are very good and much cheaper than most[/url] but they're in the States - mine came in about four days though IIRC.

So what are your options?

That's what they cost. Crazy, but true. I'm sure they must cost pence to make. I wonder could they make them out of some sort of very strong nylon....y'know stiff enough to work but capable of bending? Meh.

So it's cost you £20 in 3 years and complaining. 🙄

well, if you could cast/ machine it for less than £20, good luck. Businesses have to survive, hence charging £20

well, if you could cast/ machine it for less than £20, good luck

Just looked and found that a replacment for my Merlin is 15 quid, so I'm in agreement that it's a rip off. I guess they can charge pretty much what they like 'cos if I need one, I need one and it's not as if I can shop around. Not keen on the fairly new practice of putting replacable hangers on steel frames, the beauty of having a steel frame was ( well, one of the beauties ) that you could simply bend it back.

well, if you could cast/ machine it for less than £20, good luck

One, unlikely. The 5000 they make, quite probably

I reckon you could get a small machine shop to nock one up for around 20. I'm sure it wouldn't be pretty, but it would do the job.

If a machine shop could do you ONE for £20, get them to do 100 for £10 and flog them on ebay 😉

^^^ Meant to say, I ordered a few from that US link I supplied above - they work out a lot cheaper that way.

If a machine shop could do you ONE for £20, get them to do 100 for £10 and flog them on ebay

I wouldn't even pay that as I have a milling machine. 😉

This boils my piss also...they are designed to be fragile, are really poor quality, there's about 100 different incompatible designs that are only slightly different.

The markup must be huge, as with tyres, cables, tubes, brake pads etc...I guess it makes the bigger stuff cheaper.

I do blame Thatcher of course.

Well, on principle, I'm going to find an old, incompatible hanger and take a file to it til it does fit.

Like I say, i'm generally happy to pay for most things on bikes, it's just this one component, that is DESIGNED to be sacrificial and replacable is so expensive. would be good if there was a standard among hangers so there wern't so many designs.

Yeah that'll teach. Grrr!

Not keen on the fairly new practice of putting replacable hangers on steel frames, the beauty of having a steel frame was ( well, one of the beauties ) that you could simply bend it back.

I've just written off my 456 frame because the mech stayed on and the frame ate itself.

A £20 mech hanger would have been a much better idea.

£20 for a component compared to the cost of a new frame? I'm not sure I see the problem.

I do, however, concur, that perhaps some sort of standard should be introduced. Not sure how this would happen tho.

look at it this way, at least it's replaceable. a built in hanger breaking (i have a couple of steel frames like this) would be considerably more hassle to bend back/have a new one welded on. £20 for something you'll probably (hopefully) only need to replace once is ok i think

Hangers prices are completely stupid. But I guess it's partly because there are so many of them out there that a bike shop may never sell some stock.

One thing I really like about the new On-One swap-out system is they are £9.99 a side and generic across their new frame range so hopefully they will drop even further. Would be nice if you could buy them for a reduced amount as a pair when swapping to track ends for example.

EDIT: if hangers were more reasonable I am sure more people would actually buy and carry a spare. I think a spare should come with most frame anyway.

if it's a trek or gf let me know, im sure i have a couple knocking about, my bikes are ss so don't need them

thats nothing the ones for my 07 stinky are 30 quid

(and that US company have got the wrong one listed)

the on-one bolt on hanger on my carbon 456 is pretty chunky - I was worried it would transmit all the force to the frame and break that.

running SS at the mo so it's not an issue but I might look at a bit of machining to weaken it beforeI put gears on it.

NickF
It's steel it will weld!
If you don't want it i'll have it:-)

£9.40 for a spare hanger for my Yeti 575....lesson = buy a Yeti!!

the on-one bolt on hanger on my carbon 456 is pretty chunky - I was worried it would transmit all the force to the frame and break that.

It will bend/break in between the mech and dropout. The wheel QR stiffens things up.

NickF
It's steel it will weld!
If you don't want it i'll have it:-)

Unfortunately it's not just the hanger - the whole drop out has been twisted and stretched to the point that it'd be too big even for a 20mm hub. It could be fixed, but it was cheaper to get a 2nd hand frame.

Anyhow, it's going on the wall as a memento of a much-loved and (t)rusty five years.