[Closed] Anyone use 23mm through winter?

Yes. Have done for nearly 20 years.
Currently our favourite reasonable reliable tire is Continental GP4 Season, with Vredestein Fortezza Tricomp Quattro as a faster alternative.

When I was a serious roadie, I rode all the while on 23mm even for commuting. My ribble just about took 23mm with guards.

Never had an issue tbh. I never longed for wider tyres.

I used 23mm on my Defy for the 2 years I had it. Fairly racey tyres as well, and never felt it was an issue.

...and some of the country roads near me are rubbish.

Yes. They slide as good as any 28mm tyre on wet/Icey roads..

They aren't 23s, but I'm very impressed with my conti gp 4 season. Very grippy even in slimey sludge, quite amazing how much you can push them on wet slimy roads.

23mm GP4s saw me through last winter, last road bike I had "back in the day" was 19mm all year round 😛

Super, thanks for the quick responses.

All the articles I have managed to find online almost make it sound like instant death is inevitable if riding in winter with anything less than a fatty setup.

I have done, they're fine. Schwalbe Durano's were my go to winter tyre in that width.

23 all year here as well. Never had a problem.

I managed to only just squeeze some SKS Chromoplastics on my Langster with 23s, did me fine last winter.

Yep, only had one off last winter, but that was sheet ice and would have been the same result with any tyre.

The new Panaracer Gravel Kings come in 23mm, these look very interesting for as a winter tyre.

http://road.cc/content/review/135369-panaracer-gravel-king-tyres

Yup never had a problem on my Defy for the 3 1/2 years I rode it (only size I could use guards with).

I've never ridden any other road tyre size, on account of my frame not having the clearance.

I don't skid in summer, I don't skid in winter either - no fuss.

I have a policy of not road riding on untreated roads when it's icy though - but I don't think 25mm tyres would make any difference there.

23s have been fine for me in the winter too. If you're out when it's proper cold be *very* careful - ice will put you on your arse in the blink of an eye

Never ridden anything but 23s, winter or summer. GP4000S at the moment.

My frame only just clears 23s as it is!

On a quick hijack, is it worth going fatter if you can?

I need some new tyres for my Defty (currently on Giants own 25c) and i have plenty of room for them or i think even 28c. Are there any benefits i may see from going for 28's over the 25's i have?

Every winter for years now. Never used anything else. Though I do use 25c on the fair weather bike!

If you're out when it's proper cold be *very* careful - ice will put you on your arse in the blink of an eye

It'll do that whether you're on 23s, 25s, 28s or as I've found out in the past, big fat mtb tyres...

23s all year round for me. Considering a switch to 25s now that you can get decent tyres in the larger size but that's for speed, not grip.

skiprat - Member

Are there any benefits i may see from going for 28's over the 25's i have?

generally, you'll notice an improvement in comfort* more than an improvement in grip.

(*but only if you drop the pressure a bit)

i don't notice that i'm any slower on bigger tyres, i do notice that it's [u]much[/u] more comfortable.

Thank ahwiles, sounds like it could be what i'm after. Speed is not really the issue, more making do with pretty crap roads!!

I have completely slick Specialized 23mm on my winter bike. Came a cropper on some cobbles once but I think that would have been the case regardless of the tyres.

I've used 23mm with no issues year round for ages. This year I'm on 21 tubulars and had a couple of sketchy moments but no real issues so far.

I always loved my Michelin Pro 4s which took so much abuse and yet had plenty of grip and speed.

As others have said - if the road conditions (or your riding) is going to put you on your arse, then an extra 2mm of tyre isn't going to make much difference.

I use 25's on the summer bike (Giant Defy) and currently have 28's on the winter Hybrid, however they keep puncturing, so might swap to the same 25mm Gatorskins as the summer bike at some point.